ICAM! Honestly, I think some people are just pissed that he had the nerve to break up their couple and make it harder for them to get back together latter on. Couple that with some of his recent comments and he becomes an easy target.

I'm sure some are upset because of that, but it doesn't mean Pratt or Guza or McTavish or B&E were or are genius writers because a big, not so beloved fanbase disliked or dislikes them. IJS.

Khan, that was delicious.

So he's saying he's not responsible for much anything that aired before this May? That it was him cleaning up for the writers before him, specifically McTavish? McTavish brought in Rebecca (the wife Jesse married 5 minutes after going into hiding), and Zach and Bianca's child, and bi-sexual gay Reese, and David's A3 obsession and druggings? Okay, lol.

Also even though many dislike whats going on with AMC, the ratings have stablized and that is something that hasn't happened since of February 2006.

The ratings stabalized and went up with McTavish for 2 solid years there and then she had several upward trends after that, that didn't exactly make her exempt to criticism from fans.

I'm sure some are upset because of that, but it doesn't mean Pratt or Guza or McTavish or B&E were or are genius writers because a big, not so beloved fanbase disliked or dislikes them. IJS.

I never said it did

And since my other post got deleted, Khan I wasn't lumping you in that category

dp, I put it back up in the post before Khan's. It just needed an edit.

I never said it did

I never said you said that, just pointing it out

ETA

Pratt, I think he could write good if there was somebody on his behind that had control over him. He's like a less grounded McTavish. He seems to have massive attention issues - he might actually have ADD so I don't mean to make a joke out of that. Storyline wise, he's doing a lot of the same things that made McTavish so unpopular. IMO, he's bringing up Dixie and opening that wound (as if the pancake death wasn't bad enough) just for a plot point to kill off another beloved character. Personally, I don't have as much of a problem with Stuart being killed off like this as I would with Myrtle or Joe or Palmer or Adam but still a lot of fans do.

He's like a less grounded McTavish.

And that's putting it mildly. Ten bucks says Amanda's farewell scene will involve her waking up in a strange place and another woman telling her she's in "hooker hell, baby!".

Oh boy, I can't wait for the next Pratt video...His alter-ego Ryape is speaking...I like what Pratt has done...He killed Babe....He killed The Fetus...He killed Greenpea...He killed Babe..He's making all the Babe worshippers suffer.

Edited April 26, 200916 yr by reallyhateskateonlost

I don't get all of this Pratt bashing. I'm enjoying what he is doing with AMC. He has made it faster paced, better storylines, and more balance. I'm glad he didn't mention B&E because let's face it, they were the worst writers IMO on AMC. Also even though many dislike whats going on with AMC, the ratings have stablized and that is something that hasn't happened since of February 2006.

Faster paced? Yeah if you mean 98% of stuff happens OFFSCREEN, and things LITERALLY change from day to day.

Nelson Branco even talked about how storylines were changing every week (he was going to have Bianca return with cancer, then was going to have Reese sleep with Zach AND Ryan).

More balance? Not really.

The worst writers? I'd say Pratt has taken that title from B&E, he's so bad he makes them look GOOD, hell he makes McT look like a brilliant writer

hell he makes McT look like a brilliant writer

Not possible.

Not possible.

Yeah things aren't working, so lets go back to something that has already been proven to not work. It is quite the mystifying logic. The same thing was said when B&E were writing.... they made McT's stuff look watchable.... the next headwriter thus will make Pratt's material look watchable. Just because one writer is bad does not make another bad writer look brilliant. Makes zero sense.

Edited April 27, 200916 yr by Adam

Like DP said I TOTALLY AGREE 100%

Many people who dislike Pratt are Zendall fans. I am glad Pratt did that, because IMO they were getting boring and B&E put them on our screen 99% of the time. Zendall would have been more tolarable if B&E did not show them 99% of the time.

Like I said many people may not like them put Pratt has been able to stablize the ratings so something must be going right with the show wether you like it or not.

Also a true fan of a soap doesn't care for just one couple, but for what's best for the show.

Edited April 27, 200916 yr by Kyle

Many people who dislike Pratt are Zendall fans.

And many people who dislike Pratt are not fans of that pairing. I think being part of a fanbase colors your opinion, be it a character or couple or show or head writer, but not to that point that the opinion becomes completely irrelevant. The opinion just becomes colored and looked at with that color.

I am glad Pratt did that, because IMO they were getting boring and B&E put them on our screen 99% of the time. Zendall would have been more tolarable if B&E did not show them 99% of the time.

Pratt airs them as much as B&E (there's other factors now: AM's vacation, RB leaving), he just airs David's crew a lot too versus say another set of younger "hot" characters.

Personally I don't think ruining things improves them. I think it just ruins things and then you're lucky if you can salvage anything out of it. For example, I'll never like Bianca and Kendall's relationship how I used too and I don't feel like that's a plus. I feel like I lost something that was just absolutely wonderful and that touched me. I don't feel like I gained anything out of that at all, nor do I feel the characters or relationship have/has.

Like I said many people may not like them put Pratt has been able to stablize the ratings so something must be going right with the show wether you like it or not.

Also a true fan of a soap doesn't care for just one couple, but for what's best for the show.

So in your opinion Pratt is best for the show, right? Are you saying if somebody disagrees with that they don't care what's best for the show and aren't a true fan of the show? I ask that, because I actually think their are more people in this thread having problems with Pratt that aren't fans of the aforementioned pairing than their are fans of the pairing.

I actually think there are more people in this thread having problems with Pratt that aren't fans of [Zendall] than there are fans of the pairing.

You go, girl.

It's been ages since I genuinely enjoyed watching AMC (probably, before some of you were even born, lol!), and Pratt has done nothing thus far to change my opinion(s). If anything, I think the show has become even more shallow and gimmicky under his pen! Honestly, I wish Ryan, Kendall, Zach, Annie, Aidan, David, Amanda, JR, Krystal, Jake, Taylor, Brot, Frankie, Colby, and Randi would all go away so I would get "my show" back.

Sorry. Just ranting....

Edited April 27, 200916 yr by Khan