Jump to content

ALL: When bad recasts happen to good characters!


Recommended Posts

  • Members

Maybe it was the picture and complaints I had heard about Fake/Temp Jax [since I'm not watching GH], or maybe it is the whole Greenlee debacle...but it seems like there has been a lot more talk about recasts of late and how many stink.

Can you think of any recasts, temporary or permanent, that made a once-great character suck? And ETA: This is not to say I personally thought Sabine Singh sucked as Greenlee. I cannot judge, as I never watched. But the whole thing surrounding her re-recast got me thinking!

Off the top of my head:

I was reminded of old school recast debacles in the Video Bash thread, when Taylor Miller left the role of Nina Cortlandt and Heather Stanford (then Barbara Kearns) took over the role for a year apiece. Thank God Taylor Miller returned. Stanford's Nina getting her ass whooped in that clip was amusing, though.

Anyone remember - speaking of returns and such - when Angie Hubbard was recast? Yep, it's true. Saundra Quarterman [best known from the sitcom, "Hangin' With Mr. Cooper" in the '90s] played Angie for a time, and it was bad. I was glad to see her go.

And remember when Marcy Walker left AMC for SB in '84? Liza was recast with Alice Haining, who would later go on to play Angel Snyder on ATWT. A bad fit for actress and character.

And the less said about the change from Kate Collins' spitfire Natalie Hunter Dillon to Melody Anderson's wet dishrag version, the better.

Then there was Days and Tracy Middendorf's Carrie Brady, along with Anne Howard's Kimberly Brady.

And Santa Barbara recast Lisa DiNapoli, played by Tawny Kitaen, with the future Mrs. David Duchovny, Téa Leoni. Talk about a change: From tall redhead to medium blonde, with none of the attitude.

Anyone else?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 44
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Well I'd hardly call the character of Greenlee Smythe a "good" character when she was recast.... but at her core Greenlee is a good character and was miscast horribly this year.

Amelia Heinle coming in as Victoria Newman on Y&R is one of the worst ones I've seen in recent memory.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Many loved Susan Walters as Diane Jenkins...but for me Alex Donnelly is the only actress who can fill Diane's stilettos. When Walters took over Diane lost her ferocity. She was still fun and bitchy, but she wasn't terrifying like when Donnelly played her.

Also, Amelia Heinle as Victoria is one of the worst in recent memory, Heinle sucked every bit of the bitchy fabulousness that Heather Tom injected into Victoria. Heather Tom's Victoria slapped Victor clear across the face, Heinle's Victoria went into a coma after being hit by a killer scone.

Although only a temporary replacement, Marj Dusay as Vivian Alamain (Louise Sorel was recovering from back surgery) was not good at all (and I like Marj). It was sort of Marj's dry run before playing Vanessa Bennett on AMC.

I think one of the worst was Sandra Nelson as Phyllis on Y&R in 1997/1998. She just didn't do well at all. She lacked bite, timing, everything was just off.

And this is waaaaaaaay back but in the early 80s when Jeanne Cooper went to rehab an actress by the name of Giselle McKenzie filled in for her as Katherine. Bill Bell later told Cooper that he would never have another actress sub in for her because it just didn't work because a line between Cooper and Katherine didn't really exist.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Nothing, in my mind, will ever top Jacob Young as Lucky #2. Jonathan Jackson was so incredible in that role- he brought such sympathy, integrity, and intelligence to the role. His Lucky was a true Spencer. And then JY showed up, and it was bad. Really, really bad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

To this day, I hate that GL didn't allow us to "grow up" w/ Rachel Miner as Michelle Bauer. Instead, we had to settle for Nancy St. Alban (sorry, Mannyacs) and Jesus Christ Rebecca Budig.

Also didn't care for Toby Poser as Amanda Spaulding. Not a thing about that girl suggested she was the sexually repressed girl who was raised by cunning, manipulative Lucille Wexler.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

For ATWT

Heather Rattray as Lily - So fragile, watching her performances could almost break her

Glynis O'Connor as Margo - Never was this character so homely

Susan Batten as Connor - A cougar with no sex appeal

Christina Chambers as Molly - Thankfully forgettable

Matt Cavenaugh as Adam - A middle of the road personality hardly credible as a would-be rapist

Oh, and my personal fave Roger Howarth as Paul, in his death defying highwire routine involving one expression and multiple acts of fakery

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Melody Anderson as Natalie on AMC....Kate Collins provided so much for the role and made you love to hate Natalie but also made her sympathetic. The rise and fall of Queen Natalie during her rape story proved to be one of Collins' high points in playing the character with many emotions and layers.

Andrew Ridings as JR on AMC...Jesse McCartney and Jonathan Bennett gave JR spunk, fire, a heart, and just overall strength to be a good character. Ridings comes along and makes him a moron as well as annoying and stupid. Thankfully, Jacob Young got the part and gave JR even more layers than McCartney and Bennett

Kelly Monaco as Brenda on GH....Brenda was not a favorite of mine but at least she had something going for her with VM. Then, Kelly comes along and they rename her Sam and nothing is worthy in the character

:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Re: Heather Rattray - Ironically, her Lily was supposed to be more brittle and less emotional than Martha Byrne's. That's why, for example, the bulk of her storylines revolved around Walsh Enterprises.

Re: Glynis O'Connor - Believe it or not, I thought she was pretty good as Margo. I bought her as Scott Holmes' on-screen wife, just as I do Ellen Dolan (and before her, Hillary B. Smith). Plus, she had real credibility as a woman juggling a family with a career in law enforcement. It's a shame, though, more people didn't give her a chance.

Re: Susan Batten - First of all, was Connor Walsh still relevant by the time Batten arrived? And secondly, was firing Allyson Rice-Taylor for her truly necessary? It seems to me then-EP Felicia Minei Behr had an agenda to bring along some former ABCD'ers. Thank goodness, though, she didn't get too far w/ that one. Otherwise, you might've seen Felicity LaFortune (ex-Laurel, AMC; ex-Leigh, RYAN'S HOPE) as a new Margo, and Daniel Hugh Kelly as a new Tom.

Re: Christina Chambers - Again, was it really necessary for TPTB to recast a character who wasn't as relevant anymore? Honestly, at this point, I'd just as soon pretend Molly, and mealy-mouthed Abigail, never existed.

Re: Matt Cavenaugh - Can't really blame him for that disaster. The guy he succeeded (forget his name) left rather abruptly (still would like to know what that was about), and plans for the character - that is, if JP ever has a plan for anything she does (aside, of course, from junking another piece of ATWT's legacy) - went all to pieces. That was one time when I watched a story unfold and had the distinct feeling it had spun out of control.

Re: Roger Howarth - All I can say is, whenever he's on-screen, I just close my eyes and pretend he's Andy Kavovit. (Just as I pretended all along that Grayson McCouch was just Brian Bloom w/ a weird Marlon Brando accent.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Not having watched AMC was one of the reasons I hesitated to make the comparison, tbf. It's odd--I feel like I could argue Cassie, Olivia, Harley and Dinah suffocated the show along with Reva the last five years.
    • Laurie and Lance accompany Leslie to her Denver concert and she relies me on Lance for support.Unbeknownst to Leslie, Brad has had the operator make a special connection to the concert hall so he can hear her concert. The Maestro, realizing Leslie’s emotional torment over her failing marriage, tries to persuade her to tell Brad about the baby, and when she refuses, he writes a letter to Brad betraying Leslie’s confidence. After another fight with her mother about how learning about her parentage has upset her life, Laurie confides to Leslie that she feels cut off, outside. Stuart overhears this conversation, and Leslie has to tell him the whole story. She tries to explain fairly how Jennifer had left Stuart and actually only spent one night with Bruce, and faced the truth about Laurie only when she was forced to. Stuart is livid over this |betrayal and wants to confront his wife ‘now, but her doctor calls. Her one-year mastectomy checkup was fine, but he’s discovered irregularities in her cardiogram and doesn’t want her under any stress until further tests can be made. Stuart assures Leslie he won’t tell her mother he knows about Laurie until he can do it calmly, and doesn’t tell his daughter about the cardiogram.  When Chris continues to receive obscene calls, Snapper goes straight to the Beckers’. Ron insists he was home with Nancy, and she corroborates this. When she steps between an advancing Snapper and her husband, screaming, “We don’t have a telephone. He couldn't have called Chris,” Snapper finally has to believe her, and he leaves. But moments later Karen tells Nancy that Daddy went out while Mommy was in the shower. Ron insists it was just a few moments, for cigarettes. Nancy lets it pass, but the next morning finds a whole carton of cigarettes in a drawer  and asks why he went out. Ron coldly tells her she’d  better pull herself together, she’s letting this thing with Chris make her a little insane. Nancy ponders telling Chris but decides that all Chris would do is  badmouth Ron again, and she and Karen have no one but Ron and can’t leave him. When a telephone-installation man arrives with their new phone, Nancy asks him not to put it in. But Ron arrives and orders the installation made, telling Nancy she’s trying to run his life, as his mother did. When Nancy tries to call Chris, Ron frighteningly tells Nancy he’s done  everything they said he did, but it’s all her fault, as she never gave him what he needed. When he informs her he’s taking Karen away from her before she can ruin her, Nancy collapses in a catatonic state. Ron then calmly calls the hospital and requests help for his wife, “Fran Jackson,” who has had a breakdown.  Laurie, seeing the extent to which Vanessa will go to keep Lance to herself, warns Lance that his mother’s possessive feelings are unhealthy. Lance suggests Vanessa will consider Leslie a threat also when he learns that Les and Brad are divorcing and things will get easier. As soon as the hospital attendants leave with Nancy, Ron dials Legal Aid and has Karen tell Chris she’s all alone. Stopping only to leave a message for Snapper about where she’s going, Chris rushes to the Beckers’ apartment, only to realize that Ron’s tricked her. Ron sends Karen out of the room and, after expressing his hatred for all women, tells Chris he’s going to prove to her he’s a man. But Karen wanders back in as he has Chris pinned to the wall, and Ron’s mind snaps when he realizes his daughter has seen his perverted side. After smashing the wall mirror, he runs out, and Greg, terrified at learning where Chris is, arrives to find her comforting Karen. Chris takes Karen home, and after several days of fruitless searching for Nancy, she applies for temporary guardianship of Karen. Peggy and Jack set a New Years Eve wedding date, but Stuart is terribly upset to realize how irrational and incomplete Peggy’s plans are. When she suddenly makes all pertinent decisions in the space of a half-hour, Stuart tells Jack this doesn’t indicate certainty, but rather proves his point—she’s just trying to convince herself that the rape didn’t affect hers and it did. A chance remark by Stuart shocks Laurie into realizing he knows she’s not his natural daughter. When she hysterically screams out her alienation and her innate feeling that she was always 'different' he assures her with tears in his eyes that since they really love each other sincerely, it makes no difference; she’ll always be his daughter. Stuart explains that Jen still doesn’t know he has learned the truth, and he would like it to continue that way. In helping Brad pay his bills, Laurie finds Maestro Fausch’s letter and tells Brad that Leslie is pregnant. Ironically, to get to him with this news, she had to get |away from Leslie, and used a meeting with Lance as an excuse. When ‘Lance arrives soon after, he’s angry that Laurie lied, and she later has to explain that she has been helping Brad. Understanding her motives, — Lance agrees that she should continue to press him to |reconcile with Leslie. Brad, however, still won’t reconsider—in fact, the news makes him even more resolute. But Vanessa has had Laurie followed, and hits Leslie with a double blow. She gives her the report saying this proves her sister is involved with her husband, and then assures Leslie that Lance loves her, — not Laurie. Badly confused and hurt, Leslie lashes out by kissing Lance while he sits with her at the piano. Leslie then waits at the apartment for Laurie, and when she arrives, she bitterly accuses her of having an affair with Brad. Laurie angrily assures Leslie she  was with Brad with Lance’s full knowledge and that Leslie’s anger means she still loves Brad. She then explains to Leslie that Brad left her because he’s blind. In shock, Leslie rushes home to confront Brad, furiously berating him for treating her like a child who cannot decide for herself. But Brad, even with Leslie now aware of the situation, refuses to reconcile with her. When Leslie tells Laurie how unreasonable Brad has been, Laurie suggests that Leslie stop seeing everything from her own angle only. 
    • In regards to the Reva vs Erica discussions... I think there was one main difference between the two characters.... Erica never took over/ate up airtime on All My Children.  While she was a larger than life character, she never took over the show and there were times she was even supporting and not the lead.... while Reva basically suffocated Guiding Light in the later years with her presence.
    • That was such a missed opportunity, especially with May sweeps.  And, it would’ve been a much better story for Naomi/Jacob than whatever’s going on with June 
    • https://www.hulu.com/hub/tv/collections/9979 Amazed! But loving it. What this shows is GH Hulu out of top 15, GH is #2 & this was Saturday. Are we happy campers? Yes, at least for the moment, you bet we are.
    • I forget his name but Tori Spelling and Jennie Garth had the EP on after they didn't understand the 60s flashback episode due to the lack of original music. He felt that was one of his strongest episodes so he came on to explain to them just how much the music changes hurt the series. Basically, they only allowed him to pick a selection of episodes he felt the music was vital and other than that they didn't bother to save the music.  They kept music for prom and things like the Color Me Badd episode and for most of the musical acts but any music you loved from the opening of the show or just music played in random scenes was cut.  I know there are also some scenes cut but I don't know too much about that. The most glaring one was Clare's final scene being cut which is obviously a huge problem for a character who'd been around for so long. Overall I was able to enjoy my rewatch using the DVDs but without all of the original music it isn't nearly as good a show.
    • Too many returns, that's when you know a show has run out of ideas and doesn't care anymore.  Zoe annoyed the sh!t out of me most times, but the Kat/Zoe storyline will always be iconic and close to my heart (that's the era I first started following the show in near real-time), and probably the only storyline in 21st century EastEnders that had long-term value for the characters involved during their initial run together. However, after all this time and the writing choice that Zoe never wants to see Kat again, I think that ship has sailed and I don't know that it makes sense to revisit it at this point. 
    • Former EastEnders star Michelle Ryan is reprising her role as Zoe Slater on the BBC soap following an absence of over 20 years.  It’s been reported that Zoe will return to Albert Square later this year and that she’ll take centre stage in a dramatic new storyline involving her family.  The news comes amidst news of other big returns, which include Max Branning (Jake Wood), Tanya Cross (Jo Joyner), Shirley Carter (Linda Henry) and Ben Mitchell (Max Bowden), who will also be back in Walford later in the year.
    • I actually love the new fashion.
    • Admittedly, I was a latecomer to ATWT (first becoming a regular viewer in 2000). But I really liked KMH's Emily. I thought she was a very specific kind of neurotic professional character, and I loved her prickly relationship with MM's Susan. I will say I don't think the show did her any favors after Hal died, stranding her in storylines with several of the show's dullest characters: nu-Paul, nu-Meg, and nu-Dusty. I actually quite liked one of her last major storylines, when she discovered she had a grown-up biological son with Larry named Hunter. But then Hunter just sort of disappeared, and the story fizzled out, which was pretty typical of the late Goutman years. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy