Jump to content

"Brilliant" (ha) Youtube vlogger's video on why soaps exist.


Recommended Posts

  • Members

I hope this hasn't been discussed on here already during my prolonged hiatus...

I have a "friend" who has always mocked my love of soaps. He has never watched (to my knowledge) a full episode, but just knows that they're "trash". Anyway he sent me this video by some popular youtube nerd he follows who apparently explains "the unexplainable" to his hundreds of thousands of viewers--and decided to explain why daytime soaps exist to them. My friend thinks this proves something. The thing is the dude in the video obviously has never watched a full soap in his life, never spoken to a person about why they follow soaps (most soap fans follow them due to a love of the characters, not because they are constantly wondering what will happen next as he says), never bothered to wiki soaps (he seems to think writers write the plots a day in advance), etc, etc. The irony is this dude LOVES comic books (superhero ones which share qualities, good and bad--and I say this not being a fan--with soaps) and things like Star Wars spin-off novels. Yet he fails to state how the writers of soaps often DO love what they do and DO pay attention to story, how current serialized primetime is in many ways indebted to soaps, how it was a rare media form that was largely led by women (writers, exec producers) and, due to its largely female audience, largely mocked or disregarded... Or the fact that if soaps are merely an advertisement for soap that is meant to hook a viewer into watching commercials--well, that's what essentially all network tv was/is on some level.
 
Argh, I have no idea why this has made me so mad. But it has.
 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 10
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Hey Eric. Welcome back!

 

I’ve seen that before too, and his whole thesis is pretty naive and misinformed for the reasons you’ve laid out. But he just seems like a snarky, douchey, misogynist guy pandering to other snarky, douchey, misogynist guys on YouTube, so I pay him little mind.

 

It’s hard to mount a defense of the shows as they stand currently, but the genre deserves respect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

it's too focused on current daytime....obviously if you don't know the histories of the shows or all of daytime in general and how they had HUGE success for many many years, it's just going to be a mockery of the Genre.

I wish I could do a proper Thesis on why Soaps STILL ARE Important, and what primetime can learn from them, but sadly it's things like that video that are use to work against  those types of analysis. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Thanks Faulkner--it's good to be back.  And, yes, that's part of the issue in a way--you can't tell someone who isn't a fan to just tune into one of the current US soaps because, while I am sure there are worthwhile on at least some of them (I don't follow any right now), they would probably just agree with his video.  But for a guy who seems to think he's explaining the history of a genre, it's particularly inane--and as mentioned, misogynistic (there is zero comment about the role women played in creating these, or the fact that one reason they have been so ignored is because they've been seen as a "female" genre.)

I guess, even knowing my friend who sent me the video, I sorta expected something that would be more even keeled and would point out the (easy to find all over Wiki) historical firsts that soaps are responsible for.

I recently got approval to do my English MA thesis on just that--which has been a lot of fun and a lot of work.  I was lucky to have a couple of people in my department who, while not soap opera watchers, felt that there was some relevance to my topic and that it hadn't properly been covered.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Any fan of 1960’s era Marvel to today comic books should know that when those books sold extremely well they were steeped in soap opera storytelling tropes- including triangles, marriages, family dynamics and generational conflicts.  Sure they were written towards a different audience and format, but still soap operatic.

 

 As a matter of fact, comic book sales and the health of their industry has declined significantly, often in part of trying to be something they are not and loosing their core audience in the process, and that audience also finding other interests they cannot compete with.  That sounds familiar doesn’t it?  They also see what they do being done better (in their own films, soaps with prime time), and having he audience not carry over.

 

I think a lot about what happened in daytime.  And at the twilight of soaps, not any of these final four has a woman EP.  When I think back to ABC in the 1990’s, when their shows had true creative resurgences, each one was filled with talented, dedicated women at every level from the head of daytime to line production.  I’m not saying only women can do this job.  Many great men have created magnificent soap opera.  But the total lack of dedicated women in these positions shows just how far soap operas have gotten from their largest viewership.  

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

This is what annoys me so much--I'm not really a fan of superhero comics (I love comics, but not superhero ones) but the analogies are so similar, it's frustrating that he couldn't see that.  They were pulp product at least as much as soaps--meant to be discarded and to only sell their advertising.  Once the Marvel system took hold, they were also "endless" storylines, that, from a non-reader--could be seen as only hooking their audience by endlessly stringing them along.  You want crazy soap opera stories?  Superhero comics had people coming back from the dead long before soaps did.  etc, etc.  To try to claim that at least some of those have genuine merit and aren't just glorified advertisements with a captive audience, and then to say that that's entirely what soaps are, is ignorant at best.



 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

He doesn’t see the similarities because he doesn’t want to.  Comic books, especially super hero comics, can and have been easily judged by their quality against other forms of literary content.  Just like soap operas.

 

Its easy to say something isn’t for you, without saying that it shouldn’t be for anyone at all.  But a lot of current criticism is based in the thought that if I don’t enjoy something, that means I can rip it to shreds, even with poor arguments based solely on my personal beliefs about something.

 

How much of this type of criticism is based in misogyny?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Most of it! And it’s classism as well. I know a lot of heterosexual men have enjoyed daytime soaps over the years, but they tend to be rural and lower middle-class in my experience. I used to watch Sex and the City with a room full of prep school-educated straight dudes in college, but they all questioned my intelligence when they caught me catching a daytime soap between classes. A lot of what this guy is saying echoes their criticisms.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I've seen this video, and I hate it just as much as the rest of y'all do. I really can't put it into intelligent words the way that I feel towards this guy and the whole vibe of the video. It's literally someone who knows very little about soaps deciding to do five minutes worth of research (if that much) to make himself "informed" among his uninformed friends so that he can become the "smart one" who knows about this enough to actually have a "valid" opinion on it. In short, he is a piece of sh!t.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I have seen this video 'recommended' for me over and over when I go on Youtube but I always ignore it, as the brief second I clicked on it was just the usual droning-to-drone atmosphere most of these videos tend to have. 

 

All of the major genres have developed soap elements in order to survive, and no amount of sneering will change this. 

 

It's this sneering and shame toward soaps, from those in charge of daytime, that killed the genre in the first place. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • They interacted before when Dani and Pamela were at the casino. 
    • The last few episodes have been good; the acting, the emotions. It's nice to see that GH can still do classic soap opera. I do wish that they would respect their long term audience more and do it without all the silly rewrites though. And where do they go from here? I'm a bit pessimistic and fully expect the show to go back to the drama-less, boring mess it usually is. I'm giving it a month, tops.
    • RATINGS & PREEMPTIONS UPDATE:   1979-Present: 4 Weeks of data missing:   1 Fast Weekly Week: 8/24/81...This week is missing the prelim ratings and full/partial preemption data.   3 Partial Regular Weeks: 12/14/87, 5/20/91, 5/27/91. These three weeks have ratings data (one from Daytime TV; the other two of the three weeks have ratings & share data from Soap Opera Weekly) These weeks are missing the affiliates/clearances and partial preemptions data. Full preemption data is confirmed by comparing the # of telecasts in the preceding and succeeding books.   TOTAL: 4 Weeks of data missing from 1/1/79-Present (out of 2,422 weeks) 99.9 percent complete!   1973-1978: 35 Weeks of data missing:   10 Full Regular Weeks: 9/3/73, 9/10/73, 9/17/73, 9/24/73, 10/1/73, 10/8/73, 10/15/73, 10/22/73, 4/10/78, 4/17/78. These ten weeks are missing the final ratings/shares/affiliates/clearances and partial preemptions data. Full preemption data is confirmed by comparing the # of telecasts in the preceding and succeeding books. For September 1973, the full preemption data is not confirmable, but newspaper listings & Vanderbilt News telecast listings provide the best list possible in its place.   25 Fast Weekly Weeks: 4/23/73, 6/25/73, 8/27/73, 12/24/73, 4/22/74, 6/24/74, 8/26/74, 12/23/74, 4/21/75, 6/23/75, 8/25/75, 12/22/75, 4/19/76, 6/21/76, 8/23/76, 12/20/76, 4/18/77, 6/20/77, 8/22/77, 12/19/77, 3/20/78, 4/24/78, 6/26/78, 8/28/78, 12/25/78. These 25 weeks are all missing the preliminary ratings and full/partial preemptions data.   TOTAL: 39 Weeks of data missing from 1/1/73-Present (out of 2,735 weeks)  98.6 percent complete!   Note: From the Days of Our Lives and Another World research, the full & partial preemptions should be all available, even from the 39 weeks above.
    • Yes. They were very much out of ideas for Reva by this time. A talk show, blindness...the time travel story... That would have made sense.  (were they acknowledging the Beth/Bill relationship by this point)
    • Will be up tomorrow.   lepää rauhassa Taina Elg

      Please register in order to view this content

          TAINA ELG          3/9/1930 - 5/15/2025 THE DOCTORS         Diana Ross      "Tomorrow Is Ours Today" week of 2/3/64 THE GUIDING LIGHT      Dr. Ingrid Fischer     1980 ONE LIFE TO LIVE     Olympia ___Buchanon "Nicole Bonnard"  1980-81 THE EDGE OF NIGHT      Madame Forrester        1984 ALL MY CHILDREN           Countess Irina Korsova         Unknown Year   LOVING                           Mrs. Mulryan           1993 and HERE'S HOLLYWOOD      Self   1961 MISTER BROADWAY    Self    1964 YOKYOPELIT     Self    1966 CA' C'EST L'AMOUR   On Camera host    2003 movies SUOMISEN PERHE     Lapsi Ollin Kutsuilla    1941 NAIMISIIN  PÄIVÄKSI    Tanssija Kabareessa    1946 THE PRODIGAL      Elissa         1955 DIANE       Alys         1956 GABY     Elsa     1956 LES GIRLS   Angele Dueros    1977 IMITATION GENERAL     Simone    1958 THE 39 STEPS       Fisher    1959 WATUSI    Erica Neuler      1959 THE BACCHANTES     Dirce     1961 SUOMALAISIA MAAILMAN   TURUILLA -- TAINA ELG     Self     1963 JUHLAT LINNASSA    Isabelle Oopperan Pikku Tanssijatar   1966   (Made for T. V.) HERCULES IN NEW YORK     Nemesis     1970 THE GREAT WALLENDAS    Helen Wallenda    1978   (Made for T. V.) LIEBESTRAUM       Old Mother Ralston    1991 DON'T DRINK THE WATER    Anna Gruber      1992   (Made for T. V.) THE MIRROR HAS TWO FACES    Female Professor    1994 TRUE LOVE      Self     2003 STARRING -- TAINA ELG   2003      (Made for T. V.) KUMMELIN JACKPOT     Mrs. Skogstedt    2006 BROADWAY LOOK TO THE LILIES        3/29/1970 - 4/19/1970      Sister Albertine UNCLE VANYA     6/4/1973 - 7/28/1973     Standby --   Yelena Andreyevna  WHERE'S CHARLEY?      12/20/1974 - 2/23/1975   Donna Lucia D'Alvadorez  ****  TONY AWARD NOMINEE -- BEST FEATURED ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL THE UTTER GLORY OF MORRISSEY HALL       5/13/1979     Mrs. Delmonde STRIDER      11/14/1979 - 5/18/1980    Replacement --  Viazapurikha; Methieu; Marie   2/5/1980 - ???? NINE      5/9/1982 - 2/4/1984   Guido's Mother    CABARET    3/19/1998 -1/4/2004     Standby -- Fraulein Schneider TOURING IRMA LA DOUCE     1/4/1962 - 8/25/1962      Irma La Douce I MARRIED AN ANGEL    1964      Angel      GIGI      9/9/1964 - 6/22/1965   Inez Alvarez THERE'S A GIRL IN MY SOUP - NATIONAL TOUR    1969     Shubert Theatre   Cincinnati, OH TWO BY TWO   9/15/1972 -3/11/1973      Esther A LITTLE NIGHT MUSIC  --  NATIONAL PREMIERE  1973 - 74    Desiree Armfeldt    Australian National Tour ZORBA     1976     Madame Hortense 13 RUE DE L'AMOUR        1978    Léontine TITANIC    1/5/1999  - 9/10/2000      Ida Straus; 3rd Class Passenger THEATER PAUL AND CONSTANTINE     1957         La Jolla Playhouse REDHEAD       1960     Essie       Dallas State Fair THE TENDER TRAP   1963     Poppy Matson   Paper Mill Playhouse CAN CAN        1964   Claudine      Kenley Players   Columbus, Ohio SILK STOCKINGS       1964     Notchka           Melodyland, CA WEST SIDE STORY       1966      Maria   Finnish National Opera   Helsinki THE SOUND OF MUSIC     1966 - 71     3 Productions UNCLE VANYA     1974      Standby for Julie Christie   Circle in the Square Uptown SOMETHING'S AFOOT     1986     Miss Tweed    Liberty Hall   Lowell, MA CABARET     1996      FrauleinSchneider    Walnut Street Theatre Main Stage Philadelphia REQUIEM FOR WILLIAM     2003    Connelly Theater, NYC          MEMORY OF SUMMER    Alice O PIONEERS! I HATE HAMLET Family Ties Parents --     Helena Doroumova (an immigrant pianist) and Ake Elg  (Ake Ludwig) also a pianist Marriages      Carl Bjorkenheim   1953 - 58    Divorced   1 Child -- Raoul Bjorkenheim      Rocco Caporale    1982 - 6/30/2008      His Death         LAURA PILLMAN   THE BOLD AND THE BEAUTIFUL      Cassandra    4/24/2025   NURSES' BALL DANCER                            RODRIGO VARANDAS      GENERAL HOSPITAL     Nurse Jack       5/21 - 23/2025 movies VIVENDO COM ZIKA        2016 LET'S DUB: VOXX STUDIOS COMMERCIAL     Audience    2016 BIO FILTER   Mr. Ramirez    2020 PSYCHE     Entity      2025 RED SOULS FEELING GOOD A MINUTE TO LOVE Upcoming SEESAW     Max      TBA    In Production THEATER ORIGINAL -- THE MUSICAL: THE LIFE STORY OF JANIVA MAGNESS    Candlelight Pavilion LEGALLY BLONDE     Candlelight Pavilion THOROUGHLY MODERN MILLIE          Candlelight Pavilion SINGIN IN THE RAIN     2015      Ensemble    WEST SIDE STORY       2015     Pepe     Candlelight Pavilion  EMPIRE   (World Premiere)   Jesse; Ensemble CHILDREN OF EDEN    2016   Storyteller; Snake    Cabrillo Music Theatre WOMEN ON THE VERGE OF A NERVOUS BREAKDOWN       2017        Carlos IRVING BERLIN'S WHITE CHRISTMAS   2017      Ensemble    Long Beach IN THE HEIGHTS        2017      Swing; Ensemble    Musical Theatre West CABARET    Herman -- Kit Kat Boy     2018      KINKY BOOTS     2020    Announcer; Angel       Cerritos, CA MAMMA MIA       2021   Pepper; Ensemble    Understudy -- Bill     SHREK    Dragon Puppeteer; Big Bad Wolf   YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN   2022     Ensemble           1776           Leather Apron;  Painter A FEW GOOD MEN    William T. Santiago  ROMEO AND JULIET     Romeo TOURING PETER PAN      Cecco SINGIN' IN THE RAIN     2014 https://stagescenela.com/2016/03/juan-caballer-rodrigo-varandas/       WANTED TO LOCK TRACY UP                                      JEFFERY THOMAS JOHNSON       Also Credited as Jeff Johnson   PARTY OF FIVE 2.0    Officer __ Bryce   2020 GENERAL HOSPITAL    Sheriff __ Lewis   April 2025 and NEWTON'S CRADLE     Officer Goodloe   2020 MY SECRET AGENT HUSBAND    Maverick Thompson     2024 HER POSSESSIVE GUARD       Gage      2024 movies THE TWO JAKES      Golfer    1990 QUEENS LOGIC      Club Patron     1991 DRACULA      Van Helsing's Student     1992 TEXAS PAYBACK     Board Member    1995 CALL GIRL    Man in Black   1995 CITIZEN RUTH   Harlan's Biker Friend     1996 LOVE ME TWICE     Phillip   1996 AMERICAN TIGERS     Krause    1996 THE BRAVE       Clerk    1997 CONTACT     Mechanical     1997 THE POSTMAN      Rope Bridge Soldier   1997 GETTING THERE     Waiter in Ski Lodge    2002 OPERATION TERROR     Federal Agent Thomas   2012 LIFE TRACKER   Brigadier General Anthony Morris    2013 CARDINAL MATTER      Jeremy Ryan    2016 THE DEVIL HAS A NAME      Police Captain     2019 AQUARIUM OF THE DEAD     Smith    2021 SUPER VOLCANO    Guillerman     2022   (Made for T. V.) 20.0  MEGAQUAKE     Guillerman   2022   (Made for T. V.) ICE STORM      Guillerman    2023    (Made for T. V.) BIRD OF PARADISE     Dominic Dunaway     2023 THE LAUNDRESS    Guy Sullivan    2024 DEAD WRONG     Mason    2024 24 HOURS TO D-DAY      Major Jones     2024 THE SIX TRIPLE EIGHT    Colonel Davenport    2024 Upcoming FIRE ANT     Nolan Karr   TBA   Post Production  INCIDENT AT COTTER CREEK     Mason     TBA    In Production JOY RIDGE    David Whipliton     TBA   In Production ALL PAID FOR     Jack    TBA     Pre Production                            ASHLEY CAPLE   GENERAL HOSPITAL   Hot Girl at Pool    6/14/2023                            Charlie's Pub Waitress     1/28/2025 and TREASURE KING      Daisy Duke    2014 HEROES WITH ISSUES    Cortara     2016; 2018 movies DESTRUCTION: LAS VEGAS   Spring Break Female    2013 ENTOURAGE      Sloan's Friend     2015 THE GUEST HOUSE   Kristy   2016 DOES SIZE MATTER     Girl in the Park  # 1     2016 HOOKED ON A HEIFER    Hot Babe # 1  Brutus' Girlfriend   2017 TALES OF FRANKENSTEIN    Adelina   2018 ASS CLOWNS: CONSTIPATED   Pool Girl   2021 OFF THE RECORD      KLM Casting Girl    2024 Upcoming NOIR      Mistress    TBA    Post Production     RED CARPET DUDE                                   GEORGE PENNACCHIO   GENERAL HOSPITAL    George Pennacchio, Red Carpet  Nurses' Ball 206; 2018; 2019; 2023; May 2025 movies SPLENDOR     Newscaster     1994 FOUR FINGERS OF THE DRAGON    Self      2003 THE LEGACY     Self    2010 SILENT LIFE: THE STORY OF THE LADY IN BLACK   T. V. Reporter   2023 Appeared in the sitcom Less than Perfect in 2003. Serves on the Board of the charity group, The Thalias. Has been the Entertainment Reporter since 1996 at ABC-7 in Los Angeles. He also hosts Oscar Specials.  
    • I can see why the Sam/Amanda story went downhill so fast. Thomas Gibson was a terrible replacement. I don't remember the circumstances of RKK quitting  (if his contract was over or if the departure was more acrimonious), but Gibson just sucks the energy out of every scene. He has no chemistry with anyone.
    • They have renewed my interest back into Hayley. I hope they keep writing her like today. She was fun and looked fabulous. Facts on top of facts! And that is the area that I want them to deep dive into more.  I forget what her purpose was for even visiting him at this point. Leslie had a great May but she can not do more of the same in June and July. I became very excited to see them interact. I don't know where it is going, but it could be a joy to watch. 
    • Dani and Doug interacted for the first time I believe. Could that be indicator that they will hookup? As wacky and drama filled as Dani is I think she'd have a lot more respect for Doug than Vanessa does and Vanessa really needs a dose of her own medicine.
    • I remember it was reported at the time that the character of Noah was originally planned for Harley but plans changed.   Beth should've shared her experience as well.
    • I really hope they fix this soon. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy