Jump to content

Y&R Promo: Diane's Murder: So Many Suspects


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 40
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

^ +1

It's a good promo. If Maura West were playing a short-term villain and this were the resulting story (and the show didn't keep going back to the mysterious death thing every three months), this could be pretty good. But it's ridiculous that they had to kill off Diane Jenkins for what I'm sure will be a horribly executed story about the same four people.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

For months people have been saying how horribly miscast MW was as Diane so I am quite shocked at all the outrage at her being fired. I like MW a lot and I don't think she ever fit on the canvas or as Diane but I do think in her last few weeks since she's been given better material we've seen MW be able to showcase her talent more and I think she's done a great job. Still doesn't take away the fact she doesn't fit as Diane. Now killing off Diane because an actress is miscast is ridiculous but knowing MAB Diane will be back with Melissa Claire Egan playing her in a few months.

THe promo is actually pretty decent.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

LOL about Melissa Claire Egan. But I think that's exactly why most Y&R fans are pissed -- not that Maura West has been fired, but that Diane's being killed off because the show had to go ahead and cram a popular (and very talented, but miscast) actress anywhere they could just to get her on the canvas.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

This happens quite a bit. I don't know how many times I have read comments about how horrible an actress/actor is until they get the boot especially when the actress/actor is treated terribly by TBTB. See Also Sabine Singh.

In Maura's case it is because people actually liked her but felt she was miscasted AND they like the character of Diane and hate that she has been murdered.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I love a smart literary reference in my soap dialogue, but I just laughed at that *picks up book* Martin: "Ralph Ellison--The Invisible Man."  Smitty: "I see you"

      Please register in order to view this content

    • I don't think Sandra Ferguson was fantastic but I thought she did well enough with the story she was given. She had chemistry with RKK and with Charles Grant and made it understandable why Amanda was torn between the two men. RKK leaving hurt the story but beyond that they didn't try hard enough to make Evan a viable character. After he was written out we just got the triangle with Olivia, which also wasn't viable because they wanted us to root for Sam/Amanda long after viewers had stopped caring.
    • Well at one point Aaron's contract with ABC guaranteed a new series on the schedule each year. I guess once his contract was up he was out the door. It would have been a huge financial commitment and as tastes changed and Aaron didn't ,ABC couldn't see the value. Spelling did have a number of flops along the way.  He always brought up Family as a counter to the criticism that his output was trashy but that's because Family was the only show among many that wasn't  trashy.
    • Passions also did this with Ethan and Sam...probably some other soaps (Billy and Dylan on GL, maybe). I am blanking through fatigue.
    • A-la Sonny shooting "Dominic", a.k.a. Dante... just, minus Dante shooting Gio.
    • Amanda getting pregnant didn't help character development and long term harmed the Sam and Amanda relationship. If this story came to be in 1984,  thoughts on Mary Page Keller playing Amanda instead of Sally and her husband Thomas Ian Griffith playing Sam instead of Catlin. And Jack Wagner as Evan. 
    • It's like all the K-Dramas or C-Dramas where the mother-in-law hates the daughter-in-law who's supposedly from a poor or less than privileged background, only to find out she's the long-lost chaebol daughter from an even richer family.  Maybe someone in the writer's room watches them like I do (mostly the recaps on YouTube) and decided to do that with a male slant? All kidding aside, this is par for the course in soaps where someone you think you hate turns out to be the family you never knew you had. Haha.
    • It's frustration the way Dante was acting. You truly don' t Jordan, I see. LOL!!  I really liked Briana Henry in the role.
    • The failure in communication is one-sided, and not mine. Despite being told repeatedly by me and others that what you may have read on other message boards, Facebook, Instagram, X (formerly Twitter), and/or any other social media site, including those you apparently run, does not make the information true, nor should it be posted here on the SON Community whatsoever. If there's something you've seen/read elsewhere that is newsworthy and from a valid source, there's nothing wrong with sharing/linking to that source. This includes linking to articles from other websites like Deadline, Us Weekly, Soap Opera Digest, EW, PEOPLE, etc. For instance, if any of the aforementioned websites reported that Tabyana Ali renewed her contract, link to that site reporting the news and/or an interview discussing it. Ditto, if Tabyana Ali said something about her contract on social media.  Just saying "apparently," while providing no source other than your statement, does not make it so. This includes if you read it by someone on any social media site other than an official outlet's post, the actress in question, or the show that employs her.  Related, your use of the word "apparently" isn't the key issue here. It's the continued posting of misinformation and the nonchalant sharing of personal information, specifically medically, about real-life people. You KNOW what I'm talking about!
    • I like Brook Kerr. I think she plays Portia exactly the way she's supposed to be. With that being said, GH has thrown Portia under the bus from day one. The woman has suffered and made bad decisions all through her tenure.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy