Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

AMC: Rate The Characters Game

Featured Replies

  • Member

Thanks for doing this Steve. I'm looking forward to seeing how this turns out.

  • Replies 31
  • Views 702
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Member
All I will say at this point is that one of the ones you have mentioned is the one chasing close behind. The leader is not any of them. I think the leader will surprise some. I think so anyway.

Now this really surprises me...surely it isn't Jackson, Ryan, Jamie, or JR. I'm guessing maybe Adam (doubt it though) - or Brooke? Maybe she was only in bottom 10 once.

Nice to see Di most in the top 10....I'm glad most everyone likes her - I wish they'd take Aiden/Di and shove them down our throats (lol), bc I'm loving every scene they have, but it is way too little :(

  • Author
  • Member

Just a brief update. Andy all I will say is that poor Brooke wasn't only in the bottom 10 once. Me don't like that at all, but everyone is entitled to their opinions.

This will most likely be the last update of the stats before tomorrow's reveal. Votes are still coming in.

We still have the same 2 performers at the top. The gap between them is a little wider but not much. And the person at #3 is getting close to taking over #2. The early leader is still hovering in the top 10, but does not seem to be a competitor for Top Character at this point.

Lily is still the only character who has not been in anyone's Top 10 or Bottom 10.

Joining her as ones who have not made the top 10 on anyone's list are: Del, Jamal, Sydney and Winifred.

Joining Lily as ones who have not made the bottom 10 of anyone's list are: Adam, Erica, JR, Joe, Palmer, and Stuart.

Picked for #1 so far have been: Brooke, Colby, Danielle, Dixie, Erica, JR, Jackson, Kendall, Ryan, Simone, and Tad

Picked for #45 so far have been: Amanda, Babe, Brooke, David, Dixie, Jeff, Jonathan, Josh, Julia, Kendall, Opal, Ryan, Sean, Simone, Terry, Val, Winifred, and Zach

With at least 3 appearances in the top 10 are: Adam, Brooke, Danielle, David, Di, Dixie, Erica, JR, Jackson, Jamie, Joe, Kendall, Krystal, Myrtle, Opal, Palmer, Ruth, Simone, Stuart, Tad, Tom, and Zach

With at least 3 appearances in the bottom 10 are: Aidan, Annie, Babe, Brooke, Colby, DAvid, Del, Derek, Di, Dixie, Erin, Jamal, Jonathan, Joshua, Krystal, Marian, Ryan, Sean, Sydney, Tad, Terry, Tom, Val, Winifred, and Zach

Notice the ones who have appeared most in the top and bottom 10. Very interesting.

  • Member

These are some really interesting stats. Amazing how everyone has their own tastes and opinions.

Ok the Colby-Ryan-Dixie #1 fans need to come out of hiding! lol - Those 3 get bashed the most on this site.

  • Author
  • Member

I have loved playing this game, and will love the other shows when I do them.

All I will ask is that no one ask to have your votes redone. I enter these each as they come in - it is a whole lot easier doing it that way. So when someone changes their votes, I have to go back and undo all the other votes and then reenter all the new ones. So it is just easier. I got the last change and it has been made, but I would just ask that no more change votes. Thanks.

  • Member
Wow - I'm really shocked at some of these results.

First and foremost - Brooke. I wonder why someone put her #45 - and why so many people put her in the bottom 10! Is it because she's barely on and you're a newer viewer? Maybe this is why Frons won't use her....polls don't like her :(

Second, I'm shocked that Jamie was in lots of people's top 10. Shocked that Kendall and Zach were people's #45.

I love this though - can't wait for the final results. Keep voting people!

Thanks Steve!

Yeah, I've only been watching since April, so I haven't seen much of the vets. I like Mrytle and Palmer, but I don't even know who Val is and I've only seen Marion once. Needless to say they ended up towards the bottom of my list. Same for Brooke. I don't have much attachment to her because I've only seen her a handful of times.

  • Member
Yeah, I've only been watching since April, so I haven't seen much of the vets. I like Mrytle and Palmer, but I don't even know who Val is and I've only seen Marion once. Needless to say they ended up towards the bottom of my list. Same for Brooke. I don't have much attachment to her because I've only seen her a handful of times.

Yeah :( That's what I thought the case might have been...its ok! :)

Val was Erica's gay little assistant at Enchantment and I think now at New Beginnings...very small role - much like Winifred (except she's been on more lately than ever) - and I think the last time we saw him was during the spring.

Marian is Stuart's husband and Liza's mother - she is such a hoot and used to be on alot - she was a funny little schemer. Stuart has settled her down.

I just thought about this - but since Bianca is back full time and she's been seen 2 times already this year...she could have gone on the list. Oh well - we'll have to do this again maybe in 6 months after storylines change, etc.

Thanks Steve again - love it.

Can't wait for the results.

  • Author
  • Member

Okay here we go.

Some stats to start off with:

We had a total of 21 votes cast. Several had ties for 1st or 45th which accounts for why there are so many in those 2 categories.

Only characters to not be chosen in anyone's top 10 were: Del Henry, Jamal Cudahy, Sydney Harris, and Winifred

Most appearances in the top 10: Adam (16), Tad (13), Brooke (12), Erica (11), J.R. (11), Kendall (11), Stuart (11), Dixie (9), Myrtle (8), David (7), Opal (7), Zach (7), Jamie (6), and Joe (5)

Only characters to not be chosen in anyone's bottom 10 were: Adam Chandler, Erica Kane, Lily Montgomery, Palmer Cortlandt, and Stuart Chandler

Most appearances in the bottom 10: Terry (17), Josh (13), Annie (12), Sean (12), Colby (11), Sydney (11), Erin (10), Jonathan (10), Val (10), Jamal (9), Babe (8), Derek (6), Tom (6), Krystal (5) and Ryan (5)

Chosen at #45 at least once were: Amanda, Babe, Brooke, Colby, David, Derek, Dixie, J.R., Jackson, Jeff, Jonathan, Josh, Julia, Kendall, Opal, Ruth, Ryan, Sean, Simone, Terry, Tom, Val, Winifred, and Zach

Most appearances at #45: Terry (6), Josh (4), Val (3), David (2), Dixie (2), & Ryan (2)

Chosen as favorite character at least once were: Babe, Brooke, Colby, Danielle, Dixie, Erica, J.R., Jackson, Joe, Kendall, Myrtle, Ryan, Simone, Tad, and Zach

Most appearances at #1: Erica (5) & Tad (5), Brooke (4), Kendall (3)

Highest finish by someone chosen at #45 by someone: Kendall at #4

Lowest finish by someone chosen at #1 was: Derek at #38

Now to the results:

Number - Character - Top 10 Finishes/#1 Finishes - Bottom 10 Finishes/#45 Finishes - Total - Average

01) Adam Chandler - 16/0 - 0/0 - 201 - 9.57

02) Erica Kane - 11/5 - 0/0 - 236 - 11.24

03) Tad Martin - 13/5 - 3/0 - 243 - 11.57

04) Kendall Slater - 11/3 - 1/1 - 256 - 12.19

05) Brooke English - 12/4 - 3/1 - 299 - 14.24

06) J.R. Chandler - 11/1 - 1/1 - 305 - 14.52

07) Myrtle Fargate - 8/1 - 2/0 - 310 - 14.76

07) Stuart Chandler - 11/1 - 0/0 - 310 - 14.76

09) Opal Cortlandt - 7/0 - 3/1 - 347 - 16.52

10) Palmer Cortlandt - 5/0 - 0/0 - 369 - 17.57

11) David Hayward - 7/0 - 3/2 - 372 - 17.71

12) Joe Martin - 5/1 - 0/0 - 373 - 17.76

13) Dixie Martin - 9/1 - 4/2 - 386 - 18.38

14) Zachery Slater - 7/1 - 3/1 - 388 - 18.48

15) Ryan Lavery - 3/1 - 5/2 - 408 - 19.43

16) Jamie Martin - 6/0 - 2/0 - 419 - 19.95

17) Simone Torres - 4/1 - 2/1 - 450 - 21.43

18) Marian Chandler - 3/0 - 4/0 - 460 - 21.91

19) Livia Frye - 2/0 - 1/0 - 466 - 22.19

20) Danielle Frye - 3/1 - 1/0 - 467 - 22.24

21) Jackson Montgomery - 4/1 - 2/1 - 470 - 22.38

21) Lily Montgomery - 1/0 - 0/0 - 470 - 22.38

23) Julia Santos - 1/0 - 1/1 - 475 - 22.62

24) Amanda Dillon - 4/0 - 1/1 - 481 - 22.90

25) Aidan Devane - 2/0 - 3/0 - 482 - 22.95

26) Ruth Martin - 3/0 - 4/1 - 496 - 23.62

27) Di Henry - 4/0 - 3/0 - 505 - 24.05

28) Reggie Porter - 2/0 - 4/0 - 508 - 24.19

29) Jeff Martin - 3/0 - 3/1 - 523 - 24.90

30) Krystal Carey - 3/0 - 5/0 - 532 - 25.33

31) Del Henry - 0/0 - 4/0 - 556 - 26.48

32) Babe Chandler - 3/1 - 8/1 - 560 - 26.67

33) Tom Cudahy - 4/0 - 6/1 - 574 - 27.33

34) Jonathan Lavery - 3/0 - 10/1 - 602 - 28.67

35) Winifred - 0/0 - 4/1 - 608 - 28.95

36) Colby Chandler - 2/1 - 11/1 - 610 - 29.05

37) Joshua Madden - 4/0 - 13/4 - 677 - 32.24

38) Derek Frye - 1/0 - 6/1 - 678 - 32.29

39) Annie McDermott - 1/0 - 12/0 - 679 - 32.33

40) Erin Lavery - 1/0 - 10/0 - 682 - 32.48

40) Jamal Cudahy - 0/0 - 9/0 - 682 - 32.48

42) Sydney Harris - 0/0 - 11/0 - 685 - 32.62

43) Val - 1/0 - 10/3 - 701 - 33.38

44) Sean Montgomery - 1/0 - 12/1 - 742 - 35.33

45) Terry McDermott - 2/0 - 17/6 - 788 - 37.52

Just a few comments from me. For the longest time, Tad led this poll. Then he got the bottom finishes and dropped. Adam took over the lead and kept it from then on. For awhile Erica got within .41 from him, but never could overtake him. Kendall got within .21 of Erica at one time but could never overtake her either. Tad stayed down in around 5 or 6 for awhile, but rebounded and stayed at 3 for awhile toward the end.

I find it surprising that all the newer characters are at the bottom. They just have not caught on at all, and fans are obviously not happy for the most part. I am surprised that Babe did so bad. I was shocked that Jonathan did not make the bottom 10 overall. I am really shocked that he made it higher than Josh, who is not one of my favorite characters but I like him lots better than Jonathan.

Thanks for everyone who voted. Love to hear what you think.

  • Member

Surprises:

-Someone put Terry in their top 10. Either you dislike Lily SO much, or you're just a freak! :P haha, jk

-Someone put Colby as their #1. I'd love for you to post more often - I like how SON has people who love one character/storyline and others who hate it. I like balance :)

-Babe is so low. I guess I need to just separate character from actor. I know most people don't like the character, but I love her.

-Jamie had so many top 10 finishes.

-I'm actually surprised that JR is so high - as his character this year has been written like a madman maniac that most people aren't happy with.

______

I love our top 3 - Erica and Tad are two of my favs - and looks like they are everyone else's. Adam is popular too - just wish he had the balls he used to before Krystal got into his life.

I also wish that Frons, McT, and the TPTB could see these results and realize that fans actually love the vets (look at 7-10) - and that David isn't get-rid-of/fire material. Vincent is a gem - and people love David.

THANKS STEVE! :)

  • Author
  • Member

YW Andy.

I was really surprised that JR did so well too. I have not liked the character at all for awhile now, and that was even before I quit watching this year. I watched some with Mom as I said this summer esp. and I really hated him then. And from what I have read here, many did too. But he still did very well.

I was shocked too that Dixie did as well as she did. I was just expecting her to be a lot lower. I found it interesting that the 2 people who chose her at #45 were also ones who either put Zach or Kendall at #1.

I was also shocked at how close Ryan and Zach were in the numbers. They alternated back and forth for awhile with Ryan ultimately coming out below him.

  • Member

Thanks for the mini history lesson Always AMC. I wish Stuart and Marion would get a scene with Colby. I think a little time with Uncle Stewart would do that girl some good.

I'm surprised that Adam way number one. I like him a lot, but somehow I thought Zack or Kendall would get it.

JR was my #1. I was shocked he did as well as he did though. This game was definitely fun and interesting. Thanks again for doing it, SF.

  • Member

I love the top 10 characters. Please, Steve, send these results to Anne Sweeney at ABC and tell her how this poll was conducted! Maybe TPTB at ABC will see how far they've gone down the wrong road.

I'm not surprised that Ryan & Zach were so close since they've become the same character lately. Both of them kept the truth from their wives to "protect" them and destroyed their marriages (although with Rylee, I was thrilled that it happened).

I'm not surprised that Babe scored so low since she's been propped up ever since she hit town and she still hasn't paid for her past actions. I despise the character!

I am surprised that Jonathan wasn't in the bottom 10. I put him where he belongs at #45.

  • Member

--I'm STUNNED Dixie did as well as she did. I never cared for the character in any of her incarnations, but she's a shrieking mess right now.

--Adam is a pleasant surpise at #1. Though he's gotten a bit cartoonish over the years. I remember the days when Adam was a cold, cunning SOB that thrived on manipulation all in the name of how Adam Chandler wanted things to be. He's been a bit of a buffoon for some time now.

--I'm disappointed that Di did so poorly. I adore Kelli Giddish and have always liked the character. I'll take her over Dixie or Del anyday. But certainly over Julia.

how I voted :

#1- Brooke

people in my top 10 not appearing in this top 10: Di Henry, David Hayward, Livia Frye

people in my bottom 10 not appearing in this bottom 10: Julia, Jonathan

my #45: JULIA

top 5: Brooke, Stuart, Myrtle, Erica, Di

  • Member

I was alittle confused with the voting myself. I thought that 45 (highest) meaning the higher the votes the greater for the character. So mine was kind of wonky. But I doubt my vote would have made much difference in the poll. :P:lol: Thanks for doing this steve. It really shows how everyone sees the characters.

  • Member

Wow, there are more erica fans on this board than I thought. I thought there were more zen fans on this board or maybe they just didn't participate.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.