Discuss.

Edited February 14, 200817 yr by stenbeck212

I missed the pre-opening stuff but can somebody try and get me to understand why Lily i appearing as a spirit? SHE'S NOT DEAD!!!!

Hopefully this follows the continuity of the show because I like Lily and Holden together. That last part was sweet.

Edited February 14, 200817 yr by angel

^Lily is appearing as a spirit because their what if is if Evan did kill Lily with the syringe.

I loved the Lily and Holden flashbacks...loved their what if...especially the end....found it to be soo sweet...so romantic

Good show so far

Edited February 14, 200817 yr by Laurie

^ Oh thanks. I have to watch the show on CBS Video. So far its better than the X-mas show. I like Luke and Noah's but it would have been better if they kissed instead of hug. I know the people on CBS.com boards are complaining about that one.

Oh my God! Never in this life did I expect my favorite soap to do a scene at the intersection of Gay and Christopher! I guess that's as groundbreaking as the show will get, seeing as Nuke was deprived of a kiss yet again. On freakin' Valentine's Day!

Would it have been too much to show Noah and Luke kiss? I'm indifferent but even I felt letdown

LOL at Tom and Margo sticking their tongues out at each other and Tom spanking Margo's butt

Edited February 14, 200817 yr by Laurie

Was Gwen's band the Itty Bitty Titty Crew? I need to see that again. Tom and Margo ROCK. They could be the show's answer to Tracy and Hepburn in regular episodes too.

I can't even articulate the depth of contradiction in Nuke's involvement today. The show highlighted the Stonewall Inn, a historic landmark that gay people know like an old friend. That's like OLTL showing the AIDS quilt, seriously. How many shows SET in New York will do that? Yet on Valentine's Day, OF ALL DAYS, ATWT's signature gay couple wasn't allowed a peck on the lips. Before anyone says that they presumably just met in their fantasy - so did Will and Gwen in theirs, but they kissed.

Edited February 14, 200817 yr by stenbeck212

Another special show I could have done without. The best part was Nuke. The previews for tomorrow look good.

I get the anger and frustration over the lack of PDA's where Nuke are concerned. I really do. At the same time, I can't help but think some of us won't be happy until we see the two literally humping each other in the Snyder kitchen. (And even then....,lol.)

I get the anger and frustration over the lack of PDA's where Nuke are concerned. I really do. At the same time, I can't help but think some of us won't be happy until we see the two literally humping each other in the Snyder kitchen. (And even then....,lol.)

As I said another thread...Supposedly P&G mandated that Nuke have no more kisses. I read it on another board. It's sad. I am just eh about it. It was obvious Nuke wasnt going to get the same treatment as the other couples on ATWT.

As I said another thread...Supposedly P&G mandated that Nuke have no more kisses.

Then ATWT is truly following AMC's lead. Now that they have their critical acclaim and their ratings boost, they've thrown Nuke under a bus. You don't indicate the Stonewall Inn and then piss on everything it stood for as if nobody will notice.

Eh....ironic that I liked the Tom/Margo one best. (Well, not really, when all they really did was steal nearly verbatim from Adam's Rib....). The Carly/Jack one was okay, but it had way too much Katie for my taste (which means it included her in the first place.) I did like Gwen's song, even though I didn't dig the Willen one in general. Another "message" moment for Nuke...who would have guessed?

I've only seen the ToMargo one so far, and yeah, I loved it. ED was on point and SH was really funny as well, and RH/KMH were both very funny as the tough guy and ditzy blonde respectively.

I've only seen the ToMargo one so far, and yeah, I loved it. ED was on point and SH was really funny as well, and RH/KMH were both very funny as the tough guy and ditzy blonde respectively.

I agree...I think Roger and Kelley were hysterical. There was a moment on the stand, where Roger kind of tugged open his shirt a little more, like he was vamping for Kelley LOL.

Tom and Margo KILLED it! They made this episode for me, along with *shock* Meg, Paul and Emily. I only wish this couple could be a real viable romantic couple in real time. The writers are losing out!!!

Everything else sucked. And I thought Jake looked horrible in the location stuff with Luke.