Jump to content

OLTL: Actor leaving?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 77
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I agree and Real Todd with Blair. But there is all the mess with Danielle being Todd's daughter. They should just have left things as they were. Once they found out OLTL was canceled...the story with RH should have been canned.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Dont worry. Its a big ol clusterf--k of a emss anyway. Since you are a new viewer, Im sure you dont even know that Dani was born offscreen 2 years after Jack, yet she's magically 2 years older than him. RH should biologically be her dad to yet like Jack, she has absolutely no connection to him. Starr is the only kid that should know him

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I think it's both a shame and not. I can live with it, certainly, because I think TSJ ceased being Todd some time ago and became someone else entirely. I wholeheartedly supported the recast, and loved him in the role for years until the stories turned awful and he began phoning it in, with the intermittent flourish of genius - not unlike Howarth's run, which is why I was happy to see him go in 2003. But I think St. John was never terribly into kind of overly schmoopy romantic material, which is what they gave him too much of from the start. He preferred to delve into the dank psychology of the character, which is compelling, but which they often couldn't write for, and so it made many of his more supposedly sincere stories ring hollow, especially in the last five years. Especially Todd and Tea's reunion - she got him off a rape charge and we're supposed to consider them the truest love? TSJ seemed to thumb his nose at that conceit, as well he should've, though his and Lozano's chemistry is electric. He couldn't or wouldn't imbue Todd with humanity and pathos in the midst of terrible or character-ruining storylines, and instead either twisted it or phoned it in. While that was often very watchable when he did [!@#$%^&*] with it, it did not add up to a character to care for, yet OLTL promoted him as a hero. That's not his fault.

As slow and at times lame as this storyline has been, it has meant a lot to me to see a Todd Manning (Howarth's) I can actually care about, believe in and invest in again as anything other than a villain for the first time in a long time. RH came back energized, so it works. To have the rapemance undone means more than I can say to me as a longtime fan of the character. The Todd they spent years trying to rebuild - with many mistakes along the way, sure - would never do that, ever, and if he did he would have to die like a dog.

I do think TSJ is very talented, and has done very well with some dark material. He also plays against anything cozy or nice or unearned - like Todd's "redemption" in the last couple years - and when he is going for the dangerous sociopath stuff he does very, very well, I think. He's just brilliantly creepy. And I think were the show going on - or not - they could've gone on for years with TSJ turning out to be Todd's scheming long-lost fraternal twin or something, this manipulative, vampiric, somewhat more subtly, insidiously evil type than RH's Todd's blunter approach. You could've played them and their relationships with the family off each other for years, that rivalry. But am I crying that he's going with the show off? No. I am really looking forward to seeing how it all shakes out, though.

On another note, I have my doubts Sam will leave with TSJ, whatever becomes of him, which means he would be in Llanview with Blair and most likely a reunion with Todd. And as I've said before, that would make me very, very happy as an ultimate resolution to the baby Jack storyline.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Agnes had written for Bernard Grant for many years on TGL as well as Ernest Graves and Joe Gallison,Doris Belack,Robert Milli,and  Antony Ponzini at AW. So she would probably gravitate to writing a role with an actor in mind or choosing someone she had written for before who she knew could deliver.
    • Once Johnny Dallas' cut himself off from Laurie Ann Karr and their son, and once Laurie successfully recovered from her mental problems, she wanted a new, fresh, and healthy start for the next chapter of her life. She legally reverted her name and changed John Victor's  surname to Karr. After moving to the country (when Teri  Keane was dropped from the show), Bill and Martha Marceau legally adopted Jennifer, the baby girl whom they had earlier taken in when the child's biological mother, Taffy Simms (and other bio family members) proved to be unfit to raise her. Jennifer legally and emotionally became a Marceau, and gave that name to her own daughter, whom Jennifer birthed through surrogacy as a single parent. Et...voila! The Karr and Marceau legacies live on.

      Please register in order to view this content

    • BLQ is having second thoughts regarding putting her baby up for adoption. Chase is upset he can't tell Dante. So both are putting this on at lulus feet. Saying she is holding it over them. Lulu is doing none of this. 
    • Yes she absolutely was involved in that story which seems to have gone nowhere.  She didn't start to remove herself from the writing until 1973.
    • Y'all are bringing back great memories of AMC 2.0 for me.  I haven't thought about it and the new characters in so long, well since it aired, and I plan to go re-watch it now. When AMC ended, I finally came to peace with it and accepted that I will never watch an hour of a TV show daily in my life again... something that I had been doing since I was 6-7 years old. I was starting a new career, relationship, and chapter in life when AMC 2.0 came out.  I found a way to watch it, but things felt differently for me at the time and when it was so short-lived and gone, it became such a distant memory, sadly.
    • That's a great point. I wish the writing could find those nuances.
    • After all Lulu's been through with her coma and missing years I can get her being on the sensitive side especially when talking to her mother.  I was thinking it was more a culmination of everything than just this one particular problem. 
    • I see her moral dilemma, too, and I don't think Lulu was out of line. I just felt it was overboard for her to break down in tears over her dilemma.
    • I also think the fact Lulu chose abortion and Brook Lynn chose to give a baby up for adoption instead when they were in similar situations adds another layer to this.  The writing doesn't really state this, but I can see Lulu slightly spiraling about thinking she could have an adult child out there if she made a different choice.  Both woman made the right choices for themselves at the time, but I can see both making parallels to their decisions.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy