I will never understand why CK gets so much criticism. She is a very, VERY good actress (and here is proof), not to mention a stunner in the looks department, and she is Emmy nominated! The "other" Lily, Davetta Sherwood, couldn't hold a candle to her IMO.

I will never understand why CK gets so much criticism. She is a very, VERY good actress (and here is proof), not to mention a stunner in the looks department, and she is Emmy nominated! The "other" Lily, Davetta Sherwood, couldn't hold a candle to her IMO.

I disagree. #1 that was an old clip, CK's acting has gotten very boring, mediocore, and stale since then, and #2 DS could act circle around CK any day of the week!

^DS never even changed her facial expression!

Christel has been miscast from the beginning and plays Lily as a vapid teenager. She doesn't bother me anymore, but she fades into the background. The chemistry horrible pairing with Cane further causes me to dislike his character as it reminds me how absurd the thing with Phillip is. He needs to be pairs with an actress who is older, more mature and can handle adult stories.

Christel is lucky daytime's worst recast, Tammin Sursok, is around to make her look good. She makes me long for the days of Charity Rahmer.

Christel has been miscast from the beginning and plays Lily as a vapid teenager. She doesn't bother me anymore, but she fades into the background. The chemistry horrible pairing with Cane further causes me to dislike his character as it reminds me how absurd the thing with Phillip is. He needs to be pairs with an actress who is older, more mature and can handle adult stories.

Christel is lucky daytime's worst recast, Tammin Sursok, is around to make her look good. She makes me long for the days of Charity Rahmer.

Amen.

Christel is lucky daytime's worst recast, Tammin Sursok, is around to make her look good. She makes me long for the days of Charity Rahmer.

And why is Tammin daytime's worst recast?

Because she's a horrible actress with no depth in her scenes and is horribly miscast. It's just hilarious that they'd cast an Australian actress as a New Yorker and she can barely hide her accent. I heard it just last week. Throw in the fact that she has chemistry with no one and you have Y&R's worst recast ever. Yes, someone is finally worse than Shari Shattuck as Ashley. Much worse.

I find it hilarious th at now with AL rumored to return there isn't an outcry of any sort for Tammin. She will not be missed by Y&R fans.

Because she's a horrible actress with no depth in her scenes and is horribly miscast. It's just hilarious that they'd cast an Australian actress as a New Yorker and she can barely hide her accent. I heard it just last week. Throw in the fact that she has chemistry with no one and you have Y&R's worst recast ever. Yes, someone is finally worse than Shari Shattuck as Ashley. Much worse.

I find it hilarious th at now with AL rumored to return there isn't an outcry of any sort for Tammin. She will not be missed by Y&R fans.

Amen.

Because she's a horrible actress with no depth in her scenes and is horribly miscast. It's just hilarious that they'd cast an Australian actress as a New Yorker and she can barely hide her accent. I heard it just last week. Throw in the fact that she has chemistry with no one and you have Y&R's worst recast ever.

She is a phenomenal actress. She held a frontburner role on another soap for more than 4 years, for which she won an award. She has an enormous fanbase in Australia and the UK. So while it could be argued that Colleen was not the right role for her, to say she is a "horrible actress" is just ridiculous.

Yes, someone is finally worse than Shari Shattuck as Ashley. Much worse.

There WAS a recast worse than Shari Shattuck's Ashley: Scott Seymour's Billy!

I find it hilarious th at now with AL rumored to return there isn't an outcry of any sort for Tammin. She will not be missed by Y&R fans.

She will DEFINITELY be missed by this Y&R fan!

Edited March 31, 200817 yr by y&r_fan

i dont think TS is a awful actress, but she is one of the worst recasts ever.

I love that Alison is on that list, she's just a step of every young actor on DOOL.

Personally i would start watch OLTL because i've seen some scene's with Farah in jail and she was great in those scene's. I loved Farah on DOOL so i like her as an actress.

And, Mackenzie is pretty good on B&B but her character is one-sided and it makes me want to slap her. Anyway i think she's a good young actress and i can see her do some prime time.