Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soap Opera Network Community

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

ATWT Carly and Jack

Featured Replies

  • Member

As a CarJack fan, I've always thought these two belonged together; even when things happen to tear them apart; however, now, since the whole mess with drugging Gwen, which had Jack lose his job because of his involvement, and the whole Nick mess, I think they should be apart for awhile.

I've seen some die-hard CarJack fans on other boards basically say that they shouldn't pair either character up with someone else; that CarJack should always be together. For me, I would love to see Carly paired with someone else for a bit before going back to Jack. Jack had Julia Larabee, why can't Carly be the one in a relationship with someone else?

I personally have grown a bit tired of the constant break-ups, and quick reunions...It would be nice to see these two work hard to get back together.

  • Replies 20
  • Views 399
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Member

I would like to see these two apart for awhile as well. I don't think it's going to happen, but I can dream. They are at their best when they are apart, imo. I loved it when Jack was married to Julia #1 and in love with Carly. They do the star crossed thing so well. It's just not that interesting when they are together. I think these two need a long break and even need to be married to other people for awhile.

  • Member

I get annoyed beyond belief when fanbases run how the show is done. If a couple is still in their prime, they should be able to break up every now and then. It makes it better when they finally settle down for good a few years down the road.

  • Member

I am ready for Carly to move on for a while. I think that Jack has hurt her way too much for her to just quickly go back to him. I would like to see Carly get a bit of her old spice back and then move on to another relationship. I have always been a CarJack fan, but they need a break. After their last reunion, Carly's every day and night has been about Jack. It's time for Carly to be selfish for a while... and let some other man make his life about Carly.

  • Author
  • Member

The thing that annoys me is how when you say how much you think a super couple should be apart, and a whole group of fanatics get their panties in a bunch insulting posters for even daring to "say such a thing".

Carly and Jack were so boring this year; I actually liked the rift that was coming between the two of them. Carly has been whining non-stop for Jack to forgive her; always apologizing to him; even when at times he was in the wrong. Now that they are broken up, I want the writers to put Carly back the way she was when she first came on the show. Carly has lost a lot of her spark and it's time she gets it back; therefore, if she has to be paired with another character to do so then do it.

I know some say that Simon and Katie should get together; but it would interesting to see Simon and Carly together for a little bit, or even Damian and Carly.....At one point, when Dusty asked her to come on board to Street Jeans, I thought they would be interesting; however now, the way Dusty is, forget it.

  • Member

I am ready for them to be apart and stay apart for Years. They have broken up over every conceivable excuse and always got back together. Its become old and boring and not something I want to invest my time in.

Carly and Simon would be interesting or even Damian. Jack with another woman who isn't a needy mental case would be interesting too but no one really come to mind. At this point I will try anything just get Carly and Jack away from each other. :rolleyes:

  • Member

I consider myself a CarJack fan but count me in as one who hopes they take their time getting back together.

I hope there are no more stories where Carly butts into Jack's life for his own good,too.

Maybe there can be some missed oppourtunities ,some misunderstandings,etc. No amnesia please!

  • Member

I think they need time apart, maybe get involved with other people. It will make them appreciate each other that much more when they finally do reunite.

  • Member

Well, if there is any fanbase running this show, I'd sure like to know which one it is. Seems to me all the fans get screwed on the show, and no one is happy. I haven't heard of any fan base en masse trying to boycott the show or threatening to leave if "couple X" isn't reunited pronto. It's not like the Manny/GL situation where there was a revolt anytime either Michelle or Danny were even in other scenes with other potential love interests, and the show backed off. ATWT seems to go full steam ahead without listening to the fans whatsoever, which is disheartening in other ways. (The day Henry gets a true love interest and a story centered on him is the day TIIC of ATWT are listening to fans)

As for Carly and Jack specifically, I want them together. I wouldn't mind break up stories for them, if they weren't so damn stupid and repetitive. Carly goes bonkers because she's accused of killing a baby and fights dirty to keep her sister's adopted child....that could have been okay, IF it had explored Carly's past (instead of making one up out of thin air) and given us some insight into what makes Carly tick. It didn't, because what happened to Carly wasn't the point of the story; making Gwen Carly's sister was. What Carly's childhood was like was totally dropped and forgotten.

If the show wants to spend all that time breaking up a couple, the fans need to be rewarded when the couple reunites. That's not happening. They "reunite" and two weeks later, it's on to the next break up story. Where's the fun in that? All the constant upheaval does is chip away at what made the couple special in the first place. I used to love Josh and Reva. Reva came back; battled Annie and won. She and Josh got married; and BOOM, they take a honeymoon in San Cristobel where we learn Reva was a Princess and had another child. They've never been the same since. (Or at least, that's the point I gave up, San Christohell was ridiculous.) Jack and Carly have never been the same since Jack went off the bridge and hooked up with IT. Not because Maura and Michael can't make the angst come through the words, but because the writers took shortcuts and never carried through on the consequences of what that meant to the Carly/Jack relationship. And that wasn't because the "Carjack" fans thought the worst of Julia and wanted her gone. (The majority of fans on the boards hated Julia; regardless of where they stood on Sarah Brown) It's because they NEVER WROTE IT.

Even now, regardless of my yearning for Carly/Jack to reunite, I desperately wish Carly could just stand up and scream, "that whore was never your wife; we shouldn't be raising JJ; and if I had to bust my ass to help you get your job back, it was because I've never trusted your love since then!!"

  • Member

Separate!! I am not a Carly/Jack fan. In fact, I don't care for either character, though I kind of enjoy Carly more now. Jack, though, is a jerk IMO.

I understand that the fanbases get pissed off, but who cares? IMO, fanbases are the ones who are ruining soaps. It's not a HUGE problem on ATWT, but it is on a lot of other soaps. Writers can't even break up a couple w/o the threat of ratings dropping.

If people are only watching the show for one couple, then they aren't real fans IMO. Real Carly and Jack fans would be willing to see the characters in other relationships and doing other things.

Look how long it took Bob and Kim to get married, and even then they've had problems. Carly and Jack will get back together eventually, but happy couples = boring couples on soaps, so why would fans want to see their favorite couple in a rut all the time?

  • Member

Reunite -- down the road. For now, try and craft some stories where the two can interact with each other, but not necessarily get back together. In the meantime, Jean needs to see what made CarJack powerful together in the first place. Even Hogan admitted he didn't get their popularity when he first came on board ATWT, but then the light went on and he began writing for them.

  • Author
  • Member

I guess that's why I like DOOL's Hope and Bo...they have been together for so long; then they break them up, either by "death" or by other people....but over time, they reunite.

It's good that Carly and Jack are broken up...I agree with what you said Ms. Walsh. I am a fan and I do have my couples, but I do know that couples have to separate in order to get to that good storyline that brings them together..Plus, I don't watch the show for just one couple; I watch the show as a whole.

  • Member

I guess I'm not a real fan because I do only watch most soaps just for couples. I mostly watch ATWT for Henry and Maddie and a few couples, nothing else holds my interest.

  • Author
  • Member

I have my favorite couples, but sometimes my favorites get dull for me....

  • Member

Yeah I can understand that ;)

Emily is almost enough to make me stop watching, but I'm too hooked on Henry/Trent to stop watching. I just want him to get the storyline he deserves *sigh*

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.