Jump to content

SaBa: Did Kim Zimmer destroy the show?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 29
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

What is this Marland? A Let's Bait Junior Thread? :lol:

Kim Zimmer didn't single-handedly destroy the show, no (Head Writer Pamela Long deserves much of the credit...) but she certainly didn't help. Jodie Walker was nothing like Reva Shayne. She was pretty dull, a lower-middle-class housewife. Actually, the ENTIRE Walker family was dull, a rare quality for an SB character, let alone an ENTIRE family.

Sydney Penny's BJ- BO-RING!

Eric Close's Sawyer- With a name like that, how interesting do YOU think he was? Sawyer Walker? Sounds like a [!@#$%^&*] fisherman to me.

Kim Zimmer's Jodie- Zzzzzzzzzzzz, here Jodie/Kim- here's a prop- go play in your corner now and chew on it.

Unfortunately, the only dangerous part of having Mattson & Zimmer on the same show was that Zimmer sucked up all the airtime while Mattson was an afterthought. When Pam Long brought Jodie & the Walkers on, they literally BECAME the show and all of the colorful, interesting, three-dimensional characters we'd come to know and love (CC, Sophia, Gina, Lionel, Julia, Mason) were severely backburnered.

To be quite honest, as much as I LOATHED Zimmer on SB, she wasn't the worst part of the final year for me.

That honor, of course, belongs to the one and only Eileen Davidson, who to this day rates as the worst Re-Cast of ALL TIME as SB's Kelly.

The thing about Kim is that she made it pretty obvious that she felt that she was going to be Santa Barbara's savior. Instead, she, Davidson and Pam Long together became the disease that destroyed it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Kim Zimmer is larger than life as is Reva. Jodie Walker was and still is to me one of the most boring and painfully dull characters of all time. The Walker family was introduced and shoved down our faces in so many storylines it was ludicrious. What bothered me the most was the "love story" of Warren and BJ. It was like GH's Sonny and Emily, a trainwreck. I was so young, it seemed like child molestation to me because BJ seemed so young and Warren seemed so old.

Santa Barbara recast almost every person on that show which hurt it a lot. I agree with Junior, Eileen Davidson was horribly miscast. All I can remember is her wearing a stupid beret and wanting her off the screen. Even the Playmate Kelly was better than ED.

The last year was so out of control, it was painful to watch

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

After Marcy Walker left in August 1991 the show became boring and uninteresting. Not becaus e Marcy was gone but the whole show changed so much, too many new characters, no use of history and bad recasts like Kelly, Lily and Ted. The only good thing were Lionel, Gina and Minx. I hated the Walker clan, we saw them almost every day, it was to much.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I was a loyal viewer of Santa Barbara for a majority of the time the show was on the air. But once Pam Long came and got her fave, Kim Zimmer, to come aboard, in addition to the hack EP that was Paul Roach...er, Rauch, the show changed irrevocably for the worse.

First we had the HORRIBLE recast of Eileen Davidson as Kelly Capwell. No way in hell, if Marcy Walker was still there, would her Kelly ever have passed as the younger sister. (And it did not help that before even airing, ED shot her mouth off in SOW, basically putting down her predecessor [Carrington Garland - who should NEVER have been fired!], saying that Kelly would finally have some intelligence. Low.)

Then you had the Capwells and Lockridges, the very backbone of the soap, with all their quirks, shoved aside for the blue-collar coma-inducing Walker clan. Everyone - Reese, Jodie, Sawyer, and BJ - sucked. They did not fit with the fabric of the show, but that did not stop Pam Long. By God, she'd make them fit! Going so far as to retcon Cruz as having a child with Jodie back when they were teens (BJ) - and having Cruz leave the show not to find the love of his life, Eden, but for something to do with BJ. Utter crap.

And Julia and Mason, my fave couple, became wallpaper when not in some ridiculous mansion-ghost story debacle. ALL the main characters were shoved aside for the new family. In doing so, the quirky nature of SB was no more. Who wanted to see the Capwells and Lockridges when we could see Jodie and Reese? And add in that Jack Wagner's Warren [good actor, bad recast] had more chemistry with both Nina Arvesen's Angela and Karen Moncrieff's Cassandra [and I hated Cassie as she was the third wheel in Mason/Julia! But she and JW did have great chemistry!] but were BOTH shoved aside for BJ, and the suckitude progressed. And Sawyer, the son played by Eric Close, was just as boring. Hell, his girlfriend, Aurora, was a snooze. And even Aurora's father, Micah, played by none other than Thaao Penghlis, couldn't save it.

If you somehow ever see the finale, it is sadder than hell that it ended on a wedding for a couple [Warren/BJ] who, to me, sucked...and about some random woman [Krista Tesreau, Andie - scary I recall her name] trying to kill Jodie with bits of Mason/Julia thrown in...and the show ended with a whimper after having so many years of big bangs.

Pamela Long only cared about showcasing Jodie, much as Pam Long showcased Reva on GL. The trouble is, KZ earned it on GL. She did NOT earn it on SB. And in not doing her homework in what made SB stand out, Pam Long and Paul Rauch killed the show and made it mediocre to downright painful. (One example was Ted Capwell marrying Lily Blake [Lily Light, who did not age in five years!]. He DESPISED Lily and all that she stood for years ago with Hayley and whatnot. No way in HELL would Ted have ever forgiven her, let alone married her! Another was the DRASTIC de-SORASing of Minx, Lionel's mom. Janis Paige was a fine actress. But she was NOT Minx Lockridge by any means.)

(Rauch was just as bad, wanting Augusta [Louise Sorel] to fall for her sister's [Julia, played by NLG] own rapist. She balked. Augusta was made into a drunk, and Louise Sorel quit. Good for her!)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I still remember when Santa Barbara, in this period, tried ED's Kelly with Stephen Nichols' Skylar Gates! I had never seen Stephen have anti-chemistry before. But wow, that was bad. No wonder he was only on SB for like six months before going poof!

On the upside, I still recall a few random scenes with NLG's Julia, and they had a nice vibe even before GH.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The Walkers were horrible. The constant focus on them caused me to tune out SB for good and I never did get to see the final episode. They were too boring and one-note for a soap that focused on entertaining, over-the-top, larger-than-life characters. Then the writers tried to do a Cruz/Kelly romance and that went over like a lead balloon.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Kim Zimmer did not kill Santa Barbara, NBC KILLED Santa Barbara. The show changed dramatically without A Martinez and Marcy Walker, but it was still enjoyable. I always had hope that they would one day return. Unfortunately, they never had the opportunity to come back. After the Dobsons were reinstated at SB that was the final nail in the shows coffin.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Last installment of 76 Felicia is horrified to arrive in Rosehill and discover that Charles has been in a coma since the night she left. She spends every moment at his bedside and, learning that a friend had a promise to God produce favorable results in a similar crisis, vows to give Eddie up forever in exchange for Charles’s recovery. Shortly after her prayer Felicia is told that Charles has rallied and has regained consciousness. Felicia now is determined to avoid Eddie and honor her promise. Bruce explains to Lynn that he must contact her parents or he and Van could be legally charged for allowing a minor child to live with them without parental consent. Bruce doubts Lynn’s assurance that her parents could care less, and is shocked when he discovers for himself that Lynn’s mother is as unfeeling as the girl has claimed. He informs a delighted Lynn that he plans to become her legal guardian.
    • I think that worked, but not as much by the late '80s, where I think they started getting things wrong with Mack.  I do respect Kevin Dobson, who did well when he was given the material he deserved (like the story with Jason).
    • 1976 Pt 2 The Organization has retained Michael Selby to represent their hit men. The district attorney recognizes his opponent as a noted courtroom specialist and knows he has his work cut out for him. Raising technicality after technicality, Selby quickly eliminates Lieutenant Price’s testimony implicating Bailey and Jerry’s testimony about Heather’s being assaulted. ‘Then, after cutting Julian’s testimony out as common knowledge, Selby goes straight to the heart of the  prosecution’s case. He demands that Carrie be produced now, sure that she’s been taken by the Organization. To Selby’s horror and shock, the doors open and Carrie walks in, and the courtroom explodes into pandemonium. As soon as the judge can restore order, Carrie is sworn in and begins her testimony. When court recesses for the day, Steve is confronted by another Organization man, Franklin, who questions him about why he took Carrie away. Steve tells him that Carrie was so frightened by the hit man lurking around that he saw his opportunity to be alone with her and “score.” Steve then adds that she wasn’t at all cooperative or friendly—she just cried all the  time—so he dumped her. He insists he has no idea how the police got her after that. Franklin accepts his story, and Steve learns that his next test is to testify to just what he’s told Franklin, omitting, of course, the reference to the hit man. Carrie insists upon a meeting with Steve and begs him not to go underground. He tells her he can’t back out now; you can’t go through life letting somebody  else do it all the time. Steve takes this opportunity to inform Lieutenant Price that he has to dump on Carrie on the witness stand for the Organization, but he can’t stop now. Julian, irate that Selby has blocked any reference to Nurse Fellowes’s disappearance and murder, as she was the only witness who could corroborate Carrie’s testimony, confronts Selby on this evasion. Selby | coldly tells Julian that there is no concrete connection between the nurses’ death and anything else that’s happened in this case and that to bring it into this trial would be a miscarriage of law. Julian, realizing  that it all falls on Carrie’s shoulders now, warns her that Selby will be out for blood; he has to make the court believe she’s lying.  The next day the district attorney introduces Carrie’s tape recorder. The tape, burned, as is the recorder, is barely audible. Selby calls for a mistrial, claiming that his clients’ reputations have been damaged enough. As the judge calls a recess: to consider the motion before the bench, the district attorney admits that he predicted everything Selby would do to this point, but had not guessed about this motion. If it works and there’s a new trial, Carrie is in far greater danger.  Steve now tells Castor that either he’s working for  the Organization as of now or he’s going to look elsewhere for a job. Castor offers the rainy weather as an excuse to wait before contacting “him,” because “the iron in him’Il be driving him crazy.” Realizing that this is a lead, Steve starts to write it down. When he is nearly caught, he warns himself that from now on  everything he learns will have to be kept in his head.  As soon as possible, he passes the “iron” clue along to Julian. The district attorney gains a respite when the judge  turns down the mistrial motion, but the tape has been disallowed also, ruled inadmissible. So it’s Selby’s turn to cross-examine Carrie. When he forces her to admit that she never actually saw the hit man, Selby turns to the jury and informs them that this proves she’s been lying. He then suggests this has all been a plot to boost the circulation of the newspaper she works for. Selby then goes to work on Carrie’s personal morals. Since she’s admitted that she and Steve spent three days in the apartment, alone together, he asks questions and makes insinuations designed to make the jury believe this was actually a sleazy affair. To Carrie’s horror, he then calls the landlady, Mrs. Wilson who testifies that that Steve and Carrie,registered as Mr. and Mrs. Clark, spent the three days in question drinking and partying with loud music and assorted other sounds coming from their rooms until late each night. Carrie rises to her feet and screams at Mrs. Wilson, ““You’re lying!” Steve is served with a subpena.  Joe Castor visits “the man”: Fred Harrington! Castor gives Harrington his report on Steve. He thinks Steve, with his computerlike mind, could be invaluable in helping the Organization work out money-exchange problems. Harrington tells Castor he wants the trial over as soon as possible, no matter how it goes. Those men are expendable; he has a bigger problem: Julian.
    • Given the weird fantasies/out of town barn trips she does for Reva/Kyle, I can't see it either. (Not to mention Kyle's obsessive talking to paintings, or Billy's nightmares.)
    • She would be great, but I of course am thinking of her in What's Love Got to Do with It.
    • Agreed that they had a home in the present tense of the first set of episodes.  But I was wondering if they lived in the mansion in the past when Sophia disappeared, and moved out when Santana got pregnant?  Or even when Danny was born.
    • According to the French Santa Barbara site the Andrades had a house in the early episodes.  I thought I remembered scenes in their home. The Andrade house
    • I always wondered if the Andrades lived at the Capwell Mansion?  Certainly they could've had a living room in their space or wherever they went on days off. But, I felt like it was never clear whether Santana visited Rosa when Kelly and Eden were young, or if she actually lived in the servant's quarters (one hopes modern developers have found a euphemism for that space).  I always imagined that Rosa, Santana, and Reuben lived with CC up until Channing was murdered, and then they found their own place because the kids were mostly over 18 (and Santana was pregnant). I like the idea of Rueban and CC being close until Santana got pregnant.  And then Reuben would've hated the adoption of Brandon.  Which would have meant he hated CC, and would've only continued to work for him to try to get info on whatever happened to his grandson. With regard Ava Lazar, having recently rewatched the pilot for the millionth time, I find her captivating to watch, but her line delivery is so dull. She looks amazing, and I just want her to be more quick witted.
    • I liked the original 4 family set up.  The families were all different from each other and were intertwined.  They should have been given equal airtime. I felt that Lockridges were perfectly cast with the exception of Laken.  She should have been quickly recast.   I liked all 4 of the actors cast as the Andrades and wish they would have been given better writing.  I really thought Ava Lazar (Santana) would have been one of the breakout stars if she had not been replaced. My only issue with the casting of the Perkins family was Robert Alan Browne as John and as much as I liked Mark Arnold he was the wrong actor to recast Joe Perkins. And of course it was ridiculous how badly they screwed up the casting of CC. The other Capwells were well cast.
    • This late 1976 stuff doesn't sound as bad as it has in other versions I've read (weekly recaps from Jon-Michael Reed and SOD synopses). I am surprised that there is a variation of Ian - Meg - Arlene - Tom playing out this late in the game, but it doesn't sound half bad. Ian's involvement with Beaver Ridge and how it impacts Rick and Cal's future also intrigued me  more than I expected. Even the Carrie - Betsy connection having Carrie watch Suzanne while Ben is visiting was a nice surprise. I feel like this all falls apart pretty quickly with the arrival of Mia Marriott, Michael Blake, and a slew of other half baked characters under Upton.  
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy