Jump to content

ATWT or Y&R: Case of the Missing Years


Recommended Posts

  • Members

It seems like we have two storylines that are somewhat similar: in terms of missing two years of someone's life.

Which one did you think was better? Y&R's Nick missing two years of his life after coming back from his plane crash? Or that of ATWT's Rosanna, who woke up from her coma thinking that she was back in the year that she learned that Craig switched the babies?

I personally like ATWT's a little bit more than that of Y&R. Only because in so many ways, they keep acknowleging the history of what went down when a lot of us were in knots about the babies of Jen and Gwen. I also like it more because it has some of the same characters who were involved in that storyline back front and center: Craig of course; Paul, who kept the truth, Rosanna, and of course Meg and Barbara.

I didn't like Y&R's at all; except for one part; and that was Nick's breakdown of having to learn all over again that his daughter, Cassie was dead. After that, i lost interest really quick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I like the Y&R one....

I'm not really a big Rosanna fan (except I loved her with HB's Craig), so that probably colors my opinion, and frankly one of the biggest players from that drama (pre and post baby switch) (Emily) is missing, though I heard they did at least mention her today (and obviously that is beyond their control with KMH off on maternity leave).

The only thing I'm moderately intrigued by in the ATWT one is whether Paul will fess up the whole truth....b/c Rosanna wanted Jen to know and he didn't follow through on that. I'm thinking he won't lol....

But I like the Y&R one b/c it gave Nick and Sharon a chance to reconnect, and I do love them together.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

ATWT hands down. At least Rosanna was gone for 2 years we weren't constantly teased about when she would return. I don't know what LML was thinking, to have Victor leave his family during their grief just to find his replacement son. That's as bad as Nikki being too shaken to attend Nick's memorial, but more than able to continue her senate campaign! Y&R also missed an opportunity to explore foul play in Nick's plane crash.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I can see where folks liked Y&R's story because of the whole Nick/Sharon thing. However, after a certain point it didn't hold my attention after the first few days. Reason. The constant forcings of Phyllis in scenes trying to get Nick to remember somethng that in some ways he obviously doesn't really want to remember....Plus too, I think I tuned out mainly because of not liking the direction of where LML is taking the show.

I like ATWT's more because of all of the stuff that was resurfacing once Rosanna woke up. I guess I like that they are bringing back some of the recent history again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.


  • Community Posts

    • Apologies Slick- not updating my somewhat disorganized lists. Michael Fairman THE YOUNG AND THE RESTLESS   Patrick "Murph" Murphy   2008-14  2017 recurring DAYS OF OUR LIVES  Mr Schroeder 1977
    • I sure don't pretend to have expert recall, lol.   In the first episode, Sally McGuire famously said, "Kind of a drag, isn't it.  Being stuck in a place like Genoa City.  God, I feel so restless."  In the same episode, the truck driver told Brad Eliot, "Genoa City -- nice-sized town, but I prefer St. Paul.  That's where the family is."     We were given the idea from Day One that Genoa City was a fairly *small* to *mid-sized* Midwestern metropolis, not nearly as big as a Chicago or even a Detroit or Minneapolis.   In the early 1990s, Victor Newman advised Hope Wilson that Genoa City was comparable to Wichita, Kansas -- population about 400,000 in 1990, with a metro population of around 500,000.   The high-rises that I remember being featured from early on were the Genoa City Hotel and Genoa Towers.  There was a restaurant called "The Embers" in one of them (Genoa Towers, I believe). Lorie Brooks moved into a penthouse, circa 1978, which was located at 247 East Chestnut.  Lorie's unit was #2500, indicating her apartment was on the 25th floor.  Vanessa Prentiss jumped to her death from the balcony in 1981.  During Lorie's trial, they gave the address about a zillion times -- "247 East Chestnut #2500".  This was an inside joke of Bill Bell's, because his co-writer, Kay Alden, resided in real-life at 247 East Chestnut #2500 in the Streeterville neighborhood of Chicago.  From Lorie's balcony, we could see a cluster of several high-rises -- not a Chicago by any stretch of the imagination, but more a Wichita.   Jabot's corporate offices were on 4th Street.  The "corporate suites" were on the 12th floor, indicating the building was likely 12 stories.  Kevin Bancroft, an architect, was hired to design a new high-rise (Newman Towers) in 1981.  Much ado was made about Newman Towers being 35 stories, among the tallest in the city.  The address given for Newman Towers was 7800 Melrose, another Bill Bell inside joke -- Y&R was recorded at 7800 Beverly Blvd in Los Angeles.  Paul moved his office into Newman Towers to "upgrade his image".  As someone mentioned, Nikki took an apartment in Newman Towers to "have a place in town to spend the night" when she "didn't feel like driving back to the ranch"; instead, her apartment became a love nest with Jack Abbott.  Victor and Diane, during their marriage, lived on the top floor of Newman Towers.  The show did a few remotes in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, back in the 1980s and early 1990s.  Evidently the production staff felt Pittsburgh mirrored what we were seeing on-screen -- cold and snowy, good-sized Rust Belt metropolis.  I believe Pittsburgh's population was around 500,000 at the time, comparable to the "Wichita-sized city" Victor described to Hope.   In the early 2000s, there were some "establishing shots" filmed around Charlotte, North Carolina.   Not sure why they selected Charlotte over Pittsburgh.  Probably figured found a couple of buildings there on which "Newman Towers" and "Jabot Cosmetics" could be airbrushed easily.  
    • Yeah, they played it wrong with them last time including the idiotic engagement to Jax (a go-to Ron always goes for with returning characters for no reason and did with Scott and Laura in an equally ridiculous subplot around the same time - there was no way those two would reunite again). But Brenda raising hell in town, antagonizing Carly, reconnecting with A.J. and Robin, even the Michael tease all worked for me because it was about her being central, able to be plugged in anywhere and shaking up the canvas. That is what she is best at and what she can do. Sonny has to come to her where she lives and especially after what happened to their marriage.
    • I mean maybe RH and Vanessa would pop off in chemistry lol.. I actually wouldn't be surprised.   I honestly don't need Brenda in random pairings but I need some movement on Sonny's part to not be the worst.  Because I feel like the always put them back together on popularity with zero movement in the actual lovestory.  And I do feel like the show plays Brenda as so lovelorn for Sonny..which fine, but Sonny is a actual trash bag fire with like 17 kids from 17 moms so...........
    • Janet Wood can be found on page 105. I'll add more to an updated profile in the a.m.      Bobby Doran is on page 210. I added 2 movies there.  Maybe more pics Thursday. I'll add the Bob Bailey, Paul Ford and Jeanne Bates  info  after I add movies/ Broadway to them. Researched Paul Geary  and Jack Wells   +  Stephen Kay of GH and Days newcomer Helen Day.  @Bright Eyes  I'll have Max Ehrich and Cam Gigandet tomorrow, Friday the latest
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy