Jump to content

Higley Quit DAYS?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 659
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

On a serious note, he better have some damn good evidence if he is going to release a name. That could potentially damage relationships or lead to someone getting fired. If a name is going to be revealed there better be stuff to back it up

And on a lighter note: Thank you for the pleasure of hijacking this thread. Every once in a while it does need to be done...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I have not watched DOOL regularly in a long time, and have no strong feelings one way or the other about how I want any of this to play out as far as any of the individual parties involved, but I find this whole situation fascinating. I'm a little confused as to the logistics of all of this...

I know that technically non-WGA members cannot legally write for soaps, but I wasn't aware that the union was in the business of hunting down non-union members who are involving themselves in the creative process when WGA members are employed and being paid at the union-negotiated rate at every level of the writing staff? I would have thought the issue during the strike was that scabs undermined the WGA's bargaining power and that is why the question of who was writing what became important, but when I start to think of every reported involvement of non-writers in writing tasks in recent history, it boggles the mind...

  • Why wasn't the Guild involved a decade ago when Jill Farren Phelps, a producer, was reportedly head-writing OLTL for nearly a year? There was nobody officially in the head writing position for most of that time if memory serves (unlike Dena Higley, who it sounds like has still been getting paid her salary). And two WGA members had been dismissed from the head writer position at OLTL in the year leading up to that (one of whom, Claire Labine, was a former WGA East president) after reported conflicts with JFP over story direction.
  • Didn't Tom Casciello say in print that one of the DOOL actresses (Kristian Alfonso?) was actively involved in writing the script for the funeral last year? Why isn't that a union violation?
  • On a lighter note, what about the alleged clause Susan Lucci had in her contract that AMC would never make Erica a grandmother, and the fact that she was never called Grandma for so long after Miranda finally was born? (I haven't watched AMC in years...has it happened?) Why hasn't the Guild been investigating whether or not Lucci ever crossed an ethical boundary by crossing out the word "Grandma" in a script?
  • More generally, why hasn't the Guild gotten involved in the past fifteen years as the locust of control has been taken more and more out of the hands of (union) writers and placed into the hands of network executives? The practice of story-telling by committee, which has been alluded to and in some cases spoken about candidly by a variety of writers, has surely compromised the status of professional writers in daytime TV as a whole moreso than this specific incident involving one (or two) shows. I've read the soap lore about the infamous Search for Tomorrow actor who was supposedly acting as head writer and ridiculously propping up his own character during the 1981 writers strike, but I don't remember ever reading anything about the legal ramifications for that. I think that is in part because he was the laughing stock of the industry and his work was shown to be amateurish and unprofessional in comparison to the union writers' work that began airing across the board as soon as the strike ended, and nothing the WGA could do to him could compare to that. Now, writers seem to be largely figureheads (at best - and surely at least some of today's writers are not nearly as talented as some of the cream of the crop who walked out in the 1981 strike who are no longer with us/working today) and the difference between Higley's product and what Ed Scott and these cast member(s) may have produced is not so self-evident.
My guess is that the WGA has chosen its battles, knowing it did not have the resources to fight all three networks on the micromanagement at large, and has concerned itself more with protecting the financial interests of guild writers even as their creative roles may be getting jerked around by higher-ups. So why are they intervening in this particular case? If it's simply a matter of Scott and the cast members in questions physically rewriting scripts and outlines by hand, is that really such a central issue here?

I'd personally rather continue to collect a paycheck and write what I want, and if someone else writes something else that makes it on the air instead of my product so be it, which appears to be Higley's deal, than have a boardroom full of executives rip to shreds something I'd spent a lot of time and effort writing and then have to personally be the one to rewrite the final product to their specifications, however ludicrous they may be, which I understand is how the process usually works. I'm not defending Scott or anyone else, but DOOL has a paid writing team (more than one, apparently - isn't James Reilly still getting paid his salary from two years ago?) and will no doubt continue to have one, so I highly doubt their internal mismanagement is going to trigger an industry trend.

I have to wonder, is Higley (whose alleged practices during the strike, if proven to be true, would certainly call into question her respect for the spirit of the WGA) the one initiating this grievance with the Guild? If so, do they actually want to take on this battle more than they have previous ones, or is she just forcing the issue more than countless other soap writers who have surely experienced their share of creative interference from non-union parties? This hardly seems like the best use of the WGA's time and resources, given the unlikelihood of this incident setting some kind of precedent, especially if it is all to protect a possible scab.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • I wasn't expecting this. Leslie was the first character I saw on GH when I started watching.

      Please register in order to view this content

    • Thanks @Paul Raven . I love that she even drew up a petition. A shame she didn't get to finish out that storyline, although it seemed to become a mess anyway.
    • It's funny to think one of the only later mentions of Justin/Sarah was in The Guiding Plight. They had some decent chemistry in the 1976 episode put out on DVD.
    • Very. They're building up his story again and picking the perfect time to do so. As the SilkPress storyline climaxes and go off in several great directions, they are building up that story to take a turn.
    • Please register in order to view this content

       
    • Please register in order to view this content

         
    • @Soapsuds Thanks for posting Night by night Mon 8pm The Rookies edged Gunsmoke but attracted younger(more desirable) viewers.NBC failed with Born Free/Smothers Brothers (how many different series did those 2 get??) 9-11pm  Maude/Rhoda/Medical Center dominated on CBS,but Football and Movies were competitive on an occasional basis. ABC tried  SWAT/Caribe later in the season and the former worked for them. Tues 8-11 pm CBS all the way Good Times, MASH, Hawaii Five O,Barnaby Jones. NBC had the fading Adam 12,Movie and Police Story mmm...don't see that listed? ABC Happy Days, which ABC decided to keep despite lackluster ratings, the Movie of the Week and Marcus Welby-once pulling big numbers but no longer. 8pm NBC had a new hit with Little House, easily beating Sons and Daughters, which was axed and replaced with Tony Orlando, which did much better. ABC had That's My Mama and the Wed movie. 9pm Cannon was the lead here as Lucas Tanner failed to capitalize on the LHOTP leadin. ABC continued the movie. 10pm Manhunter started strong for CBS but petered out and was cancelled. Petrocelli manged to beat Get Christie Love, which was replaced by Baretta-no ratings winner but ABC decided to renew. Thurs Another CBS night with The Waltons and a movie. ABC counterprogrammed with Odd Couple/Paper Moon then Barney Miller/Karen NBC did even worse with Sierra and replaced it with Mac Davis which improved ratings quite a bit. However, it was moved to 9pm for Sunshine/Bob Crane 9pm Some good numbers for ABC with Streets of San Francisco fending off Ironside,Archer and Mac Davis. 10pm Harry O had a slim victory over Movin On Fri 8-11 NBCs best night Sanford/Chico/Rockford/Police Woman. 8pm CBS had high hopes for Planet of the Apes but it bombed. Replacement Khan did even worse. Paul Sand and We'll Get By were tossed in at the end of the season. With poor lead ins the Friday movie didn't deliver. ABC's odd line up saw Kodiak flop, Six Million dollar Man struggle and Texas Wheelers  quickly cancelled. Kung Fu was brought in @8 and Six Million moved to 9. Then Kolchak took over at 8 and Hot*l Baltimore/Odd Couple 9-10. Despite controversy Hot*l flopped. 10pm ABC tried Kolchak then Baretta and finally Get Christie Love Sat CBS lead  with #1 AITF then Paul Sand/MTM/Bob Newhart/Carol Burnett. Paul Sand lost too much of the lead in so CBS spun off The Jeffersons and it was a smash. NBC did OK with Emergency (which beat Paul Sand on occasion, thus hastening that show's demise) and a movie. ABC was a disaster with New Land/Kung Fu and Nakia all failing. They introduced a movie @9 and moved Kung Fu to 8. Sun  NBC  with Disney and Mystery Movie (Columbo McCloud, MacMillan and Wife/Amy Prentiss)did well. ABC flopped with Sonny Bono and recovered by moving Six Million Dollar Man from Fri as a lead in to the movie. CBS hoped Apples Way would be another Waltons but no, so Cher did what Sonny couldn't. Kojak and Mannix successfully finished out the night. Two other shows on the ratings list were Adams of Eagle Lake starring Andy Griffith. Only 2 episodes aired and did well, so I'm not sure what happened there. As for The Law it was a series follow up to a 2 and a half hour NBC special movie .   
    • Please register in order to view this content

       
    • Please register in order to view this content

       
    • Trust is very easily lost and very hard to re-build.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy