Well, I'm sad about Chekize was sent home. In my opinion he has the best voice. I think Ramile should have gone home. She hasn't had a good performance in quite a long time. I don't know who to root for anymore. David A, Caryl, and Brooke are over hyped. Kristy Lee isn't very good. I guess I'll root for David Cook. I'm having a hard time with people saying this is the best season ever. IMO there really isn't a standout performer in the group.

In my opinion, I think this is the best season. These amateur performers can't be perfect all the time. And I expect it. I'm assuming that the problem with David Archuleta is that he listened to the judges because he kept doing too many ballads. Simon is telling him to change it up and quit doing all of these depressing songs because he's being too repetitive etc, and I honestly think that David Archuleta can't really do fast paced tempo songs. I really don't. And I think it has something to do with the problem that he had with his throat when he was younger.

Carly Smithson is awesome, but I think her husband isn't being very supportive at all. In fact, I think that he's jealous. And I also think that he's the one who spread the rumors to the tabloids that she was pregnant. He wants to watch her fail because he's insecure about losing her.

Brooke White is still professional and she still values feedback from the judges and she never cops an attitude when the judges give certain negative feedback. She listens with an open ear and that's what I love about her.

I do like David Cook, but I think he's going to be another Chris Daughtry in this competition. He'll probably stick around for a couple of weeks, but I'm thinking 2 weeks after 'Idol gives back', he'll be eliminated.

I do like David Cook, but I think he's going to be another Chris Daughtry in this competition. He'll probably stick around for a couple of weeks, but I'm thinking 2 weeks after 'Idol gives back', he'll be eliminated.

I have already set myself up for David Cook not to win AI. I just get the feeling he will be this year's Chris Daughtry. But now looking at it, Chris Daughtry isn't doing that bad.

They sent the right one home. I am glad Jason Castro was in the bottom 3. He thinks his looks will get him through. Some of his songs have been dull and boring. Michael Johns was so much better last night. I like him a lot but his song choices are so bad. I cant stand Carly Smithson singing. I hope she is out soon. David A. was ok. But he has lost some of his fire. The one I am hoping will win Idol is David Cook. He was awesome last night. And has been very constant.

Michael Johns song choices aren't bad at all imho. Some could be better, but he's still the 2nd best man in the competition! Glad you're rooting for the awsome David Cook now, I thought you were rooting for David Archuletta, I can't stand him anymore (hate him almost as much as I hate Taylor Hicks lol). Carly Smithson IS AWESOME man. She kicks ass. IMHO, she's the best female singer on the show ever besides Kelly Clarkson!

Michael Johns song choices aren't bad at all imho. Some could be better, but he's still the 2nd best man in the competition! Glad you're rooting for the awsome David Cook now, I thought you were rooting for David Archuletta, I can't stand him anymore (hate him almost as much as I hate Taylor Hicks lol). Carly Smithson IS AWESOME man. She kicks ass. IMHO, she's the best female singer on the show ever besides Kelly Clarkson!

I think the best singer would be Jennifer Hudson in the entire Idol history. She is followed by Melinda Doolittle. And then, in no particular order, Mandisa, Katherine McPhee, Carly Smithson, etc. The problme with Carly is her personality, and all her lies, and the fact that she actually worked with Randy jackson(!) as published by votefortheworst.com.

Michael Johns song choices aren't bad at all imho. Some could be better, but he's still the 2nd best man in the competition! Glad you're rooting for the awsome David Cook now, I thought you were rooting for David Archuletta, I can't stand him anymore (hate him almost as much as I hate Taylor Hicks lol). Carly Smithson IS AWESOME man. She kicks ass. IMHO, she's the best female singer on the show ever besides Kelly Clarkson!

I think the best singer would be Jennifer Hudson in the entire Idol history. She is followed by Melinda Doolittle. And then, in no particular order, Mandisa, Katherine McPhee, Carly Smithson, etc. The problme with Carly is her personality, and all her lies, and the fact that she actually worked with Randy jackson(!) as published by votefortheworst.com.

This is a much more better season than last year's. There are many i am rooting for this year. The top 32 this year was stronger then the past 2 years as well.

I think the best singer would be Jennifer Hudson in the entire Idol history. She is followed by Melinda Doolittle. And then, in no particular order, Mandisa, Katherine McPhee, Carly Smithson, etc. The problme with Carly is her personality, and all her lies, and the fact that she actually worked with Randy jackson(!) as published by votefortheworst.com.

Carly's lies??!? WTF are you talking about? Jennifer Hudson is good yeah, forgot about her there. I agree she's right up there with Kelly, Carly probably in 3rd position. Melinda right up there. Mandisa is good and so is Katherine. Carrie Underwood also is good, but I think a little over-rated.

I think Ramiele is going next, but honestly, I don't know. Because I think the judges know how exactly many votes she gets. I've noticed how they're not too critical like they were before. I guess we'll have to wait and see tonight.

Edited April 1, 200817 yr by Noel

Awww...that's the part in American Idol that makes me sad is when the contestants cry and sing their little song in the end. I think the only reason why Kristy Lee Cook is still in this thing is because everything is basically in her favor. Like this week was a tribute to Dolly Parton, but you know, she was one of the bottom three! I think she knows she's about to leave pretty soon.

And Brooke White! I *heart* that woman.

I agree with Simon (for once) that America got the Bottom 3 right this week. I do wish though that Kristy Lee went instead of Ramiele, but she'd be the next to go anyhow. I think Kristy Lee, after 5 weeks in the Bottom 2(!), she'll finally go home next week (next Thursday btw).

Who do you think will be going home Thursday? I missed almost half of it, so I have no clue.

Idol Gives Back this year was pretty good. However i detest Mylee Cyrus. She is crap!! Poor performances tonight and poor singing. How the hell is she so popular?

Idol Gives Back this year was pretty good. However i detest Mylee Cyrus. She is crap!! Poor performances tonight and poor singing. How the hell is she so popular?

My guess is that 'American Idol' is a family show and children to do watch it, and Miley Cyrus is extremely popular with the kids, so they had performers on last night to cater to all the group of viewers.

IDOL GIVES BACK sucked big time. It was good last year, but for the most part this show sucked. I get it 5 out of 10. The good points---Fergie with John Legend, Fergie & Heart, Mariah Carey, Annie Lennox was ok, Teri Hatcher was pretty good actually, Robin Williams and Jimmy Kimmell were awesome, I wish Ellen had more part (like she did last year), the Christian number at the end was good, but shouldn't have been on the show, too much of the stories, no need for the additonal half hour, Paula should've performed "Dance Like There's No Tomorrow", Why didn't Jordin Sparks perform (2nd week in audience but no performance by the reigning IDOL, makes no sense),

Well holy hell!! Michael Johns has been eliminated!! What the hell is with that? SICKENING!! I am shocked and ticked off!! What on earth was America thinking. I predicted him the Top 3 of the season along with David Cook and Carly Smithson. I am just baffled. But look what happened 2 years ago with Chris Daughtry. The man should have won Idol...and didnt.