I don't have to state my valid reasons for liking her, if you don't have to state your valid reasons for disliking her.

Because you have none.

Because you have none.

Much like you, eh?

I still flove ya, Sylph.

Edited July 14, 200817 yr by Y&RWorldTurner

Much like you, eh?

I still flove ya, Sylph.

Stop it, children, you're both pretty.

She is still employed at Y&R, as far as I know, but she's on "vacation", sort of.

Without a single historical connection on that show (and no, MAB doesn't count)...and now these 'grand vision' men coming in to muck up the works (Sheffer, Rauch, Racina) I am terribly concerned.

Racina sounded nice on the podcast I listened...but not so emotionally involved.

The prep he was given was the LAST FEW MONTHS of scripts.

That is not history.

I will reserve judgment...I always do...and I always give Y&R the benefit of the doubt...but none of this bodes well AT ALL.

I will reserve judgment...I always do...and I always give Y&R the benefit of the doubt...but none of this bodes well AT ALL.

Do you see me being satisfied by all this? No. So I don't know what to say to reassure you. Because, frankly, there is nothing to be said. With this type of management, the show will sink even further.

But I know you, Mark, you're the unshakeable Pollyanna. Always an optimist, full of youthful vigour.

Uhhh.... because nobody really checks those things out at the Academy, and FV/RC wanted to hook a friend up? :-)

Seriously, I have no idea. But I believe the number is 19% of the episodes. Which ATC still wouldn't have had enough of.

That's kinda shady. If you're gonna do it for Anna, you gotta to do it for Tomlin and Jeanne Ford too who were both credited before Anna.

How come nobody really checks? I mean, they don't have to check everyone, just those who joined close to the percentage. In this case, Anna wasn't even close, and that didn't raise a red flag to anyone? You have to accurate with this stuff! You can't just give someone an Emmy if they're not eligible!

So what am I suppose to do for my archives now? If I go by the official Emmy list, I gotta put an Emmy win for her, but I know she shouldn't be on the list. Grrr....

Put a symbol next to her Emmy win and at the bottom say, "Courtesy of being Valentini and Carlivati's Special Friend."

Edited July 14, 200817 yr by Y&RWorldTurner

So what am I suppose to do for my archives now? If I go by the official Emmy list, I gotta put an Emmy win for her, but I know she shouldn't be on the list. Grrr....

Did she win an Emmy? She did. So there's your answer. No matter how unfair the win, it's a win. You are not the one who decides who gets an Emmy, you only write it down after it happens.

Edited July 14, 200817 yr by Sylph

Also, you can write to the Academy and make a formal complaint.

Did she win an Emmy? She did. So there's your answer. No matter how unfair the win, it's a win. You are not the one who decides to get an Emmy, you only write it down after it happens.

And that sad truth just might provide yet another reason to diminish the credibility of the Daytime Emmys. As if the controversies over voting practices and nominations weren't enough, now you have these "non-wins."

Put a symbol next to her Emmy win and at the bottom say, "Courtesy of being Valentini and Carlivati's Special Friend."

LOL!!

Did she win an Emmy? She did. So there's your answer. No matter how unfair the win, it's a win. You are not the one who decides who gets an Emmy, you only write it down after it happens.

I've decided I'm not gonna give her an Emmy in the profiles.....for now. I have do a little more investigating here. I would icky giving her one when it was so obvious she wasn't eligible.

And that sad truth just might provide yet another reason to diminish the credibility of the Daytime Emmys. As if the controversies over voting practices and nominations weren't enough, now you have these "non-wins."

To win an Emmy is actually an emarrassment, not a praise-worthy feat.

The whole daytime industry is plagued with unfairness, one would be lost trying to straighten everything out.

I've decided I'm not gonna give her an Emmy in the profiles.....for now. I have do a little more investigating here. I would icky giving her one when she wasn't eligible.

And if you ever decide to give it to her, then you just have to put a note (possibly in bolded red letters) that she wasn't eligible, yet she won it. That's fair to me.

How come nobody really checks? I mean, they don't have to check everyone, just those who joined close to the percentage. In this case, Anna wasn't even close, and that didn't raise a red flag to anyone? You have to accurate with this stuff! You can't just give someone an Emmy if they're not eligible!

I thought they used to check, at least for actors. I remember back in 2005, Y&R gave Camryn Grimes a lot of flashbacks so that she'd have enough episodes to make the minimum, since she was just shy based on when Cassie died. Maybe the Academy feels it's too time consuming with the writing awards, with some of the "revolving door" writing teams that some soaps have in the course of a year, so they rely on the discretion of the shows to provide an accurate list? Not that it's much of an excuse, but that might be the way they think.

That's kinda shady. If you're gonna do it for Anna, you gotta to do it for Tomlin and Jeanne Ford too who were both credited before Anna.

How come nobody really checks? I mean, they don't have to check everyone, just those who joined close to the percentage. In this case, Anna wasn't even close, and that didn't raise a red flag to anyone? You have to accurate with this stuff! You can't just give someone an Emmy if they're not eligible!

So what am I suppose to do for my archives now? If I go by the official Emmy list, I gotta put an Emmy win for her, but I know she shouldn't be on the list. Grrr....

Yikes.

That whole "special friend" thing was a joke. I'm not trying to start any rumors here.

Anna's first air show of 2007 was seriously in December of '07?

IF THAT'S TRUE, then yeah. It doesn't make any sense. That's like less than 10% of the 07's air shows.

Toups, is there a way to see if she's on the ballot for ATWT? She definitely wrote enough episodes there to be on their ballot.

ETA: Oh wait, you can't. ATWT wasn't nominated. LOL!

But I thought of something else. ATC may have gone on stage and back to the press room with the team, but that doesn't necessarily mean she has a statue. I know the writers' assistants on ATWT went on stage (and backstage) with the ATWT team the last two times they won (I think it was '03 and '04?), but obviously, they didn't get statues.

Edited July 14, 200817 yr by brimike