Jump to content

Should American soaps rethink their format?


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 100
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

I think they have an illusion that they know, but they don't.

To illustrate a point: you have tons of people on the internet who believe that they're ATWT's (e.g.) next Douglas Marland just because they can write a soap blog or some fan fic or something. But to thump out a, say, 100-page story bible is something completely different.

And HW's job is not just the bible! Contracts, network, managing the staff, editing... You get the picture.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Well, hence my example about telenovelas and how many of them actually ended up being backdoor pilots for new shows. In fact a better handled Nightshift might be something like that. Sneak it under the audience, wait for them to get attached to it and then turn it into a new soap. And if it doesn't catch on, end it and claim that it was always the intention to be just a limited experiment. And keep trying on a smaller scale till you hit gold.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

That makes sense to me. It's like what Sci-Fi did with Battlestar Galactica. They made it a miniseries, that could act as either a pilot, or the beginning of a series. If it did well - series. If not? It stands alone as a miniseries and nobody looks dumb.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Soaps have too many things working against them right now. Good writing can't compete with the business realities of trying to produce 250+ shows a year on a shoestring budget. My friend who recently became a stay at home mom tried watching soaps but she found herself watching Without a Trace on the picture-in-picture. Guess which show won out?

Writing's the easiest to pick on because everybody thinks they can do it. But to do it five days a week? While you have executives and their focus groups breathing down your neck? And no money to do anything great with? And fighting cable showings of primetime shows like ER and Law & Order which, when shown daily, feel just like a soap only edgier and more modern?

Now throw in fans who bitch about new characters, the implementation of budget saving measures like CGI or product placement and staying true to their (often selective) memory of a character that was created by someone else. Why would a truly visionary writer like a Joss Whedon or JJ Abrams, both of whom have done some of the soapiest writing I've ever seen, even consider doing daytime?

You could dig up Mark Twain, Tennessee Williams and Zora Neale Hurston reanimate them through voodoo and black magic and make them headwriters and people would only complain how the undead don't understand soaps.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

For example, an unshootable scene description? (Because that one is the easiest, and the epithet can apply to anything from story bible to scene descriptions etc.) This one is borrowed from T. Rossio:

INT. WAREHOUSE - NIGHT

A big guy opens the door, comes into the warehouse. Larry is dead, stabbed in the back. The big guy looks at the knife, then turns and stumbles out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Abrams with his $50+m deal is not interested. Besides, he wouldn't be a fit for daytime.

Oh, "that fatuous comment that if Dickens were alive today, he'd be writing for EastEnders; a remark that can only be followed by the reflection that if Dickens did write EastEnders, it would be so very much improved in quality as to be unrecognisable." :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The sole question is whether networks really want soaps. Because if they don't then it really is a moot point. I don't think that it really has that much to do with business realities because other countries show that money can be made with soaps. Yes, even soaps that air during the day rather than at 6pm.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Although several people have made very good points in this thread, I, myself, have no qualms with the format of (American) soaps today. Call me a simple-minded optimist, but I truly believe soaps would have no trouble finding audiences if they just went back to basics: good stories, performed by good actors. As Doug Marland said, that's all you need.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Just to be clear I wasn't referring to the actual JJ Abrams or Joss Whedon. I just used them as examples. And, saying that Abrams wouldn't "be a fit for daytime" is exactly the kind of thinking I'm referring to.

Nothing is a "fit" for daytime anymore because so much has changed. Audience expectations have changed. And I know that someone will jump in here and say "Audience expectations haven't changed we still want family and romance, etc..." but the steady hemorrhage of viewers says otherwise. The leftover viewers want the same thing they were getting 20 years ago but those things are harder to provide in the modern climate. For example, you see people lamenting the fact that we don't get lavish wedding events or location shoots, anymore but those are harder to do now for very practical reasons. Then people complain about CGI even though it's well accepted in primetime.

On the telenovela suggestion, I think the structure might work but I'm not sure about the stories. I believe MyNetworkTV tried that and failed. But MyNetworkTV is pretty much a failure all the way around so who knows, perhaps someone else could make it work. Networks may resist soaps now specifically because its a never-ending money pit. The 13-week format may work. Or just writing them with the expectation that they will end in 2-5 years could be enough.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I think this is true.

One thing they could do: if the supercouple has this huge fanbase, spin off a little show, 1/2 hour, about that couple and their new life somewhere else. If the fanbases are that big, it would work. If they aren't that big, then write them off to live happily ever after as the German soap did.

The reason it is so hard to write good stories appears to be that the couple has to stay frontburner, yet they need drama, so they break up and get back together over and over again, which gets old for everyone not obsessed with the couple. The fanbase doesn't even like it; third parties are forever interfering and threatening to develop new fanbases.

If there were, for example, a Jack and Carly sitcom where they live happily ever after and enjoy the hijinx of their children, their fanbase is happy, and ATWT is not bogged down with the need to put them on all the time; and the newbies can be better liked because they aren't there to create drama and break up Jack and Carly, only to have their hearts broken when Jack and Carly reunite! They can do something more interesting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Yes, that was his last appearance. 
    • I am ready for Joss to take a nice long trip to see her father in Australia and give the character a break and a recast. If the show is hell bent on keeping Eden at least give the girl stories that play to some of EM's strengths.  Dead boyfriends, sex tapes, trying to become a Dr., and now a spy?  None of that works for a character that should be a bitchy, spoiled brat causing trouble in the background.  Not the younger leading heroine.
    • Too bad Anne Meacham is no longer living.  Wouldn't it be great to see Louise Goddard appear as Anita and Vernon's housekeeper????
    • In my usual video hosting site, acct: shallotpeel, title of video is: 1998 SOD Awards Show (This is abridged, soaps only.) The 14th Annual SOD Awards Presentation 1998 with Drake Hogestyn & Leeza Gibbons hosting Opening Number introduced by Linda Dano, the segment follows & it’s Guys in Drag in Daytime AW Cass & Jake DAYS Ivan & Ivan again GH Kevin & Mac BEACH Eddie (Peter Barton) The first winner isn’t shown, from AMC, playing Liza ‘s mother, she even thought to thank her cat Clark. I think her cat entertained the judges in style. Of course this is Jennifer Bassey, who plays Marian Colby. From AW Judi Evans, Tom Eplin & Lisa Peluso presenting Best Villainess Clips of Watros, Allison Sweeney clips (Days Sami), Gina Tognoni. Alli wins. B&B’s Barbara Crampton & Ian Buchanan present Best Villain. Roger Howarth wins. Show (off) clips of ATWT & B&B Jennifer Bassey & Michael E Knight present Best Male Newcomer & Jensen Ackles wins. Dominique Jennings, Sherri Saum & Jason George present Hottest Romance & Hayley & Mateo win. Sharon Case, Jennifer Gareis & Josh Morrow present Best Younger Female Lead &  Sarah Joy Brown wins.  Show (off) clips of DAYS & GH Vanessa Marcil & Ingo present Favorite New Couple & Philip & Harley win. Michael Nader & John Callahan present Best Female Newcomer where this is not shown but it’s a female from Y&R, Trisha. Jon & Kelly Hensley present the special Editor’s award which goes to Bob & Kim from ATWT. Kathy Hays, may she rest in peace, was both classy & entertaining. Debbi Morgan & Mitch Longley present Best Male Scene Stealer & John Ingle won. Rhonda Ross Kendrick & Henry Simmons presented Favorite New Character & Laura Wright won for GL’s Cassie. Kristoff St. John & Shemar Moore presented Hottest Female Star & Sharon Case won & among others she shouted out Bill Bell & the camera found him in the audience.  Show (off) clips : GL & beginning of OLTL ….   
    • The writers need to stop writing Nick/Sharon as forever young and beautiful star-crossed lovers and write them as the middle aged adults with grown children that they are.
    • Yes. He was asleep in the living room, over in the chair that is sideways to the room, but faces it & he had one of his bad dreams in the exact same way as always & as always it woke him up. Is that a thing? Are there bad dreams that for some reason always wake you?
    • Just happy to see the Pointer Sisters getting their flowers again, thanks to GTA 6.

      Please register in order to view this content

       
    • Yeah, I was fickle. I abandoned baby watch & just tried to think of really well matched pairings. Yeah, they sent Carter & Thomasina away far too soon for my way of looking at things.  I REALLY liked them & they were rare being both young & African Americans. 
    • My watching in that time period was sketchy.  After high school, I didn't have a TV.  I would watch in the dormitory common room  my first year away from home, but then after that I lived in a rental with housemates who didn't want TV.  I think I caught up on the soaps during school(univ) vacations, when visiting my sister's house.  And then many many years later on soapnet?  Not sure. I had no idea that Jeff ever tried suicide. Reading just now is the first I ever heard of that. Interesting. I will agree that Monica wanted Jeff out of the way so she could be with Rick, but she would have wanted him gone emotionally.  But I don't remember watching Jeff having any medical issues, so I don't know if she would have wanted him dead.
    • Didn't he have a nightmare last week?
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy