Grant refuses Emma's invitation to join her and her family for Thanksgiving dinner. He says that he and Lisa already made plans with Roxie and her new man friend.

Emma is ecstatic though when Lucinda, Sierra, Lily, Holden, Lucy, Luke, Maddie, Faith, Natalie, Jack, Carly, Parker, J.J., and Sage all come over for the Snyder's annual Thanksgiving dinner. Emma asks where Craig is and Sierra says that he was having dinner alone to avoid any scrutiny. They all discuss their opinion on whether or not Craig has truly changed...but none seems to buy it. They also all welcome Lucy back from the hospital. Just then, there's a knock at the door and everyone wonders who it could be....

Tom, Emily, and Erin all settle in for Thanksgiving at the Hughes residence. Kim, Bob, and Nancy debate on whether or not to confront Erin about her lies and her obvious connection to Jason Summers. Just then, Andy walks through the door...back from Spain. As Andy and Emily reunite, the doorbell rings and everyone wonders who it could be....

Ben and Jessica sit down at their home for a quick bite to eat before they return to work. Jessica talks of the murder trail that has officially ruined her holiday spirit. Ben tells of how short handed they've been at the hospital lately and how he's debationg whether or not to fill in tonight. As he's talking, the doorbell rings and the happy couple wonders who it is...

John and Roxie cancel their dinner plans with Grant and Lisa and upon hearing that Andy is back in town, they decide to crash the Hughes's holiday dinner.

Henry and Jason are worried when they can't get through to Margo, Jack, Mike, or Lyla. They look at the Thanksgiving meal they prepared and worry that nobody will be there to eat it.

In the Carolinas, the search team slowly exits their vehicle and find that they're in the middle of nowhere. Jack worries aloud to Lyla if she was right about her "hunch". Lyla tells Jack to suck it up and be a man...as the team looks for Katie. Meanwhile, a guard grabs Katie up and Panzico threatens Katie that if she says one word, she might just end up like almsot all turkeys on Thanksgiving.