Jump to content

Do you think Soap fans of today are resistant to change?


Recommended Posts

  • Members

 

I feel like Kay Alden's run was really strong from 1998 - 2002. While Ed Scott's ouster in 2001 probably hurt the show a lot in the long run, because he was so strong and steady behind the scenes, I think David Shaughnessy was very effective. Once John F. Smith was appointed EP in 2003, though, things changed. As you say, from 2006 onward, good lord what's happened. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 20
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Members

I guess it depends what you are into. I know I have mentioned it ad nauseum, but the sperm caper story ruined three great female characters. It was such a gross and poorly told story, and was similar to JER's Days run. Fun on Days not on Y&R

 

Jill Faren Phelps said when she started on the show the mandate was to bring the show into the 21st Century, make it hot and blah blah blah. I am almost certain Kay Alden was pushed to do the same thing in 99/00, that's why we got that story. I think the failure of this story to bring in viewers and the loss Y&R suffered that year probably resulted in Trent Jones being promoted to either Co-Headwriter or Associate Head Writer. I have no solid proof this is what happened, but I am fairly confident Trent was promoted in 2000, his writing credit moved up just beneath Kay Alden and his wiki states he became a co-headwriter in 2000. He was definitely a co-headwriter by June 2002 when Jack Smith returned to the show as a 3rd co-headwriter. Which then led to Paul raping, I mean not raping, Christine. Kay/Jill being mother and daughter and a bunch of other stuff I have forgotten because I didn't like it. I was in and out until 2005/06 whenever the Phick affair was in full swing, then just gave up entirely. 

 

The true golden age for me (in retrospect) ended when Nicholas Newman was aged in the summer of 94.

 

For me Fall 1994 to Fall 1997 wasn't great, I have mentioned the Abbott family stories I dislike before. Ones I have not mentioned before though; de-aging Nathan then giving him a mid-life crises affair storyline, bringing on Malcolm and having him rape his sister in law almost as soon as he arrives, then setting him up as a sweet, tender and talented hunk. Victoria going from frigid to bearing it all for a national men's porno magazine with an absolutely lame reason "People change, Ryan" lol okay, thanks for that Victoria totally makes sense now. Nicholas in anything, if it were not for Sharon Case I would not have lasted, haha. 1997/98 - roughly 99/00 was a return to form, but it was short lived as mentioned above.

Edited by will81
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I think the bigger issue is the forcing of pets to the forefront. B&B spent years focusing solely on Hope/Liam/Steffy and IMO it was briefly great but then they had nothing else to rely on and when they did they ruined it (Maya and Aly) while GH focuses solely on the deadly boring quad whose names I won't mention. I think some people-audience and behind the scenes- become so attached to the pets that they become all the show focuses on. 

 

Y&R spent literally a decade struggling to build young talent while giving the same boring non suspenseful storylines to the older cast. I am still haunted by the horrible casting and staleness of 2009 era Noah and Eden, bad casting for Daisy and Kyle and other forgotten attempts. When they did find great talent-Ricky Williams, Ana Hamilton, Fen Baldwin, Hilary Curtis for example-they ruin or write them off. 

 

When the soaps try to build the younger talent it is so out of wack and unnatural that it is simply painful to watch. 

 

The other issue as I believe someone said above is that no one has CHARACTER. Every single scene is the same boring conversation for every character. No one is quirky, glamourous or over the top anymore. 

 

I would love to see one of the shows make a lasting change, become diverse and feel alive again but outside of a few good story months here and there I have lost faith. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

What kind of change though?  Because I feel as though most soap fans might associate change with taking something away, rather than adding something good. Many of these soap producers claim that they plan to make changes that will improve or restore the show, only to dismantle the few aspects that actually still work. The track record of most of the producers hasn't been that great. There have been some resounding successes but quite a bit of mediocrity as well and soap fans have no reason to trust someone who comes in and makes a boatload of promises and pronouncements. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

A good example I can think of is Pratt dismantling AMC but whoever came after not giving anything for the sake of keeping people at bay. Pratt had the show one event after another and then after summer 2010 through 2011 I don't think there was anything to offer. It would be nice if someone could shake things up just enough to build momentum and update the soaps but not dismantle the core of them. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I tend to have two minds about Tawny (Kathy Najimy) fainting during Soapdish's big reveal. You're the costume designer, if anything, you should have known the whole time. I guess it's an application of what TV Tropes calls the "Rule of Funny." Every time I watch Delirious, I always want the genuine romance in John and Mariel's reunion at the deli counter to last longer. Film critics had their knives out for Sally in this period. I'll start a separate thread on the movies page.
    • I don't think so, but I wouldn't be surprised if he was Dumas this whole time.
    • Tamara Tunie was serving up grand dame diva fierceness.
    • Nick told Victoria that he and Sharon had married in England.  Victoria was shocked.  Then she realized he was kidding.  He confirmed it was a joke and they're platonic. I don't even know what to say about that.
    • It's funny you say that because part of the entertainment of the trials on the show are all the day players who come on as witnesses and jurors.  I'm certain it was like the Law and Order of its time. It employed so many New York actors, that if you look close enough, there's usually someone vaguely recognizable in the courtroom.
    • I will defend Dante.  People already suspect he may be a bit unstable from time to time (from his time as a prisoner).  And, he's taking care of other people's kids from time to time.  So, he has reason to be cautious with those in his care.
    • Josh continues to try and milk Abbott/Newman rivalry. First it was Billy/Victoria, then Kyle/Summer, then Noah/Allie (that worked out well) and now Kyle/Claire. Do we have any inkling when Billy Flynn will arrive and who he will play? I'm sure Cole's illness will mostly play offscreen. What's in store for Nick and Sharon? Is it time to put them back together? I can't see any other romantic options. Nick has no children on the canvas to play off, as Christian is never seen. Sharon has only Mariah onscreen.
    • I would appreciate (if they're not coming), for future scripts to refer to them by their iconic hairdos.  For example, if Hope needs to call Chelsea because Bo has Sepsis, I'd like Shawn-D to say, "My Mom called Chelsea (the one with the sassy short black hair) for an update." Also, new rule, if Melanie does return, she needs to dye her hair back to red.  I googled who she was five times during Victor's funeral.

      Please register in order to view this content

    • Broderick, thank you for all of the info [I edited for space]. I am so grateful for everyone filling in the blanks for me. I suspected the Nora/Eliot scene was very important and it was setting something up but I didn't know what. Can't wait to see it play out. The two actors had such a great back and forth. I should have made the Paige/Patty Hearst connection. I thought Paige was in love with Brian from the first episode I watched but it seemed as if they were brother and sister. Steve kept being affectionate with her so I assumed he was the love interest. Then she was affectionate with someone else and well..she's a very busy woman. I can't wait to see Frances Fisher show up. (I'm trying to be vague because I don't know what would be a spoiler in this storyline) Now it makes sense why Draper would be upset. I didn't get the whole background of why he didn't go to NY. I'm a sucker for good acting, so I might still side with April and Margo, if the writers don't give Draper more to do besides yelling.  He had more chemistry with Logan, but I know that's not happening.  Something else I noticed: the show really takes care with even the smallest parts. The acting is superb. Too often, I noticed on older soaps they don't take care with the recurring or day players (Ryan's Hope was so bad with this that I couldn't make it through some episodes). It's only been six episodes, but so far, the casting department was spot on.
    • I thought Dante was overreacting.  Gio made some mistakes but he's young and he tried.  It's not like he dragged two 14 years to a party and made them get blackout drunk.  Dante can have the initial upset reaction, but to go on and on was a bit much.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy