5 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

🥰

Why not? I liked her on Guiding Light but seeing her on The Young and the Restless made me love her.

Plus, I'd love to see her vs. Laura Wright again!

I think not knowing her work on World Turns does change things. New York soaps, as we know, were just built differently. And West carried World Turns.

I agreed about not fully loving MW because I don't know her work well enough.  Her GH stuff is so out of control to me.  But I think I just prefer a different type of actress.  MW earns her paycheck, just not my thing

Gina Tognoni is fine.  I only saw her stuff on OLTL (which I thought was bland) and a little of GL.  Again, not the full context of work so I can't judge thoroughly.  I am just joking honestly.  If GT was cast as anything other than Brenda I would be fine with it.

1 minute ago, Donna L. Bridges said:

Gosh, never saw anyone have actual dislike for her. I've only been advocating that she be a recast Sami on DAYS for 2 years now. 

And, yes, part of it is that it's a crying shame she's not working anywhere. 

Hard no, Donna!  Sami?   I just...........no.

7 minutes ago, Vee said:

I couldn't stand her on OLTL. But I think she did incredible work at both GL and Y&R. She earned my respect. She was also very nearly Carly #2, 3 or 4.

If I recall, she was up for the role once Brown left, alongside Robin Christopher.

2 minutes ago, carolineg said:

I agreed about not fully loving MW because I don't know her work well enough.  Her GH stuff is so out of control to me.  But I think I just prefer a different type of actress.  MW earns her paycheck, just not my thing

I like it that Maura can take it to the edge if need be, sure, but more than that I like that most of the time she prefers nuanced to "out there" 

2 minutes ago, carolineg said:

Gina Tognoni is fine.  I only saw her stuff on OLTL (which I thought was bland) and a little of GL.  Again, not the full context of work so I can't judge thoroughly.  I am just joking honestly.  If GT was cast as anything other than Brenda I would be fine with it.

Hard no, Donna!  Sami?   I just...........no.

Well, who would you cast? I really think the show needs to have Sami. 

4 minutes ago, carolineg said:

Hard no, Donna!  Sami?   I just...........no.

No clue what was said... but Gina as Sami? Nah.

Just now, Liberty City said:

If I recall, she was up for the role once Brown left, alongside Robin Christopher.

I'm pretty sure Jill always intended to just port RC over to GH as Skye. But yes, I do recall hearing Gina was up for Carly in 2001 though I also heard (and believe) that Tamara was originally a temp intended to kill Carly off after JFP famously clashed with Sarah and led to her quitting. I also heard they talked to Gina again when Tamara left, GL or no GL. But I'm not clear on the timeline.

2 minutes ago, Vee said:

I'm pretty sure Jill always intended to just port RC over to GH as Skye. But yes, I do recall hearing Gina was up for Carly in 2001 though I also heard (and believe) that Tamara was originally a temp intended to kill Carly off after JFP famously clashed with Sarah and led to her quitting. I also heard they talked to Gina again when Tamara left, GL or no GL. But I'm not clear on the timeline.

Would not surprise me one bit. And all of this sounds very JFP! To a T! Haha. I think Tognoni would've been a suitable Carly, though, especially back then.

2 minutes ago, Donna L. Bridges said:

I like it that Maura can take it to the edge if need be, sure, but more than that I like that most of the time she prefers nuanced to "out there" 

Well, who would you cast? I really think the show needs to have Sami. 

Idk, I would just let Ali appear when she can.  At this point I think a recast would be a mistake.

1 minute ago, Vee said:

I'm pretty sure Jill always intended to just port RC over to GH as Skye. But yes, I do recall hearing Gina was up for Carly in 2001 though I also heard (and believe) that Tamara was originally a temp intended to kill Carly off after JFP famously clashed with Sarah and led to her quitting. I also heard they talked to Gina again when Tamara left, GL or no GL. But I'm not clear on the timeline.

RC for Carly?  Can't see that.  I think she's a bit too old.

I believe you are correct about TB being temporary and to be killed off though.   I remember reading SODs saying TB was a temp.  I am trying to picture GT and MB as a couple.  Maybe?  

1 minute ago, carolineg said:

I am trying to picture GT and MB as a couple.  Maybe?  

Frankly, you could put MB with almost anyone and it is bound to work on one level or another.

2 minutes ago, Liberty City said:

Would not surprise me one bit. And all of this sounds very JFP! To a T!

Specifically, the temp Carly was supposedly to be raped by Sonny's rival Sorel while Sonny and Angel made love and Carly would later die of some sort of gruesome cancer or disease.

MB hated the Angel story, and he and several other performers basically mutinied over their stories (including Endgame). Maurice threw his weight behind Tamara publicly as did the fans, and everything fell apart for Jill and Megan shortly thereafter.

1 minute ago, Vee said:

everything fell apart for Jill and Megan shortly thereafter.

Angela Shapiro (?) was foolish to think Megan McTavish would be a good fit for GH.

2 minutes ago, Vee said:

Specifically, the temp Carly was supposedly to be raped by Sonny's rival Sorel while Sonny and Angel made love and Carly would later die of some sort of gruesome cancer or disease.

MB hated the Angel story, and he and several other performers basically mutinied over their stories (including Endgame). Maurice threw his weight behind Tamara publicly as did the fans, and everything fell apart for Jill and Megan shortly thereafter.

And this was around the time they were planning to make Bobbie go crazy and get shipped off or die, right? 

A part of me thinks in the long run GH would have been better off with Carly leaving, but not that way.

1 minute ago, Khan said:

Frankly, you could put MB with almost anyone and it is bound to work on one level or another.

Lol!  Idk I have seen a lot of MB pairings fail spectacularly. 

 

1 minute ago, Vee said:

Specifically, the temp Carly was supposedly to be raped by Sonny's rival Sorel while Sonny and Angel made love and Carly would later die of some sort of gruesome cancer or disease.

MB hated the Angel story, and he and several other performers basically mutinied over their stories (including Endgame). Maurice threw his weight behind Tamara publicly as did the fans, and everything fell apart for Jill and Megan shortly thereafter.

I remember all this too.  I wish I could find what I read, but Carly was supposed to have a tragic death.  

MB ain't wrong for hating the Angel story.  

4 minutes ago, Vee said:

Specifically, the temp Carly was supposedly to be raped by Sonny's rival Sorel while Sonny and Angel made love and Carly would later die of some sort of gruesome cancer or disease.

MB hated the Angel story, and he and several other performers basically mutinied over their stories (including Endgame). Maurice threw his weight behind Tamara publicly as did the fans, and everything fell apart for Jill and Megan shortly thereafter.

That's insane; I never knew any of this! Wow!

3 minutes ago, Khan said:

Angela Shapiro (?) was foolish to think Megan McTavish would be a good fit for GH.

She came with Jill. They were a package deal at that point. Of course when they tanked the show Jill lost virtually all central power AFAIK despite retaining her title, which is a worthwhile comeuppance IMO - it was Guza's Hospital from then on. He had learned from his battles with Riche and came back after securing a producer credit. The only moment that changed was during the writer's strike in 2008, when she was the one minding the store with Guza gone and suddenly you had the return of her color/wardrobe fetish introductions a la Angel or some of her GL characters with Claudia, then an overnight huge frontburner story for Rick Hearst and Ric's new immigrant bride lol.

2 minutes ago, DRW50 said:

And this was around the time they were planning to make Bobbie go crazy and get shipped off or die, right? 

Yes, and Tony put a stop to that. I don't know if she was going to die but I do remember the word was Bobbie would go nuts over Roy and Melissa and get shipped off to Ferncliff.

2 minutes ago, carolineg said:

I remember all this too.  I wish I could find what I read, but Carly was supposed to have a tragic death.  

The worst version of the story I remember was that somehow Carly's rape would be somehow connected to the cancer or disease, like uterine cancer or something. Just something really grotesque and typical of Jill.

Edited January 4, 20241 yr by Vee

3 minutes ago, Vee said:

She came with Jill. They were a package deal at that point. Of course when they tanked the show Jill lost virtually all central power AFAIK despite retaining her title, which is a worthwhile comeuppance IMO - it was Guza's Hospital from then on. He had learned from his battles with Riche and came back after securing a producer credit. The only moment that changed was during the writer's strike in 2008, when she was the one minding the store with Guza gone and suddenly you had the return of her color/wardrobe fetish introductions a la Angel or some of her GL characters with Claudia, then an overnight huge frontburner story for Rick Hearst and Ric's new immigrant bride lol.

Yes, and Tony put a stop to that. I don't know if she was going to die but I do remember the word was Bobbie would go nuts over Roy and Melissa and get shipped off to Ferncliff.

The worst version of the story I remember was that somehow Carly's rape would be somehow connected to the cancer or disease, like uterine cancer or something. Just something really grotesque and typical of Jill.

I think Bobbie was just going to be written off because "no one wants to see old people have sex".  I don't think I ever heard about her dying.

JFP wanted to ruin Carly after SJB.  I think we are "lucky" Angel was a flop and MB stood up for her.  I honestly can't tell you if keeping Carly was good in the long run, but I am glad she was kept at the time.