Jump to content

Scandal: Discussion Thread


Recommended Posts

  • Members

What about the madam and her powerful political johns last season? This season: The senator who had sex on his desk? The wife of the Reverend? All these people have money, power, and privilege which helped them afford and/or get access Olivia's services. The whole thing is unsavory and unappealing. However, I get that this procedural element is part of the show, but I wish it would be toned down a bit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 676
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

True they have the money but there is more of a human element there for me. Take the service guy they helped and the widow of the pilot. Don't forget the judicial candidate who was oblivious to his wife's past s an ex-hooker was also helped by that madam scandal, as unsavory as it was. I didn't think of the reverend's wife as rich until the mistress demanded all that cash which made her look more like a gold digger than the wife looked like some rich woman trying to protect her image. The wife was sympathetic and ultimately sacrificed to save her husband's reputation. She could have easily said let the woman speak and gone into hiding with whatever millions she had coming to her.

I agree with you on some of the cases and disagree on some and I see why the scandal of the week seems unnecessary. Fixing is the essence of Olivia's character though. It would be like having a medical drama where there are no patients every week because the focus is strictly on the medical staff's personal lives. It reminds viewers that Olivia does have a job to do and she can't put her job on hold to tend to her personal business. It all has to fit in somehow.

That's soo fangurl worthy like "you complete me."

it would be cool to have a list of lines like that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

IMO, the problem is that the kind of procedural cases that Olivia handles, the scandals of the rich and famous, is simple not appealing to a wider audience which why one of the reasons that the show has been unable to build its audience and is in danger of cancellation. Yes, you can find the human element in some of the cases, but overall I find myself rolling my eyes at them unless they have a direct connection to Olivia's personal situation like the one with the Reverend's mistress. What police/CSI/medical dramas all have in common is that the good guys win or people are helped/saved. As much as Shonda tries and keeps on repeating it, it is very hard to buy Olivia as a "white hat/good guy" when she is dabbling in cynical politics [ETA] and cleaning up crime scenes.The West Wing was one of the few successful political dramas on broadcast tv and it was full of idealistic main characters trying to do right by the country.

Frankly, I think that Scandal straddles too many genres; political drama, serial drama, weekly procedural. I actually think that Scandal would do well on cable where it would find a niche audience like Suits on USA or Sons of Anarchy or Justified on FX. On these shows, the audience accepts that the lead characters are not necessarily good or bad, they are just doing their thing. Scandal could get a solid demo, while it struggles on ABC.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Right, I don't get the constant drilling of the wearing of the white hat because she's not saving your average citizens in any type of noble gesture. She's generally keeping sleazy characters out of potentially damaging scandals and as such cannot come across as some charitable soul. It's kind of hard to see the flip side where protecting these secrets indirectly benefits decent people.

I think the nature of the show does not lend itself to drawing a large audience. As you've pointed out, these aren't the kinds of problems people relate to and that's the kind of job Olivia happens to have. Theoretically, it may sound interesting or fascinating--especially if she's fixing scandals of celebrities, but in practice it's not beyond possibly knowing what the scandal being covered up is.

You're right. This is a better show for a station like TNT. They would also have the freedom to be more realistic with the dialogue and certain scenes.

I never gave the whole grey leading character any thought, but you've got a point. I love Raylan Givens for no apparent reason and Margo Martindale was all kinds of awesome as Mags Bennett. Neal McDonough made Quarles super creepy and was effective but last's season's villains can't come close to the power of Mags. And way off the wall but Boris Kodjoe's "Undercover" show was perfect for USA.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I absolutely love Justified which has the best writing on tv, imo. I adore Raylan and Boyd who are amazingly well written and acted characters. Mags and Quarles were awesome villains along with Arlo and Dewey Crow.

Perhaps if ABC passes on Scandal, it would consider selling it to FX or AMC. I think these are the cable networks that I think would fit a more realistically written Scandal.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I don't see Scandal on TNT which has "dramas" where the lead are "good" characters. Leverage is the closest thing and it is helping people through a con. TNT and USA are both peppy quirky cable networks. In contrast, AMC has Breaking Bad, Hell on Wheels, The Walking Dead, and Mad Men. All these shows have conflicted amoral ambivalent lead characters so Scandal would fit. Same with FX which has gritty dramas.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I was thinking more like "Southland" where the characters are shades of grey and not all "good." USA is definitely all peppy and colorful although the "Suits" characters are shades of grey no matter how they pass off the means justifying the end. I've never gotten into "Burn Notice" so I don't know if they're a bit shady.

I don't think Holly Hunter's Grace ("Saving Grace") was all "good" though her intentions may have been. And "Hawthorne" was one of those breaking the rules for the right reasons character, although in the last season she was a complete mess as was the show. She actually became quite contemptible which is unusual for the heroine of a show but I don't think she was all that likable from the beginning. Michael Vartan's character made her tolerable but then she basically ripped him apart to manufacture drama with Marc Anthony's character and basically wrecked the show because if it.

And I never watched "The Closer" but those promos made her seem like a law bender.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

"Why didn't I meet you sooner? What kind of coward was I to marry her and not wait for you to show up?"

Ooooh you guys. This is my favorite line this year. My favorite.

It's too bad that this show is not a HUGE hit or it would go down in history.

Someone said that to me, I would just melt.

It is so romantic in an understating way.

Who says this and doesn't mean it.

Ah, I just love that line.

I agree, "Scandal" should have been on AMC. It would have done much better. And they could have shown much more sexy scenes, that's for sure. Don't know if Shonda has some sort of contract with the primetime network.

~Milo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I forgot about Southland, but despite the hype about it, its ratings have been poor compared to other TNT dramas. The Closer was a great show. There are ethical questions about Brenda Leigh's actions at times, but she never broke the law and there was never any doubt that she was the ultimate white hat.

Scandal has a difficult premise to sell to an audience so maybe there is no ideal cable network. Regardless, Scandal's demo and overall ratings have not grown this season so I do not see it getting more than the 13 episodes much less another season on ABC.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I'm thinking that the character of Olivia is a major hurdle. She's not accessible and whatever I've learned about her is by way of interaction with other characters which leads to a lot of fill in the blanks. The biggest assumptions about are made based on her relationship with Fitz. There needs to be moments where her guard comes completely down and who she is and how she feels comes directly from her own mouth as in "I feel this way..." That's usually achieved with a friend or confidant which she lacks. Average viewers may need that sort of connection to become invested in a show and I don't think this show offers that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I am just keeping my fingers cross that we get to watch 13 episodes cause things don't look good and I am not holding my breath.

The cast is so good at communicating with the fans. You can tell they are trying to do everything to keep the show going. And they are most greatful. I wish back in the day, I would have been able to do that when I actually used to love to watch a lot of tv. Now there aren't too many shows that interest me.

~Milo

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

My reaction will probably be "oh well." I can't remember ever caring that a show was cancelled or ended. I have cared a couple of times that someone was leaving a soap which meant the end of a couple I liked but that was momentary.

Hopefully their followers are all respectful and sane. The telenovela adaptation I watched ended on the 5th and a group of fans are basically using twitter to constantly plead with some of the stars and others related to the show for a second season. One wants everyone to tweet Nick Cannon since he told kids to find something they're passionate about and they're passionate about the show and getting another season. I'm pretty sure his intent was to encourage teems to help others not to fight to encourage him to get a show but they claim not to be able to live or ever be happy again without it. Oh well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Not having news about Tomas being recast is super disappointing. This triangle could be great if there was an actor with an actual pulse playing Tomas.    Leslie showing up at Nicole’s, I absolutely liiiive. AND this nasty heffa is gonna blame Eva for Laura’s accident

      Please register in order to view this content

      . All of the cast mixing and mingling today was great! I never imagined some of these cast members ever interacting.
    • Guiding Light 1976 continues... Dr. Joe Werner’s double load, covering Ed’s patients as well as his own, has taken its toll, and he’s having chest pains. Joe arranges for a checkup at another hospital and then confesses to Sarah that the results show he has angina pectoris and must slow down. Dr. Justin Marler arrives in Springfield to join the Cedars staff. His purpose is to organize improvements for the surgical-cardiac wing. He immediately disrupts the staff by giving a premature interview, saying the hospital needs much improvement.  Sarah tries to avoid Marler and is noticeably cool to him. They were in love while in medical school, but Marler broke with her to marry a girl whose money and social position could help his career. Since Marler has criticized him for cutting back on his patient hours, Joe once again picks up his pace. After performing emergency surgery, he collapses in the scrub room, a victim of cardiac arrest. Marler finds him, and his fast reactions save Joe’s  life. Sarah,learning of Marler’s efforts for Joe, expresses unlimited appreciation.Although he’s recovering well, Joe now fears for his future and insists upon revising his will. Sarah is frightened by his attitude, but Joe is adamant. Mike’s client, Ben McFarren, was wrongly convicted of a crime and was in prison for fifteen months. When Mike informs Ben he’s been exonerated, Ben, embittered by his imprisonment, blames Mike for his having been there in the first place. Ben, released, will have a professorship in art at the local college in the fall. He’s working temporarily at the hospital and at the Metro, and he meets Mike’s daughter, Hope.Ben and Hope hit it off well from the first and soon begin dating. Ben tells Hope she’s naive and innocent, but she wants him to think otherwise. However, Ben’s increasing ardor frightens Hope, and she finally insists she won’t be pressured into sleeping with him just to prove-she likes him and is with it. Ben retorts that she’s letting them both down and walks out. Hope visits his studio, hoping to make him understand that she’s torn between her desires and the way she was raised. Ben tells her he understands but makes it clear that it’s his terms or not at all. Hope, to help Ben out, offers to replace the nude model for his art class. When the moment comes, however, she can’t do it, and poses in a bikini. But a local gossip columnist exploits the incident, and Mike finds himself defending his daughter to all his friends. But when Mike discovers that Ben has sketched a nude of Hope, he questions her integrity, whether her denial was truthful. Hope is upset that she must defend her morality to her father. Mike also can’t help but wonder about Ben’s intentions toward Hope. Hope becomes confused, as Ben’s feelings for her seem to vary day by day. At one meeting he will be open and affectionate with her, at the next remote and cool. Finally Ben explains to her that this is the  first time in his life that he has someone he can trust, and he still occasionally can’t overcome his suspicions and fears of being hurt and withdraws. Unable to discuss this with her father, Hope confides the situation to Ann, who has helped her with advice and a listening post before. Ann is able to understand, as she can empathize with the problems of living through an unhappy and difficult life, something beyond Hope’s experience. She makes Hope see that Ben has found only betrayal in his life until now and he can’t help but be cautious. Hope soon discovers there’s a side to Ben she’s never seen before. When his boss at the Metro imposes on him unfairly and then rides him about being an ex con, Ben reacts with a rage that frightens Hope, but he manages to keep his control.. Ben realizes he overreacted when Hope remarks about his violent temper, but is surprised and deeply affected to see that she’s offering him support instead of castigation or rejection, when she defends him to Mike. This leads Ben to admit to Hope that he loves her.  But Mike is worried. He tells Hope that while he was defending Ben he looked into the young man’s background and found that he had a history of short temper and violent outbursts. And, based on what’s recently happened, Mike warns Hope that Ben has apparently not changed. Hope refuses to let Mike’s argument deter her; in fact, she asks Mike if it’s not possible that this very past just might be the best incentive Ben has to do differently in the future. Now that she has recovered from surgery, Mrs. Stapleton is eager to return home, but Evie is very upset by this news. She wants to stay in Springfield, particularly since she has just started dating Tim. Rita, understanding her sister’s wish not to return to the slow-paced small-town life she so recently left, convinces her mother to delay her departure, explaining that Evie stands a much better chance to plan her future here. Rita herself is delighted that Ed’s attentions now seem exclusively hers. Her helping him study for the neurology boards has paid off: He’s passed the state boards and can now begin his neurology practice. Rita has told her mother that Ed is the first man she has ever seriously considered sharing her future with, and her mother concludes that her daughter is finally. in love. Rita is eagerly anticipating a celebration dinner with Ed following the good news, but her happiness is shattered when she catches sight of a man in the corridor at Cedars whose presence forms ice around her heart. She is so shaken that Ed, coming upon her at the nurses’ station, is concerned and asks her what has happened. She cannot discuss this with him but is withdrawn and upset. And, indeed, her worst fears are realized when late at night, after Ed has left Malcolm Grainger shows up at her door. Grainger bitterly threatens to ruin Rita by exposing the truth about what she did in Texas to her family and all of Springfield. Rita thinks she has managed to stall him, for a day, and, assuming he has gone, she rushes to the Metro to tell Roger that Malcolm is in town. Rita and Roger are unaware that Grainger followed her and is standing outside the door of Roger’s office, listening to their conversation. Roger tells Rita he doesn’t want Grainger to know he is also in Springfield, and orders her to meet with Grainger.
    • So limited that he was on Dynasty and AMC.
    • Denise was the best thing about that otherwise ridiculous plotline. I wasn't familiar with her work on Days of Our Lives or General Hospital but I could see her warmth and charisma as Mary even though the Another World storyline was a bit lacking.   
    • I don't know what else to say except we have lost another legend at a time when it feels like we are losing too many. I love that Denise Alexander never played Lesley as some perpetual victim, but as a woman and physician with integrity and backbone.  Rick and Monica made an absolute fool of her with their affair; yet, Lesley was someone who never made you pity her. Ladies and gentlemen, we aren't just losing veteran actors here.  We're also losing vital parts of this genre's legacy, and that just breaks my heart. God bless Ms. Alexander and her loved ones.  May she RIP.
    • Michael Nader was limited too? 

      Please register in order to view this content

    • For some reason, Tomas reminds me of a younger Dimitri from AMC.
    • Very sorry to see this news.  My first memory of her and Days was the story of her character Susan Martin shooting her husband after their baby died, and then of course Susan introduced Doug to Julie.  Enjoyed all of her work though.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy