Jump to content

OLTL: Has anyone else given up watching this show?


Recommended Posts

  • Members

I was all excited about OLTL not too long ago, it seemed like the show was heading in a good direction.

But now, the Todd/Marty stuff is the reason I've stopped watching. Sorry but yes Carlivati is a hack, the Todd/Marty ish is disgusting on so many levels I can't count.

How long before RC is fired? He sure isn't setting the ratings on fire :mellow:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 223
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I've not been glued to it like I was for the BE takeover and Nash's death.

However I wouldn't go clamoring for Carlivati's firing. He's shown he understands the characters and their flaws, but somewhere along the way for the anniversary, he lost his way and has been struggling to get the show back together. So I'm going to wait and see if it can pull me back in. It hasn't today.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I completely agree. And I wouldn't even say this is a bad storyline. I think it's a truly f*cked up storyline, a controversial storyline, and when's the last time that was shown on a soap opera? You know, there was a time when soaps were all about controversy. I know some can say that Carlivati is going for the shock value by pairing Todd and Marty together, which is what some have said, but I don't think that's what's going on here. I don't think he's trying to shock us at all. I think he's telling a very interesting story that shows how f*cked up Todd really is. He's lost everything, which he considers his family. That's everything to him. He has nothing else and is grasping at strings. At first, yes, taking Marty was about revenge, but from the time that he's spent with her, he's grown close to her. She has essentially become his family. And since that's missing, he'll accept that and go along with it because it's all he has. You do see him resisting at times and I think it's a good thing that they show that resistance rather than Todd just going in for the kill and romancing Marty. He knows this is wrong, but he wants to have someone in his life and right now, the only person giving him the time of day is Marty.

And then you have Marty, who has no idea what's going on, so it works. In a normal situation, Todd and Marty could never work. It should never work. But this isn't Marty right now. She has no idea about the rape. Until Marty's memory comes back, she's a completely new character with a clean slate.

Now, once Marty's memory comes back and she still wants to be with Todd, then I'll be on board in saying that this is a bad storyline.

But as of right now, I'm intrigued. Carlivati is giving me something no other writers are. Controversy.

I'm not giving up. I can't.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Exactly....

I am kind of disturbed on how fast people have turned on this guy. It kind of proves the daytime industry right. They are damned if they do damned if they don't. They actually go and promote someone from within, someone who knows the history and isn't burnt out, and then the minute something goes wrong they are ready to crucify him. I kind of sympathize with TPTB to a certain extent on that regard. I am not watching so I can't comment on the storylines, but I find it very hard to believe he has went from saviour to devil in all of a month. Some fans just need to give things some time....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I also want to point out that I didn't watch the rape live like a lot of other viewers did. I watched the clips on YouTube, but I'm sure it was much more effective to those that actually saw the rape and saw the aftermath of the rape for years to come. So I cannot fault any of you guys for being disgusted by this storyline. That is your personal opinions based on your own values and such. That's fine.

It's sad, really. It's like, even when the daytime industry tries to give fans what they want, time passes and fans are still unpleased.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Between Todd & Marty and the tru wuv of Rex & Gigi being shoved down our throats every frigging day, I've just about had it. Maybe if the actors playing Adriana & Brody weren't wiping them off the screen, or the fact that Rex & Gigi are the smuggest assholes that ever s-mugged.

At least I know when Marty finds out Todd has been keeping Cole away from her she'll rip him a new @$$hole.

Gigi/Rex? Making Brody the bad guy is not a bad idea. He's too sympathetic, the love he has for Gig & Shane is more real to me than anything I'm seeing from Rex. And Rex being angrier at Adriana for not telling him about Shane, and giving a pass to Gigi about it is total crap. Gigi wouldn't even tell Rex until she had assurances from Rex that he loved her. Talk about selfish - Rex had a good relationship with Shane - but Gigi didn't care about that, it was only about her relationship with Rex. She should have put her son first - SEVEN MONTHS AGO.

Gigi not telling the truth - to her son, and Rex - Is like Babe keeping Miranda from Bianca. She is ruined forever for me. And Rex being such an entitled ass - and he still hasn't paid for keeping Tommy's secret, taking Todd's money, and getting Todd stabbed in the process - has ruined him forever for me too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I'm sorry Toupsy, but so? So because RC doesn't have the experience that makes him different somehow? The lack of experience is showing when it comes to OLTL IMO

I truly hope so, but I won't hold my breath, Marty has lost her tits and I don't see RC giving them back to her soon. I don't think it was RC's intention to have people turn on Marty the way they have Todd, but that's exactly what's happening.

Way to go Carlivati, you should be so proud <_<

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I disagree. In today's soap world, couples are usually brought together in 3 months, and in that three months, they've made love, proposed and are usually married, and then on the brink of divorce.

With Rex and Gigi, Carlivati spanned this storyline out for almost a year. It's been so long since it has taken a whole year for a couple to come together.

But how can anyone truly turn on Marty? This isn't Marty, people! She has freaking amnesia. She doesn't know Todd Manning from Joe Stuart. That's why the storyline works.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Well, yeah. I mean, the guy barely lasted a year or whatever. Take a look at Bill Bell: for decades he's been writing two shows simultaneously and did it splendidly for most of the time. Lorraine Broderick didn't falter after a year, Clarie Labine didn't... So what I'm trying to say: it can be done, people don't want a good six months or a year. They want at least two years.

This was like seeing a train plummet off a bridge so fast with such intensity it was barely believable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • If a soap actor or behind the scenes figure was roasted at any point in time, who would you have at the main table? This topic came about when I imagined a Friends episode (Joey, of course, would bomb at roasting). The Roast of Deidre Hall, circa 1997 Roastmaster: Drake Hogestyn Roasters: Jed Allan, Wayne Northrop, Joseph Mascolo, Eileen Davidson, Christie Clark, Alison Sweeney, Ken Corday, James E. Reilly, Andrea Hall, Jane Elliot, James Reynolds, Shannen Doherty, Wilford Brimley, and Frances Reid.
    • Amanda has been giving it to Abby ever since her and Chance walked in on them together. So great to hear.   I can see that. Lily and Damian are always a highlight to me. 
    • I recall @Chris B asking about this but here is an interview Sheri Anderson did with SOU back in the fall of ‘89: Here is an article that I think is interesting, it is an interview with Shery Anderson, screenwriter of the ninth season THE WRITE STUFF: FALCON CREST’S SHERI ANDERSON: FROM DAYS TO NIGHTTIME By Richard Spencer Soap Opera Update, 1989 : At a time when the success of nighttime soaps is shaky, Sheri Anderson, former headwriter for DAYS OF OUR UVES, ANOTHER WORLD, GUIDING LIGHT and GENERAL HOSPITAL, makes the jump to the evening format with some new ideas to help strenthen the CBS California vineyard based soap opera FALCON CREST. "FALCON CREST is going to have a differnet tone that it never had before," headwriter Sheri Anderson expiains. "The people that I am working with are kind of an interesting mix. The executive producer, Joel Sumow, did the first years of MIAMI VICE and THE EQUALIZER, Bob Cochran, a Harvard MBA,and Cyrus Nowrasteh, who has done a number of features, are story editors. I am co-porducer, with a history in daytime, so we are a real different mix. We all kind of balance each other out in different ways. I am sort of the emotional side (coming from daytime) and they are more the gritty side." A lack of focus is what Sheri attributes to FALCON CREST's problems the last few seasons. "No one , seemed to knwo that the characters' motivations were. Pilar was a real good example. No one seemed to know what she wanted. This season it is clear that Pilar wants Lance. That is really her dream and goal tokeep Lance. She will do anything to do that. She will be making some sacrifices thís season that really jeopardize her relationship with Lance." While Pilar's character may be strongly in place, Maggie's is not. How will the show restructure in light of Maggie's drowning? " We are not trying to replace her, but we are adding another kind of strong heroine character. That character is Laruren Daniels. She's very earthy; married to a construction worker. Lauren. is the sister of Michael Sharp, Gregory Harrison's new character. "Michael is an extremely powerful adversary to Richard Channing. He will be more cynical than Richard and less emotionally motivated. For Michael it is all power and money. The audience will be more sympathetic toward Richard. He will be going through hell," Sheri reveáis with doom in her voice, "...Paying for his past sins " The complete opposite of Richard or Michael's intensity is the the new character of Charlíe St. James."Charlie is every woman's foolish choice," Sheri character sketches. "He's kind of indescribable; charismatic, totally unpredictable, charming, unnervtng. He's coming in as a love interest for Emma. He will be the first man to make Emma feel like a woman. She's really not victimized by him...she’s addicted to him. Charlie's presence will make her a little less flakey this season." But Emma is not the only one in store for major personality changes, also in the categroy is Frank. "We arebringing back somebody from his past," Sheri reveals "there will be a great secret that will come to ight." Speaking of characters from the past, are there any Sheri would like to return? "Everyone is fond of Ana-Alicia in her original role. At this point we don't have any plans to bring her back because we have some other character that are going to take the forefront." And if one thing is going to remain the same, it will be what Sheri recognizes as the theme of FALCON CREST "Quest for control of Falcon Crest. We have people trying to take control, and they are all taking it for different reasons. Some are emotioanl, some are revenge, but they each have a different eason for which they want Falcon Crest. And that is really the pivotal center. It is very earthy." Keeping the core of lite show intact is not the only thing nighttime shows have to do to stay interesting and acording to Sheri"I din't think night time shows have kept paces with changes in the viewing audience," Sheri answers by analyzing what exactly is primetime soaps* problem. ln datyime, you do over the years the shows stay on, but you are adapting to what people are accepting:faster-paced, or slower, or addíng more comedy, depending on the audience, and what they are buying. I don't think some of these shows in primetime have done that "We are trying to make the show as much episodio as it is continuing. We are cutting down the number of scenes in each act to get the audience more involved. But some of the shows, and this happens in daytime al so, don’t let the characters really grow," Sheri certainly made chracters develop during her daytime career, but especially on DAYS OF OUR LIVES, which is the source for her favourite stories of her careen ”When Víctor carne to Salem and revealed tha the was really Bo’s father, it caused such a ripple effect for Kim, Shane, Román, Bo, Hope, Caroline and Sean. I also liked bringing Kayla back for Patch.” Having written for Kristian Alfonso' s Hope (DAYS) and now Pilar on FC, Sheri distínguishes between the two characters. "Pilar is a woman, but Hope was growing up. Hope was more innocent and Pilar is not Pilar has an intelligent strength where Hope did all the wrong things for all the right reasons." Pilar wíll be the only one retuming from her family, while Angela Channing’s appearances will be limited (per Jane Wyman's contract). "But Richard will be taking a very strong role which is very similar to Angela Angelad presence will be felt in every epísode/ Sheri informs. A lot of people complained about the women of FALCON CREST being wishy-washy They certainly aren't this season Sheri emphasizes. "Lauren will be strong, especially after her brother Michael steais Richard’s children and places them with her, Frnak’s step daughter will be very devious, indicateive of Kathleen Turner in “Body Heat” And Gregory Harrison is fabulous," Sheri reports with joy. "He is so different from his character on TRAPPER JOHN, M.D He is very similar to Michael Douglas in the film 'Wall Street'. FALCON CREST viewers will find a much richer textrae, getting away from the glamour and really going to substance and style." Sheri concludes, "it will be a show to watch, We are trying to bring in a new audience, and at the same time, respect our past audience."
    • Well, if he's had a series of mini-strokes along the way (which, IIRC, he did), then that influences things. I can say, from my experience of having had two full-blown strokes, that recovery periods were very, very different, both in terms of difficulty and length of time.
    • Whhhhhhhhhhhattttttttttttttttt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Was everybody out this weekend.
    • She did have a thing with him in the late '90s, before she inexplicably disappeared with no mention as to why, although I can't remember if they had sex.
    • I don't believe she did. She did sleep with Simon, believing he was a Spaulding.
    • -- If I ever get sick, please don't send me to Garland Memorial. That hospital is a YIKES. -- Soooo much activity around the main nurses' desk. Do they move dead people on a gurney past that desk, too? -- 8 months for Bill to recover from a "small stroke"? Uh....I don't think so. Is anyone researching this stuff? The hospital stuff is not coming off as realistic. -- It's good that Derek and Ashley are being integrated into other stories, but it's a real stretch to say Leslie was "stalking" Ashley. It makes Derek seem dumber than we already think he is. -- Ashley spends a lot of time having small talk while she's at work. -- Chelsea is embarrassing. Period. -- Tomas is supposed to pick up the slack for Bill, but he has time to have worthless conversations with Leslie? OK then. -- Kat is destroying the case against Leslie, but that's clearly the way to keep Leslie on the canvas.
    • 6-3   I almost let my system just delete the episode just like with B&B. I am now questioning if I should have. lol.   I just can't believe that Cole sat there and started to get sick and then only Victoria off and ran off and everyone basically went back to what they were doing at Nikki's birthday party. Cole was too much of a vet character for that. And now story back off-screen.   I did chuckle at how much Victor pay Kyle dust. And now Kyle with this deal and a promise to leave town if he hurts Claire. smh. As if Victor isn't going to make that happen.   It was lovely to see Ashley. And actually (misdressed and all) Abby.    And I liked Claire's dress. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy