I was the one who mentioned Tracey Bregman playing this story (suprise, suprise), but I think it would have played out better because you need an actress who can play those dimensions and Michael and Lauren are a long established couple with a young child, and I am sure TEB and CLB would wring every bit of emotion from that story. Plus, ovarian cancer is rare in a woman so young and with Lauren we would not know if she would survive which would build tension unlike with Lily who you just know will survive and be moving onto a surrogate storyline next year.

What MAB said seemed heartfelt, but if she truly wanted to do what she says then she should not have given this story to Lily. She should have not made this only about redeeming Cane and the Lily and Cane love story. They did not need this story. They were married in May and he was caught lying in July. That was enough to play out.

And finally if she wanted to show how this effects the family why is it that she chose to write Kristoff St John out for 6 weeks and Tonya out for eight weeks and going when the Lily cancer story is playing out.

I can't say that she is being insincere in what she said, especially since she is a cancer survivor and a writer on her staff is battling breast cancer, but I do have to question her choices of actors to play such a emotional story. Maybe she should be less worried about giving yet more story to couples with vocal fanbases and instead give story to actors that can actually play the story based on talent. If she did she might have found herself up for more emmys next year instead of having to defend why this story is important.

Wow... perfectly put!

I have to say, today's US show was the first time that I felt any iota of a feeling within this cancer storyline but I'm actually crediting Goddard for that even though I still hate the Cane character.

I have a hard time believing that someone such as MAB, whose been touched by cancer herself, would actually feel anything from this storyline.

We all know every experience is not the same. Despite your disbelief viewers have been compelled to share their own experiences with cancer and many have commended MAB and CK on the story line.

Well hello, didn't you read my last post? Although I didn't feel anything from Christel, still, I'm sure all of the Laner's are eating her up in this story. I still think a better actress would have done this story better justice even with the writing.

Well hello, didn't you read my last post? Although I didn't feel anything from Christel, still, I'm sure all of the Laner's are eating her up in this story. I still think a better actress would have done this story better justice even with the writing.

Some people have selective leanings...

This storyline has never centered on the cancer issue, it's always been about Lily and her realizing how she wants and needs to be with Cane and Neil and Devon not being too happy with that. Cancer is almost an afterthought.

Certainly a better actress would have brought more depth to the role though, despite the writing. But I don't blame Christel for all the bad writing for her character.

It is very odd that Neil and Olivia have been written out of the cancer story. I'm not as critical of MAB as certain other people have been in the last few months (not mentioning any names ) but there have been a lot of "WTF moments" lately.

They should have given COLLEEN the cancer story (instead of killing her off). TS is a stronger actress than CK and Colleen has a history of cancer in her family. Plus, Colleen hasn't been shoved down the audience's throats the way Lily has in the past year.

Some people have selective leanings...

Including you

Cancer is almost an afterthought.

The decision making process of this writing team is highly questionable. As someone mentioned Lane didn't need this SL on top of the P3

reveal. It could have waited if they had the patience to just play out the beats of the P3 fallout.

The decision making process of this writing team is highly questionable. As someone mentioned Lane didn't need this SL on top of the P3

reveal. It could have waited if they had the patience to just play out the beats of the P3 fallout.

Truer words were never written!

Does anyone even care about P3 in Genoa City? It is appalling.... Is he getting to reconnect with his family? Finding a lover? WTF?

Including you

Especially you when it comes to Cane/Lily.

Not like you respond to posts about anything else.

I didn't entirely skip over another post from the same poster when he corrected himself.

The decision making process of this writing team is highly questionable. As someone mentioned Lane didn't need this SL on top of the P3

reveal. It could have waited if they had the patience to just play out the beats of the P3 fallout.

Lane, if they must be together could use a story that isn't about them wanting and needing to be together. There's other stories couples can be involved in. This cancer story is about Lily being sure and then not so sure about wanting to be with Cane. From the beginning, that has been their storyline.

Then again, every storyline is rushed on this show, so we're never gonna get fully thought out stories.

Edited September 3, 200916 yr by Y&RWorldTurner

We all know every experience is not the same. Despite your disbelief viewers have been compelled to share their own experiences with cancer and many have commended MAB and CK on the story line.

Exactly and certainly not only Laners as well. I've come across many on other boards who were never liked Lane or Lily and this story is resonating with them. Its not written to its fullest potential but frankly its the only story I'm currently watching. And yes I happen to think that Ck is doing a great job, DG and others. Do we even know if KSJ taking 6 weeks off isnt by choice? Or a mutual decision, he felt like he wasn't getting enough airtime so he took some time off?? If ptb can have Colleen and Mac visiting her, I highly doubt they wont do the same with Neil. And this story is not exactly dominating the airwaves anyhow.

And I don't know why people keep equating the way Lily is acting with all cancer patients, there is not a cancer handbook that every pt subscribes to. We all don't act alike even in sickness. And having had a personal/family experience with it, I can say all I'm seeing from Lily I've seen before. Most of the beats in this sl is being played not all but most.

Especially you when it comes to Cane/Lily. Not like you respond to posts about anything else.

It's no secret that I'm a Lane fan and they really are the only the characters I'm interested in. I find the rest of the show

as horrible as you find Lane although the Sep 17th stuff looks somewhat promising especially if it means the end of that story.

I didn't entirely skip over another post from the same poster when he corrected himself.

Lol, I didn't consider the DG disclaimer as an amendment to the sentiment of the original statement.

It's no secret that I'm a Lane fan and they really are the only the characters I'm interested in. I find the rest of the show as horrible as you find Lane

No, at the moment, I find the entire show horrible, including Lane.

Lol, I didn't consider the DG disclaimer as an amendment to the sentiment of the original statement.

I took it as DG helping Heyou get more invested and interested in the storyline, even if it's not a favourite of her's...

They should have given COLLEEN the cancer story (instead of killing her off). TS is a stronger actress than CK and Colleen has a history of cancer in her family. Plus, Colleen hasn't been shoved down the audience's throats the way Lily has in the past year.

Ha Ha heee heee That's a good one. TS might have been good in Far & Away where she can use her own accent. But on Y&R she was hardly use. How can you tell who is better between the two.

Olivia I believe also had cancer. But CK can't pull off a heavy storyline that why they switch gears to Lame love.

Edited September 5, 200916 yr by MoTheGreat

The suggestion to give this to Lauren is great! For such a vain and bitchy character it could be a new era for her. I think the writers have forgotten just how deeply connected Lauren is to both Y&R and B&B. She's a major character with ties to the masses. At this rate I wish she'd just go back to B&B. They don't need another female lead, but I'm sure with their packed half hour show we'd still see her more than on Y&R. I do think Michael is done story wise, but Lauren still has potential.

The suggestion to give this to Lauren is great! For such a vain and bitchy character it could be a new era for her. I think the writers have forgotten just how deeply connected Lauren is to both Y&R and B&B. She's a major character with ties to the masses. At this rate I wish she'd just go back to B&B. They don't need another female lead, but I'm sure with their packed half hour show we'd still see her more than on Y&R. I do think Michael is done story wise, but Lauren still has potential.

I agree about Lauren, but I never get these statements like Michael is done story wise. It doesn't make sense. If they can continue to write story for Victor, Jack, Katherine, Jill, Phyllis, etc they can write story for Michael. He is a complicated character with a rich history. It is the writers ineptitude and stubborness in refusing to write him a story that is the problem not anything inherently wrong with the character that makes him impossible to write for.

Edited September 5, 200916 yr by lmfan