Roger D. posted this on his board ...we love the soaps

"I've seen one person say they know who it is but can't say until it is released on Friday or Monday. They implied we were going to HATE it with a passion."

Tracey Melchor or whatever her name is....

Tracey Melchor or whatever her name is....

I hope not. I will be sending letters to SOW & SOD complaining about it. That is for sure. I will write and even call to complain.

No offense to whoever they choose, but I hope it bombs. It won't be the recast actor's fault, but the execs. Martha IS Lily. Don't make me have to send cans to the damn studio......

No offense to whoever they choose, but I hope it bombs. It won't be the recast actor's fault, but the execs. Martha IS Lily. Don't make me have to send cans to the damn studio......

I think we are going to have deja vu all over again. I have a feeling a lot of cans will be sent to ATWT before all this mess is cleared up.

Looking at ATWT's history, didn't Goutman learn his lesson from the lady he replaced as EP(FMB)?

It's going to be Connor-gate all over again. Soap fans get your cans ready to send over to ATWT studios!

This post may come off a bit mean-spirited I would love to see Susan Haskell play the role. She's brilliant. Now, here's a list of actresses that should never, EVER be considered as recasts on soaps:

Christina Chambers - put the most simplistic, one-note spin on one of One Life's most complex and legendary characters.

Tracy Melchior - has the stage presence of a goat.

Jennifer Bransford - plays whatever the scene calls for without building a character.

Christina Chambers - put the most simplistic, one-note spin on one of One Life's most complex and legendary characters.

Tracy Melchior - has the stage presence of a goat.

Jennifer Bransford - plays whatever the scene calls for without building a character.

You know what's funny, Christina Chambers's name was familiar but I couldn't remember until I read again "one-note spin" and realized it was OLTL's Marty '07. Jesus. That woman can really drive the spirit out of every character she plays.

When she replaced Leslie Kay at ATWT in 2004, I was like, "who the $#&* is this?" because it certainly wasn't Molly. And they were just finishing some spectacle of a storyline that demanded much more spirit than Christine delivered. By the time it was over, she was on the, "I need to leave town to clear my head" depression/depressing ish. Leslie Kay's Molly had issues but she wasn't depressing.

Anyway, you're totally right about her. And Tracy Melchior was another "hit the snooze button" actress. The AIDS story on B&B really should've been much more endearing if anyone who could act played it.

It doesn't matter who they have cast as the new Lily. I don't think the majority of ATWT fans will ever accept her as Lily. I know I won't.

I think they should get the actress who played Rose. She was a dead wringer for Martha Byrne!

I think they should get the actress who played Rose. She was a dead wringer for Martha Byrne!

That's because Martha Byrne portrayed Rose.

I think they should get the actress who played Rose. She was a dead wringer for Martha Byrne!

That's because Martha Byrne portrayed Rose.

That's because Martha Byrne portrayed Rose.

Duh lol, I want her to stay.

Duh lol, I want her to stay.

Haha, I walked right into that one didn't I!!! Just call me Rose from the golden girls.... LOL

I want her to stay too.

Maybe its Beth Ehlers.