Jump to content

ALL: When bad recasts happen to good characters!


Recommended Posts

  • Members

Maybe it was the picture and complaints I had heard about Fake/Temp Jax [since I'm not watching GH], or maybe it is the whole Greenlee debacle...but it seems like there has been a lot more talk about recasts of late and how many stink.

Can you think of any recasts, temporary or permanent, that made a once-great character suck? And ETA: This is not to say I personally thought Sabine Singh sucked as Greenlee. I cannot judge, as I never watched. But the whole thing surrounding her re-recast got me thinking!

Off the top of my head:

I was reminded of old school recast debacles in the Video Bash thread, when Taylor Miller left the role of Nina Cortlandt and Heather Stanford (then Barbara Kearns) took over the role for a year apiece. Thank God Taylor Miller returned. Stanford's Nina getting her ass whooped in that clip was amusing, though.

Anyone remember - speaking of returns and such - when Angie Hubbard was recast? Yep, it's true. Saundra Quarterman [best known from the sitcom, "Hangin' With Mr. Cooper" in the '90s] played Angie for a time, and it was bad. I was glad to see her go.

And remember when Marcy Walker left AMC for SB in '84? Liza was recast with Alice Haining, who would later go on to play Angel Snyder on ATWT. A bad fit for actress and character.

And the less said about the change from Kate Collins' spitfire Natalie Hunter Dillon to Melody Anderson's wet dishrag version, the better.

Then there was Days and Tracy Middendorf's Carrie Brady, along with Anne Howard's Kimberly Brady.

And Santa Barbara recast Lisa DiNapoli, played by Tawny Kitaen, with the future Mrs. David Duchovny, Téa Leoni. Talk about a change: From tall redhead to medium blonde, with none of the attitude.

Anyone else?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 44
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Well I'd hardly call the character of Greenlee Smythe a "good" character when she was recast.... but at her core Greenlee is a good character and was miscast horribly this year.

Amelia Heinle coming in as Victoria Newman on Y&R is one of the worst ones I've seen in recent memory.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Many loved Susan Walters as Diane Jenkins...but for me Alex Donnelly is the only actress who can fill Diane's stilettos. When Walters took over Diane lost her ferocity. She was still fun and bitchy, but she wasn't terrifying like when Donnelly played her.

Also, Amelia Heinle as Victoria is one of the worst in recent memory, Heinle sucked every bit of the bitchy fabulousness that Heather Tom injected into Victoria. Heather Tom's Victoria slapped Victor clear across the face, Heinle's Victoria went into a coma after being hit by a killer scone.

Although only a temporary replacement, Marj Dusay as Vivian Alamain (Louise Sorel was recovering from back surgery) was not good at all (and I like Marj). It was sort of Marj's dry run before playing Vanessa Bennett on AMC.

I think one of the worst was Sandra Nelson as Phyllis on Y&R in 1997/1998. She just didn't do well at all. She lacked bite, timing, everything was just off.

And this is waaaaaaaay back but in the early 80s when Jeanne Cooper went to rehab an actress by the name of Giselle McKenzie filled in for her as Katherine. Bill Bell later told Cooper that he would never have another actress sub in for her because it just didn't work because a line between Cooper and Katherine didn't really exist.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Nothing, in my mind, will ever top Jacob Young as Lucky #2. Jonathan Jackson was so incredible in that role- he brought such sympathy, integrity, and intelligence to the role. His Lucky was a true Spencer. And then JY showed up, and it was bad. Really, really bad.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

To this day, I hate that GL didn't allow us to "grow up" w/ Rachel Miner as Michelle Bauer. Instead, we had to settle for Nancy St. Alban (sorry, Mannyacs) and Jesus Christ Rebecca Budig.

Also didn't care for Toby Poser as Amanda Spaulding. Not a thing about that girl suggested she was the sexually repressed girl who was raised by cunning, manipulative Lucille Wexler.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

For ATWT

Heather Rattray as Lily - So fragile, watching her performances could almost break her

Glynis O'Connor as Margo - Never was this character so homely

Susan Batten as Connor - A cougar with no sex appeal

Christina Chambers as Molly - Thankfully forgettable

Matt Cavenaugh as Adam - A middle of the road personality hardly credible as a would-be rapist

Oh, and my personal fave Roger Howarth as Paul, in his death defying highwire routine involving one expression and multiple acts of fakery

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Melody Anderson as Natalie on AMC....Kate Collins provided so much for the role and made you love to hate Natalie but also made her sympathetic. The rise and fall of Queen Natalie during her rape story proved to be one of Collins' high points in playing the character with many emotions and layers.

Andrew Ridings as JR on AMC...Jesse McCartney and Jonathan Bennett gave JR spunk, fire, a heart, and just overall strength to be a good character. Ridings comes along and makes him a moron as well as annoying and stupid. Thankfully, Jacob Young got the part and gave JR even more layers than McCartney and Bennett

Kelly Monaco as Brenda on GH....Brenda was not a favorite of mine but at least she had something going for her with VM. Then, Kelly comes along and they rename her Sam and nothing is worthy in the character

:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Re: Heather Rattray - Ironically, her Lily was supposed to be more brittle and less emotional than Martha Byrne's. That's why, for example, the bulk of her storylines revolved around Walsh Enterprises.

Re: Glynis O'Connor - Believe it or not, I thought she was pretty good as Margo. I bought her as Scott Holmes' on-screen wife, just as I do Ellen Dolan (and before her, Hillary B. Smith). Plus, she had real credibility as a woman juggling a family with a career in law enforcement. It's a shame, though, more people didn't give her a chance.

Re: Susan Batten - First of all, was Connor Walsh still relevant by the time Batten arrived? And secondly, was firing Allyson Rice-Taylor for her truly necessary? It seems to me then-EP Felicia Minei Behr had an agenda to bring along some former ABCD'ers. Thank goodness, though, she didn't get too far w/ that one. Otherwise, you might've seen Felicity LaFortune (ex-Laurel, AMC; ex-Leigh, RYAN'S HOPE) as a new Margo, and Daniel Hugh Kelly as a new Tom.

Re: Christina Chambers - Again, was it really necessary for TPTB to recast a character who wasn't as relevant anymore? Honestly, at this point, I'd just as soon pretend Molly, and mealy-mouthed Abigail, never existed.

Re: Matt Cavenaugh - Can't really blame him for that disaster. The guy he succeeded (forget his name) left rather abruptly (still would like to know what that was about), and plans for the character - that is, if JP ever has a plan for anything she does (aside, of course, from junking another piece of ATWT's legacy) - went all to pieces. That was one time when I watched a story unfold and had the distinct feeling it had spun out of control.

Re: Roger Howarth - All I can say is, whenever he's on-screen, I just close my eyes and pretend he's Andy Kavovit. (Just as I pretended all along that Grayson McCouch was just Brian Bloom w/ a weird Marlon Brando accent.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Kobe/Long had their own template and pretty much gutted the cast. As soon as contracts were up established characters were dropped. They needed to free the budget for the new characters. Going back to Ann,I wonder why the Dobsons renewed her contract around 78? After her initial story she became supporting and they didn't seem to want to pursue a romance with Mike. Maybe the feedback was that viewers blamed her indirectly for Leslie's death. If Mike hadn't taken on her case etc. Did she decide not to disrupt her son's life? Seems odd after everything she didn't claim him back. 1976 continues... Joe Werner is just not bouncing back after his recovery as he should, and Sarah, concerned about his sometimes morbid-seeming depression, consults Justin Marler. They agree that Joe is becoming a “cardiac cripple,” and know this kind of overcompensation for illness and overprecaution can not only be a permanently depressed condition but can actually cause a setback for him physically.  Marler releases Joe into Sarah’s care, but it’s soon apparent that just being out of the hospital hasn’t done anything to boost Joe’s spirits about his return to a normal existence. Marler finally lays it out to Joe—the choice has to be his. He can choose to lead a normal, productive life as a doctor and as a husband to the best wife he could have, or he can choose to become an invalid and live on the outside looking in for the rest of his days, sentencing Sarah to the same fate. Realizing the selfishness of what he’s doing to —Sarah as well as the narrowness of the confinement he’s set for himself, Joe begins to see his preoccupation with his illness as the self-pity it really is and decides he’s ready to return to the hospital for a one hour shift each day. Sarah is overjoyed by his turnabout, but full happiness is hers on the day she overhears Joe telling a fearful patient that the world is beautiful and worth any. effort to get back into it. Steve and Adam are thrilled to learn that Cedars has been the recipient of the Levy Grant for expansion of hospital property. But they have learned, as they report to Ed, that the land they were hoping to build the new research facility on, the land immediately adjacent to the hospital, has been purchased by Dr. Justin Marler. Both Adam and Steve feel that Justin is expanding a power base at Cedars and the land purchase is just one more block in Justin’s power play. When Ed asks Marler why he purchased this particular parcel of land, Marler explains that he bought it with the express intention of someday building his own offices and facilities convenient to the major facilities of Cedars. When the subject of the hospital’s needing the land arises, Marler meets with Adam, and they agree that he should realize a fair profit from his property and that an unbiased assessor should be engaged to evaluate the market value of the land so they can agree on a selling price. When Sarah comments on the fact that Marler is to realize a profit on the land, he bitterly replies that no matter what he’s done since coming to Cedars to prove that he has changed. since she last knew him, she refuses to see him as anything but what he was all those years ago. Sarah insists this isn’t true. But Marler then calls Adam for a meeting and informs him that the land is not for sale at any price. As Adam begins to grow alarmed, Marler continues that the site for the new building will be his personal donation to the hospital. As Adam expresses profuse thanks and appreciation, Marler wryly notes that the tax deductions he’ll realize on this contribution to a charitable institution will benefit himself almost as much as Cedars. When Steve Jackson learns that Marler is to be elected head of the research wing that will be built on his property, he expresses the conviction that this was the exact intention of the gift. Adam, however, assures Steve that the donation wasn’t a factor in the hospital  board’s decision, they were concerned only with Dr. Marler’s reputation as a doctor. | After lengthy consultations and meetings. with the hospital  staff, Ed assured by the head nurse that her nurses performed commendably despite the added pressure of the train wreck, presents his findings to the hospital review board. Steve arrives at two possible explanations for the facts. Either Grainger, more active than usual due to the previously delayed medication, reached for the writing pad and inadvertently disconnected the breathing tubes, or he was in a state of extreme upset because of the delayed medication and.in the excitement a surge of adrenalin within his system caused his brain aneurism to start hemorrhaging. " Upon learning that the review board has ruled out negligence in Grainger’s death, Ed tells Rita, who takes her first free breath in a long time. But Ed hasn’t thought to tell Rita that he’s been in touch with Grainger’s attorney, Mr. Schafer, who, knowing that a woman was at the base of Grainger’s investigation, is coming to Springfield to try to find out who the woman - was who walked out on Grainger when he collapsed —in the restaurant. Peggy, learning that Rita’s “forgetting” to deliver Holly’s message was instrumental in their divorce ‘being finalized, tells Ed that Holly wanted to reach him to stop the divorce. Immediately after, Peggy is torn by doubts, wondering if she did the right thing.She confides in Barbara, who then discusses the situation with Ed. He tells her he and Holly have discovered a new closeness now that they are building their separate lives. Barbara quickly contradicts him: Holly is not building a new life. Barbara gently cautions Ed, saying, “People change, feelings change, and what seems right now may not be right a year from now. No decision is irrevocable.” Ed agrees with this. Now that Ben has declared his love for her, Hope finds herself apprehensive, fearing that she might be making a mistake, as she did a few years ago, when she was sure she was in love with her college professor. Explaining that she doesn’t want to make another mistake, she asks Ben to be patient, and he agrees. When Mike expresses his disapproval of Ben’s overstated independence, his need to be beholden to no one, Hope quickly jumps to Ben’s defense, and Mike apologizes. But Ben, surprisingly, accepts Mike’s assessment as constructive criticism. Later Hope, examining her feelings and desires, tells Ben she does love him and wants to belong to him. Later that evening, after they’ve made love, Ben asks Hope to marry him.And, delighted, she replies that she will. At Hope’s instigation, Bert has a family dinner to which Ben is invited, and Hope announces their intention to marry over glasses of wine. Mike politely offers best wishes while Bert thrills the couple with her offer to' make a Christmas wedding for them. Bert later tells Mike he must accept this engagement with good spirits for Hope, and later, seeing the joy she’s feeling, he gives his daughter his approval. But Ben finds another problem on his very own doorstep: his brother Jerry, who announces he’s left home after several bad fights with their parents. He refuses to tell Ben what they were fighting about. As Ben is showering, Jerry borrows his car and goes out for an hour. The phone rings, but Ben can’t hear it. Shortly after, two uniformed officers visit Mike at home to tell him that his late wife’s car has been involved in a delicatessen robbery earlier in the evening. Since Ben bought Leslie’s car, Mike accompanies the officers to Ben’s apartment. Ben curtly informs the police that he had nothing to do with the robbery and makes it clear that he feels they wouldn’t be there if he didn’t have a record and that his exoneration doesn’t prevent his being hassled like any ex-con,as they tell him he has to go to the police station for questioning. Hope tells Ben she called him earlier, and when he replies that he must have been in the shower, she accepts his word unhesitatingly.Jerry finally returns to Ben’s place and under questioning from Ben admits that he robbed the store,explaining that he has debts. Ben is now in a quandary,as he feels he must protect his brother but doesn’t want to be unfair to Hope. He tries to ease the situation by withdrawing $185 from the joint checking account he opened with Hope and repaying the delicatessen owner. He then sends Jerry out of town to stay with a friend. His relief at having solved the problem is short-lived, however, when Mike informs him that, despite the reparations, the robbery was a felony and the police will continue to investigate. Hope is badly upset to learn while making a deposit that Ben withdrew’a sum which Mike tells her is equal to the amount stolen. This shakes her belief that he _was really home when she called, and she goes to him, asking for an answer to put her mind at rest. Ben can’t betray Jerry and asks Hope to trust him, promising she will have the whole story eventually. But Hope can’t accept this; she needs complete honesty and openness in her relationship and without it cannot goon. She painfully tells her father that the wedding is off despite her love for Ben, and tells Bert to stop preparations. Mike goes to Ben, reminding him that half the money in the account is Hope’s and she has the right to an answer. But Ben won’t say any more and refuses Mike’s offer to represent him legally, again stating that he doesn’t need a lawyer, because he’s done nothing wrong.     
    • And not since. I recall it was quite small for a house that size. And I don't know why you would walk down a narrow corridor to get to the main living area. I hate when the sets on soaps don't have a logical layout! As for Andre his clothing is fashion forward and suitable for his character.He ain't gonna wear no blazer!
    • The last I remember seeing Ben, he was divorcing Amanda. He came to tell Evie that he still loved her, but was leaving town so that Amanda wouldn't blame Evie for his divorcing her. I'm not exactly sure when, but Evie doesn't leave town until sometime after Nola and Quint's engagement ball. I'm not sure if she leaves before or after Justin leaves in Sept(?) of '83. I grew to like Helena when she became friends with Vanessa, once she's edging her way out of Quint's life.
    • Please register in order to view this content

    • Please register in order to view this content

       
    • It sure was!  With respect, how does that make sense?  These men are young, I don't see that. 
    • I hope this played better than it sounds, because I'm imagining two separate scenes (the attack by Arnie, and later Charles getting shot). In my mind, it should have been a fluid single sequence. I wonder if or how often "bastard" was uttered in this scene. Fare thee well, Christopher Reeve. I've said it before, but pop culture's gain was daytime's definite loss. Imagine seeing HIM day after day, year after year, decade after decade, conceivably until they stopped producing soaps in NYC.   Well, that answers my "bastard" question. Good lord, the roads of Rosehill are packed with high-strung drivers and/or pedestrians. More sequences that I hope played better than they sound.

      Please register in order to view this content

    • I think Ben had already left while under Marland and only returned briefly to reconcile with Eve. The whole thing confuses me as I thought for a long time that Eve left the show to go be with him and that was when they reconciled, but it seems like he returned, they got back together, then he left and maybe they were still together until she left to join him? I have no idea.  It does seem like the interim writers were using some characters like Justin and Helena who were quickly dumped under Kobe/Long, which is a shame. Helena is one of those characters who likely always had a shelf life but Rose Alaio was such a vibrant screen presence, if Kobe/Long had just been patient, she likely would have fit in well in the Reva era.
    • Also, the lawsuit story was not the right story to bring Naomi and Bill into a court battle since those types of lawsuits are usually resolved via settlements.
    • I know that Sara did eventually become Carrie's therapist, but I was curious if the show had her make comments regarding Carrie's stunts of making it seem as though Justin was cheating on Jackie.  Given that Justin cheated on Sara with both Jackie and Brandy, I wondered if it was wise of her to counsel Carrie given the conflict of interest involved. @DRW50I think once Adam/Sara end up married.. Marland didn't see any reason to explore Sara's personal life after the actor playing Adam was released.  I know that Sara lasts until at least Christmas 1982 on the show.. but I don't think she ended up staying on for very long into 1983. The period between Marland quitting and Pam Long starting was the perfect time to clean house on characters that had outgrown their usefulness  (i.e. Ben, Evie, Sara, Jennifer, Morgan).. and tying up stories started by Marland that were too complex (Mona Enright, Mark/Jennifer/Amanda triangle).
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy