ALL: Soap Actors You'd Like To See Face-Off

November 17, 200718 yr

Member

Which two iconic soap actors would you like to see in the same scene? A daytime equivalent to Joan Crawford and Bette Davis in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? or Robert DeNiro and Al Pacino in Heat.

My picks:

Beverlee McKinsey and Elizabeth Hubbard (the two P&G corporate divas of the '80s, Alexandra Spaulding and Lucinda Walsh, having it out)

Heather Tom and Sarah Brown (posh bitch vs. working-class bitch)

Christian LeBlanc and Trent Dawson (smart, slightly prissy zinger-slingers)

Who are your picks?

Replies 14
Views 2.8k
Created 18 yr18 yr
Last Reply 18 yr18 yr

November 17, 200718 yr

Member

Alexis Carrington Colby (Joan Collins) vs Iris Cory Carrington Wheeler (Carmen Duncan). Accent wielding diva vs accent wielding diva.

Katherine Chancellor (Jeanne Cooper) vs Felicia Gallant (Linda Dano). Alcoholic grand dame vs alcoholic grand dame.

Victor Newman (Eric Braeden) vs Roger Thorpe (Michael Zaslow). Evil tycoon vs evil tycoon.

Edited November 17, 200718 yr by DaytimeFan

November 17, 200718 yr

Member

Alexis Carrington Colby (Joan Collins) vs Iris Cory Carrington Wheeler (Carmen Duncan). Accent wielding diva vs accent wielding diva.

Katherine Chancellor (Jeanne Cooper) vs Felicia Gallant (Linda Dano). Alcoholic grand dame vs alcoholic grand dame.

Victor Newman (Eric Braeden) vs Roger Thorpe (Michael Zaslow). Evil tycoon vs evil tycoon.

How about Iris Cory (Bev Mckensey) and Alexandra Spauding (Bev Mckensey)..now there's a fight!

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Michael Zaslow and Anthony Herrera - Roger Thorpe vs. James Stenbeck in a steel cage fight to the finish match. :lol:

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Vanessa Marcil's Brenda vs Sarah Brown's Carly on GH

GH's Tracy Quartermaine vs ATWT Lucinda Walsh

In who's the worst doctor, GL's Rick Bauer and Days Lexie Carver

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Lucinda Walsh (Elizabeth Hubbard) vs. Stephanie Forrester (Susan Flannery), that would be fun to watch

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Jane Elliot vs. Susan Flannery.

Ronn Moss vs. Drake Hogestyn.

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Ronn Moss vs, Drake Hogestyn???? For what, worst actor of all time??

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Lisa Rinna vs. Cameron Mathison for the title of soaps' biggest media whore. :lol:

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Ronn Moss vs, Drake Hogestyn???? For what, worst actor of all time??

Lisa Rinna vs. Cameron Mathison for the title of soaps' biggest media whore.

ROFL at both these posts :lol:

Edited November 18, 200718 yr by ReddFoxx

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

ATWT's Carly Snyder (Maura West) vs. GH's Carly Jacks (Laura Wright)

GL's Alan Spaulding (Ron Raines) vs. AMC's Adam Chandler (David Canary)

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

AMC's Erica Kane (Susan Lucci) vs. ANOTHER WORLD's Rachel Cory (Victoria Wyndham), w/ the added possibility of Wyndham playing Erica's secret stepmother.

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Which two iconic soap actors would you like to see in the same scene? A daytime equivalent to Joan Crawford and Bette Davis in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? or Robert DeNiro and Al Pacino in Heat.

My picks:

Beverlee McKinsey and Elizabeth Hubbard (the two P&G corporate divas of the '80s, Alexandra Spaulding and Lucinda Walsh, having it out)

Heather Tom and Sarah Brown (posh bitch vs. working-class bitch)

Christian LeBlanc and Trent Dawson (smart, slightly prissy zinger-slingers)

Who are your picks?

You know Joan Crawford and Bette Davis on a soap, that would have been big.

But i have heard of from many sites that they loathed playing against eachother, so that would have been a lot of bickering, maybe that wouldn`t haven been so nice, but i agree that they two together where fun to see on movies.

What ever happened to Baby Jane, that is one classic great film. I must say if i have to choose one, i actually think Bette where a little better, but Joan where great also!...

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Roger Howarth (as Todd Manning) and Scott Bryce (Craig Montgomery)

Robin Strasser (Dorian Lord) and Colleen Zenk Pinter (Barbara Ryan)

Erika Slezak (Viki Carpenter) and Elizabeth Hubbard (Lucinda Walsh)

Melody Thomas Scott (Nikki Newman) and Susan Lucci (Erica Kane)

I would have loved to see a OLTL/GH crossover with Todd and Tea Manning working with Sonny Corinthos and Alexis Davis.

Most pathetic contest

Marie Wilson (Meg Montgomery) and Kassie Depaiva (Blair Cramer)

November 18, 200718 yr

Member

Scott Bryce vs. Hunt Block to decide once and for all who the ultimate Craig Montgomery really is.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

No registered users viewing this page.

R.I.P.: Anthony Geary has passed away

It's too bad that there weren't better writers for Geary's final years with the show, writers that could have done justice and given a proper closure to Luke and the pairing of Luke and Laura. That attempt in 2015 to explain the character of Luke by revealing he killed his parents was so bad. And then having Luke's final adventure be a quick return of Frank Smith; truly horrible and beneath everyone.
It would have been interesting to see what Guza might have done to bring the character of Luke to a close.

By Jdee43 · 21 minutes ago21 min
Another World Discussion Thread

I know what you mean - I feel that way when I try to go through ATWT and GL from 93-95 or so.
Any thoughts you have on this episode or DAYS or The Doctors I would enjoy reading. DAYS of this period in particular is something I'd always love knowing more about.

By DRW50 · 22 minutes ago22 min
One Life to Live Tribute Thread

Thanks @Maxim I appreciate the details about the changes you think Griffith is making, and the various books Malone is adapting to Llanview.
The main reason for the change in this story is soon Clint Ritchie will be offscreen for a good long while due to having an accident on his ranch.
I knew Lindsay was there for Clint, but I wasn't expecting her to also make a play for Sloan.
It's as if Marty and Lindsay have been conjured up to make Viki pay for her wicked ways.
I wonder if they may have originally planned to reveal that Lindsay was on Dorian's payroll.

By DRW50 · 24 minutes ago24 min
Another World Discussion Thread

It's interesting; back in 1979, I was disappointed in all three of these soaps, because to me, DAYS had fallen apart in early 1977 with the dismissal of Pat Falken Smith, AW had been crippled by the cast massacre of 1975 and the continuing decline in its writing, and The Doctor had also been the victim of poor writing under various scribes like Mel and Ethel Brez and Linda Grover. BUT! With modern-day viewing of episodes from this period, my criticisms are less harsh than they once were. While I still lament the less-than-stellar quality, the shows are/were much better than we have seen on daytime for a long time. Just seeing familiar faces is a treat in itself.
Thanks for the tag.

By vetsoapfan · 26 minutes ago26 min
Y&R: Old Articles

No nepotism… Right. They started all at the bottom. Especially Lauralee. With a character on Daddys Soap and as a Front burner lol That’s definitely the bottom of it all.

By AMCOLTLLover · 28 minutes ago28 min
Another World Discussion Thread

That would have been an interesting turn.
Lemay would have had a big curveball to deal with due to Beverlee leaving. I wonder how he would have reshaped the canvas.

By DRW50 · 37 minutes ago37 min
Guiding Light Discussion Thread

Didn't Holly just come back for a visit and Pam was impressed by Maureen Garrett? Decided to bring her on full time?

By Paul Raven · 3 hours ago3 hr
Y&R: Old Articles

No I don't believe she is . You would think that link would be very widely known. When Bill spoke about first working with Irna that connection was never mentioned.

By Paul Raven · 3 hours ago3 hr
BTG: History, Behind the Scenes Articles & Photos

It came across as though he thinks gay guys are so far away from his persona as to be unplayable.
Whereas in reality there are plenty of gay guys who present the way Ted (and Maurice) do.

By Paul Raven · 3 hours ago3 hr
GH: December 2025 Discussion Thread

I loathe that dayplayer.

By Taoboi · 3 hours ago3 hr

Sign In

ALL: Soap Actors You'd Like To See Face-Off

Featured Replies

Archived

Recently Browsing 0

Recent Posts

R.I.P.: Anthony Geary has passed away

Another World Discussion Thread

One Life to Live Tribute Thread

Another World Discussion Thread

Y&R: Old Articles

Another World Discussion Thread

Guiding Light Discussion Thread

Y&R: Old Articles

BTG: History, Behind the Scenes Articles & Photos

GH: December 2025 Discussion Thread

Important Information

Account

Navigation

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)

Chrome (Desktop)

Safari (iOS 16.4+)

Safari (macOS)

Edge (Android)

Edge (Desktop)

Firefox (Android)

Firefox (Desktop)