Gah Original and best Carly ever

Robin with short hair

Amber Tamblyn!!!!

Sarah Brown- the ONLY Carly

Jonathan Jackson looks pretty good.

And Bobbies on!!!!

Flove AmTam's Emily

I couldnt stand Emily when AT was playing her. Thank god she left and never came back

OMG I love her so much, especially in comparison to Natalia

I liked Emily until they made her so smug and judgmental. It never failed to disgust me that she was so nasty to a family who took her in when she could have been dumped in care. She was a nasty brat and her worship of the thug for hire ruined her. I did think she and Chad Brannon worked well together, and I preferred her to Natalia.

So this is back when JJ did more than weep and look like a hobo.

Edited February 13, 201114 yr by CarlD2

LOL yeah about JJ.I loved original Emily & Zander

I loved Carly and Sonny, this version of them and always thought they looked like they wanted to have hate sex LOL

I liked Emily until they made her so smug and judgmental. It never failed to disgust me that she was so nasty to a family who took her in when she could have been dumped in care. She was a nasty brat and her worship of the thug for hire ruined her. I did think she and Chad Brannon worked well together, and I preferred her to Natalia.

Same here. Emily's Jason worship was horrible, but she wasn't alone. Emily and Zander were great together. I loved them.

At the time I was also very put off by the way she treated Carly, although intellectually I knew that Carly was no innocent, I was so invested in SJB's Carly that I usually hated (almost) anyone who hated her. Looking back I can see that that was silly, but, what can you say.

I wonder who decided to repeat this episode. It seems like someone at ABC made it very clear last year that Liz/Lucky were a terrible couple, that Lucky only ever wanted to be with Liz because she had been raped, and that Lucky deserved better.

Edited February 13, 201114 yr by CarlD2

To twist the knife into LnL2 fans hearts even deeper? LOL

At the time I was also very put off by the way she treated Carly, although intellectually I knew that Carly was no innocent, I was so invested in SJB's Carly that I usually hated (almost) anyone who hated her. Looking back I can see that that was silly, but, what can you say.

I was such a SJB Carly fan it was ridiculous LOL. I hated Robin at that time for the same reason, same with AJ, Q's anyone who hated her LOL

I think SJB's Carly was the first and last time I had a strong emotional connection to a GH character, aside from Lucy Coe. Guza's writing style is very cold, and in the late 90s the show often seemed to be on a snooze button, but Carly was a real live wire back then.

Pretty good episode. Such a much slower pace compared to current GH as well.

Seriously NLG is ageless, she looks the same still, and Becky is even more beautiful now

Ingo is so adorable

Edited February 13, 201114 yr by dragonflies

haha, I also loved SB's Carly and HATED Robin. Cutting her hair and looking like a damn pixie, didnt help her cause. I was glad when Carly laughed her out of town which was so wrong in hindsight, but I didnt care bc I was a fan

Pretty good episode. Such a much slower pace compared to current GH as well.

It was mind-numbing. The baby Michael story is very possibly the most mind-numbing, suffocating, character-destroying story ever on a soap. For most of 1998 and 1999 I felt like entire episodes were devoted to Jason reading a children's story to Michael.