Jump to content

Roswell, New Mexico


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 19
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Members

 

To be fair, only the first season of the original show was really good. The second year was still okay and had its moments, but the third and final season was abysmal; really hard to watch. Plus, Shiri Appleby was pretty wooden and expressionless as Liz. (Don't get me wrong. I still love the first incarnation of Roswell, thanks to its great debut season and the hunky Jason Behr as Max, but I have read comments on-line from devoted fans who say it was the greatest thing on earth, and I would have to disagree.)

 

I am wont to loathe reboots, so I watched the first few episodes of R:NM just to complain about it. I think the new Liz is a better actress than the original, as is the new Michael. The new Isobel is channeling Heigl, big time, LOL. I think there is on-screen chemistry between Michael and Alex. Aside from all that, Nathan Parsons looks sweet and vulnerable as Max, but he lacks Jason Behr's intensity. The show is just...more of the same from the CW. I may continue to watch it on a casual basis, just because I enjoy seeing beautiful boys kissing (yes, I am shallow and a 'ho), but I doubt R:NM will go down in history as one of my favorite series.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Members

 

It was really the chemistry of the actors that made Roswell work as a character study, rather than as a show. I don't know many people who watch Roswell who were in love with the plotting and storylines but rather the actors, couples and pairings which made the show work. It had a dedicated fanbase directly because of those actors/character ships. Liz/Max (Dreamers), Maria/Micheal (Candies), and even Isabel/Alex (Stargazers) really were what kept the series afloat. When they started messing with those characters and the relationships, friendships and connections within the series the show pretty much tanked, as a lot of fans felt betrayed in seasons two and three. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Well...I happen to like the intrigue that came with the introduction of Tess personally.

 

But I liked most of the sci-fi of Season Two (barring that whole queen hive thing)...but I'll give you season Three which I have finally watched a few months ago does not hold up well at all. Though I will ALWAYS love 'Get Up, Bitca.'

 

That said...I am loving the reboot so far with the intrigue (and I love Amber Midhunter on LEGION) and the floating bodies thing...it's a show you can't just have on in the background. That's for sure.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

Tess herself, wasn't the problem so much as the way she was utilized as a plot contrivance to bring the show in a different direction. I think had the show gone about bringing her on differently, there wouldn't have been much of a controversy around her addition to the group. She was added to bring strife to the group, and she broke up the set that was mostly formed by the time she got there. Had she been added to the group sooner (and differently) - I think she would have been more accepted.  The fact that she came nearly right at the end of the first season made fans look at Tess as an interloper.

 

There's also a larger metaphor that they don't like the way the show deviated and got worse over time around the time she became apart of the main cast. The larger problem was that the WB didn't know what they wanted Roswell to be, they didn't know if they wanted it to be a romantic teen melodrama like Dawson's Creek/Felicity, or if they wanted it to be a huge arc carrying sci-fi action series like Buffy/Smallville and the network interference caused a lot of issues in the second season. I think the series writers even lamp-shaded this in an episode where they had two of the characters argue which movie was better "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon" or "The Matrix". It didn't help that the writers didn't know what they wanted either.

 

If you take a look at Season Two of Roswell, it's all over the place. They went from a secondary alien invasion from a rival species, to Time Travel to Evil Twin Aliens to Alien Possession Parasites to Alien Teen Pregnancy to Alien War on a Remote Planet. A hodgepodge of ideas, none of which had real legs. A lot of people give season three grief, but it was clear that the show was going off the rails as soon as season two. Season three just inherited a lot of bad debt. The writers tried everything they could but the show couldn't stick with anything, and by the end they couldn't bail themselves out of bad story-telling. It's telling that most fans now either ignore those plot points completely or forget they even existed. The Sci-Fi portion of  the show never found the right direction, and never took off. I don't know if it's because they couldn't or they didn't want to. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

See? I would disagree with that. The interference no. I vaguely remember that going down. I also vaguely remember Jason Katims was more interested in a lot of the romantic teen melodrama than the scifi...which did show and kinda like how Tim Kring was on HEROES if I'm being honest. Regardless of his dislike...I felt Season Two had direction right up until the doppleganger/alien summit in New York episodes.  After that, it went off the rails because the writing had all these ideas with no idea of how to converge it all together in a way that made sense. The war with the Skins did have legs if it had not just been resolved for the most part by episode 7 of that season. 

 

Basically from what I heard...they didn't want to go totally that way re: sci-fi.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I adored Roswell up until the introduction of Tess.  I think the Tess character was badly written and introduced, and I think the quality of the show suffered. IT was something out of a soap opera writer's reject pile. I've never been so quickly repelled by a show. I usually start drifting away from a show, but the Tess character just ruined my enjoyment and I never felt the same way about the show. I hated the second season because it felt like it was a completely different show--and one I didn't want to watch. IT also made no sense (and I found it funny when cast members admitted they had no idea what was going on). I barely remember the third season and I think I just dipped in here and there just to see what was going on.

 

The new Roswell has a lot of potential, but it's also plagued by the same problems: too much overplotting and an obsessive need to keep Max and Liz apart. I would find it more interesting to see Max and Liz together but dealing with the problems from that connection. The sci-fi/military angle does not work and it's as boring as all the sci-fi stuff from the original.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 year later...
  • Members

Yeah, Jason Katims and the WB fought over that Season 2 version for sure. But still liked it. But I can see why people didn't like Season 3.

 

Then you should have liked Max and Liz drama during Season 2 which was almost totally internal. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Well they didn't really do anything with him...he might as well had been a ghost of a memory that kept Michael and Alex apart.

 

They didn't even really try to redeem him.  And given where the plot was going, he was dead weight.

 

Bring on more aliens and the 'shadow self.'

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

 

It would not surprise me if that does happen in season 3 and is apart of Alex's arc. 

 

Trevor St. John seems to be a CW favorite he was on Vampire Dairies, Containment and now Roswell. I wouldn't be surprised to see him pop up somewhere else soon.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Monday's episode(what was today's before the pre emption) is posted   https://www.cbs.com/shows/video/CAD_kZcynpkzM5vrwPg77Hh5MQD3hTbH/
    • Denise had so much inherent warmth, yet also layered her work with neuroses and emotion, making sure her characters were never as one-dimensional as the writing could have been. She was one of the first high profile poachings from one soap to another, which could have been a recipe for disaster, but she worked hard and turned Lesley into such an integral part of GH's rebuilding. The show may not have survived the '70s without her.  I wish they'd done more with Lesley when they brought her back in 1996. I hope more of Denise's run at DAYS will appear. I enjoyed Denise's work on AW, in a very underwritten part - it felt like she was just hitting her stride in playing the role when she left.  We are losing so many of our legends, but in moments like this I try to just be grateful we had them for as long as we did.  I do feel terrible for those at GH as they've been hit hard the last few years. 
    • Before my time, but besides Lesley, I know many say her work on Days as Susan was fabulous. I saw a clip, when Julie met Doug for the first time (with Susan the one that introduced them as BJ Hunnicutt David Banning was in the background!)... But so much of her work as Susan is not available. May Denise Alexander rest in peace!
    • Oh, no. I came in at the tail end of her Susan Martin run on Days and instantly loved her. I started watching GH because of her, not the Luke & Laura phenom. And though I thought AW wasted her as Mary McKinnon, her talent and charisma was still on full display. Thanks for the memories, Denise. 
    • I didn’t know if you were being serious or not for a second I really feel like the way they’re mixing up who’s interacting with who, a couple of changes to the overall look (lighting, camera angles) and a few actors having changes in hairstyle etc (Naomi and Nicole are the first that comes to mind), there may have been a break in production before this week’s episodes were shot and they’ve reassessed a few things (in particular I noticed the lighting has improved and a lot of my gripes around the makeup - particularly on some of the female cast has also improved - two things which go hand in hand), perhaps some episodes have been edited and moved around to still give the Friday cliffhanger which is why Derek and Ashley were edited out of an episode they were slated to appear in etc. Regardless, this week has been excellent and I’ve noticed the actor who plays Martin is improving and Hayley too - especially given how poorly the Hayley character is written and how her personality / motivation changes from scene to scene.
    • Found this on YT

      Please register in order to view this content

      Retired Supreme Court Justice David Souter Dies At 85 years old.     
    • Awww man. All of our legends are going. Leslie Charleson and Leslie Webber are together now. Some of the best of Leslie's work:

      Please register in order to view this content

         
    • Didn't she look good. First thing I thought. As I was watching I was thinking Timon Durrett is a damn good actor. I fell out! Oh man, this is going to be good. I'm starting to go along with Eva may not be her biological daughter.
    • And, the first storyline I remember was DAYS Susan & David & Julie & poor baby Dickie. Denise as Susan was the STAR of that story. 
    • A masterclass. A true masterclass.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy