Is bottled water healthier?

[Sylph]

Bottles, bottles, everywhere

By Ramon Cruz Posted Wed Mar 26, 2008 12:38pm PDT

This post is by Ramon Cruz, Senior Policy Analyst for Living Cities at Environmental Defense Fund.

It's ironic. In many parts of the world, there is no clean drinking water. Here in the U.S., pure, drinkable water flows out of every tap, and yet Americans buy a staggering amount of bottled water. We pay big bucks for it, too — more than $15 billion a year.

Worse of all, the bottles are overflowing our landfills and contributing to global warming. Take a look at this video from Doug James:

Video

Also illustrating the case against bottled water:

•  More than a quarter of bottled water is just processed tap water, including Pepsi's Aquafina and Coca-Cola's Dasani. Despite this, bottled water consumption is growing at 10 percent a year, faster than any other beverage. We drink 15 times more bottled water today than we did in 1976.

•  This doesn't mean we're healthier, despite the ads. Federal regulations for municipal water are far more stringent. Bottled water rules allow higher levels of many contaminants, with more lenient requirements for filtration, testing, and reporting. See NRDC’s bottled water report for details of contaminants by brand.

•  The earth isn’t healthier for it, either. According to the Pacific Institute’s fact sheet (PDF), manufacturing the 30+ billion plastic water bottles we bought in 2006 required the equivalent of more than 17 million barrels of oil, produced more than 2.5 million tons of carbon dioxide, and used three times the amount of water in the bottle.

And these numbers don't include transporting the bottles. Nearly 25 percent of bottled water crosses national borders before reaching consumers.

Adding in transportation, the energy used comes to more 50 million barrels of oil equivalent -- enough to run 3 million cars for a year.

Case study: Fiji water

Fiji Water produces more than a million bottles of water a day, while more than half the people in Fiji do not have reliable drinking water (see this Fast Company article). Adding to the irony, Fiji itself uses almost no bottled water, according to a Pacific Institute report (PDF). They export it.

Shipping Fiji Water around the world increases its environmental footprint. Manufacturing and shipping a one-liter bottle produces over half a pound of greenhouse gas emissions and uses nearly 7 times the amount of water in the bottle, according to calculations by Pablo Päster on TriplePundit.

The heavy use of water is as serious as the greenhouse gas emissions. Water is fast becoming a scarce resource.

What about recycling?

Recycling would help, but we don’t usually do it. Less than 20 percent of the 28 billion single-serving water bottles that Americans buy each year are recycled. Some estimates are as low as 12 percent.

According to a Container Recycling Institute report (PDF), the national recycling rate for all beverage containers is 33 percent. In states with deposit systems, the rate jumps to 65-95 percent. But of the 11 states with deposit laws, only three include containers for non-carbonated beverages (like water), though non-carbonated beverages now comprise 27 percent of the market.

Last November, Rep. Edward Markey (D-Mass.) introduced a national bottle bill to address global warming that includes water bottles and other non-carbonated beverage containers.

The beverage industry, which long resisted deposit laws, has started to cooperate — mainly because it sees bottled water as the answer to the soda sales slump. Following months of bad publicity, manufacturers like Coke, Pepsi, and Nestlé have begun making lighter-weight plastic bottles and are encouraging consumers to recycle.

Better yet, carry tap water

If you buy bottled water, recycle the bottle. But the better solution — for you and the environment — is to drink tap water, both at home and at restaurants:

•  Tap water is cleaner than most bottled water.

•  Tap water is delivered to homes and offices for $0.002 a gallon. Bottled water, which can cost as much per gallon as gasoline, is a thousand times more expensive.

The quality of municipal water in the U.S. is generally excellent. Don’t let the recent reports about pharmaceuticals in tap water deter you — see this TreeHugger post for why.

But if you don’t trust tap water or you have old plumbing or you think tap water tastes funny, then try a water filter like those from PUR or Brita. To learn more about water filters, check out the rated list of water filter review sites at Consumer Search.

To carry water with you, use a reusable container filled with tap water. But don’t reuse single-use water bottles. This can expose you to bacterial build-up and carcinogens leached from the plastic.

Quite a few companies make reusable water bottles. There’s an ongoing debate about the safety of the polycarbonate plastic some use, but there are many safe reusable bottles made from other materials.

Use it or lose it

National Geographic’s Green Guide notes, "the federal share of funding for water systems has declined from 78 percent in 1973 to 3 percent today." This places the financial burden almost entirely on local governments.

Food and Water Watch also talks about how important it is to stop this trend and maintain the quality of municipal water. Its Take Back the Tap (PDF) report gives a detailed overview of the issues surrounding tap water versus bottled water.

[Sundance]

I am glad you posted this article on bottled water. There are some people that got very rich in erroneously convincing people that tap water is bad for us and that we should buy their bottle water. In the long run we all pay for this waste of plastic.

Fluoride has been added to tap water to help prevent tooth decay. Ironically many don't drink that water. It is used to take showers, do laundry, flush toilets, etc. In Mexico the people buy 5-gallon recycable jugs to bring into their homes for drinking and cooking. They don't go to all the expense of highly purifiying the rest of the water. I stayed there for two weeks and never got sick.

Meanwhile, if you really don't like your tap water, you can get your own clean jugs refilled at reverse stations. Some Wal-Mart stores have these for only 25 cents a gallon. See: Reverse Osmosis

[Sylph]

No problem, Sundance, thank you for your contribution.

[JackPeyton]

i love bottled water - i am a guy on the go and it makes my life much more simple.

tho i never have understood why epople drink bottles of water at home.

[Noel]

I don't drink a lot of bottled water unless I party, but that's just about it. But thank you for posting this.

[Sylph]

I don't drink it that often, too. I'm glad this thread got a positive feedback.

I generally hate those preachy and condescending health, correct nutrition, fitness articles, but sometimes I think it's OK to address certain issues.

[juppiter]

I stopped drinking bottled water about a year ago. I am not an environmentalist at all usually, but I heard on the news that $1000 worth of bottled water is equal to like 20 cents of tap water. So I bought a "Nalgene" and fill it with tap water. After a while you de-psych yourself and realize that tap water is not polluted.... it's perfectly clean water.

[EricaKane70]

I don't think bottle water is healthier, and its not even cheaper. There are more people going to the dentist because bottled water does not have fluoride which is suppose to prevent cavities. Also why does bottled water cost $1.00-2.00?

[Sundance]

Its that price because there are some dumb thirsty people willing to pay it!

[DevotedToAMC]

I have heard something about bottled water having a better health standard so that is a good thing since most of the time I drink it from the bottle. Either way, it is pertinent to include enough water in your diet because it does a body good...forget milk. All about the water doing the body wonders

[EricaKane70]

Devoted you should not forget milk, its good for your bone health. You especially want to drink milk or some type of calcium supplement if you are a white female because they are more prone to getting osteoporosis.

[DevotedToAMC]

oh I don't forget milk...I include milk, juice, water, gatorade, in my diet. Devoted treats his body well

[juppiter]

Unless it says "spring water," you're drinking filtered tap water. Buying a Brita does the same job for cheaper.

[Sundance]

For those that do drink bottled water, do you put the bottles in a recycle place?

[DevotedToAMC]

I tend to recycle them, Sun