I have to respectfully disagree with you Sylph. I don't think it's lazy writing. It's working on a history that's already there and giving you good mileage from the story.

Lazy writing isn't always going for the obvious. Lazy writing is what GH does with their Mob rival/family comes to town and wants to deal, Sonny/Jason resist and a war breaks out. It's wash, rinse, repeat each time.

Y&R doing an story with Nikki falling off the wagon could be very interesting if done well, and could open up other stories for characters such as Kay, Jill, Paul and others.

Agreed. Lazy writing is using new characters to redo a story you did a decade ago. Lazy writing is having someone suddenly become addicted out of nowhere.

In this case, substance abuse is a chronic condition. It never went away. They dallied with pill use at the tail end of the Bobby Marsino story...but Nikki went away on a cruse and when she returned it was forgotten.

This is a very appropriate time to show us that she is either strong enough to fight, or watch her plummet anew. Either angle is intriguing, because Nikki is NOT the same pampered housewife she used to be.

As long as Nikki is not rescued by TGVN, I'm fine with it. She deserves to enter the pantheon of Genoa City Troubled Broads that Gay Men Worship. Katherine already resides there. I believe she kicked her addictions without the aid of a passing One True Wuv.

Cat

Agreed. Lazy writing is using new characters to redo a story you did a decade ago. Lazy writing is having someone suddenly become addicted out of nowhere.

In this case, substance abuse is a chronic condition. It never went away. They dallied with pill use at the tail end of the Bobby Marsino story...but Nikki went away on a cruse and when she returned it was forgotten.

This is a very appropriate time to show us that she is either strong enough to fight, or watch her plummet anew. Either angle is intriguing, because Nikki is NOT the same pampered housewife she used to be.

This type of attitude destroyed the soaps. You're basically saying: More recycled stories! No matter how well-written - it's been done, they are recycled. It's lazy because it's easy.

And BTW - I wish Nikki jumped off a cliff in a nervous-breakdown-brought-because-of-alcoholism kind of thing. And never ever come back.

The most id!otic character ever. Played by the most annoying actress EVER.

Done.

This type of attitude destroyed the soaps. You're basically saying: More recycled stories! No matter how well-written - it's been done, they are recycled. It's lazy because it's easy.

And BTW - I wish Nikki jumped off a cliff in a nervous-breakdown-brought-because-of-alcoholism kind of thing. And never ever come back.

The most id!otic character ever. Played by the most annoying actress EVER.

Done.

Glad you are done.

I hate recycling soap stories as much as you.

But dealing with a chronic condition on a continuing drama is NOT recycling. Indeed. soaps/serials are the rare form that can do justice to such a thing.

But dealing with a chronic condition on a continuing drama is NOT recycling. Indeed. soaps/serials are the rare form that can do justice to such a thing.

Mark, it's just a cr*ppy story for any soap, especially one as campy as Y&R can be. Alcoholism is so eighties!

Unless, of course, Nikki jumps off a cliff or has a car crash or something like that.

The most annoying character ever. And that whiny voice does not help.

Slyph are you kidding me? Alcoholism is so eighties? This is a problem that MANY people have to deal with. This character has a history of abuse. It makes sense for her to downward spiral (or be tempted to).

I don't understand how you can say alcoholism is so eighties.

Eighties in the sense - a story that might have been features in the eighties on soaps. It's been done, gazillion times.

Most stories on soaps have been done gazillions of times. It doesn't mean it's lazy writing or re-exploring a character's past addictions is lazy writing.

Most stories on soaps have been done gazillions of times. It doesn't mean it's lazy writing or re-exploring a character's past addictions is lazy writing.

Long Day's Journey into Night.

I mean, the tales that can be told around substance abuse.... I'm dumbfounded that this might be viewed as anything but potentially great. My pic-at-left, though, clearly shows how I feel .

Long Day's Journey into Night.

I mean, the tales that can be told around substance abuse.... I'm dumbfounded that this might be viewed as anything but potentially great. My pic-at-left, though, clearly shows how I feel .

See - why rewrite Journey when Journey is just great. Anything else - a faint copy.

It was mentioned today about Niki falling off the wagon again. If they are going to do this story again it better not drag out.

Edited August 4, 200817 yr by Soapsuds

But dealing with a chronic condition on a continuing drama is NOT recycling. Indeed. soaps/serials are the rare form that can do justice to such a thing.

If you'd like a masterpiece written about alcoholism, let me point you towards Zola's L'Assomoir.

Edited August 10, 200817 yr by Sylph

Oh, god. Not another bout of alcoholic Nikki again. That was pretty bloody horrible back in the day, with Melody's "oh the pain!" acting.

Oh, God.