Jump to content

American Idol: Discussion Thread


R!ck

Recommended Posts

  • Members

Well, I wouldn't go that far Kenny. There have been many people with issues such as that who are famous and successful. Once she gets with someone who can help her, she will be fine. I don't see her winning anyway as she isn't as likeable as some of the others (especiall Jordin and Melinda) but I think she has improved quite a bit in terms of the way she is in interviews and such.

I wouldn't say Jordin and Melinda is a slam dunk. Those are my two as well but Blake can easily knock one of them out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 1.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Phil - just as boring as ever. He sucked tonight. The judges are on crack. I think they are building up the other people in the competition who suck so Sanjaya will go this week.

Jordin - a little boring in the beginning, but it picked up. I haven't watched every week, but she impresses me every week I do. I really love her. She should be in the final three, if it's based solely on talent. She can be the idol. She has the look, the voice, the talent, the humor, the personality, and the potential.

Sanjaya - hilarious. I love when he flirts with girls and tries to make the songs about girls when he clearly loves boys. I will say it takes guts to come out so positively every week. I am glad Simon was blunt this week. Love Simon.

Lakishia - boring. I don't like her. She should have learned from whatshername from last season. Never pick an Idol's song!!! I don't think she is humble at all.

Chris - I don't think Country is his thing. I love him, but I really wonder if he wants this. He doesn't have the desire and ambition the others do. F Idol. Do Playgirl.

Melinda - What is there to say? She's never looked better either. Give her a free pass to the final two.

Blake - That's not even a country song originally, moron!! (Much love to Ryan Adams, the original writer/performer.) He's not that great. I'm sorry. I hate the way he drabs and draws things out. And I HATE his mouth when he sings. I also hate how he never changes his performance at all. It's the same stupid thing every week.

Ryan Seacrest, I really cannot wait for five years down the line when you are on the unemployment line being a big loser because it's what you are, and it's what you deserve!!!

Everyone but Jordin and Melinda deserve to be in the bottom three.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

LOL I thought I was the only one annoyed with Blake's mouth. It's annoying.

I agree Melinda & Jordin were better then everyone by a mile.

My rankings lastnight...

1. Jordin

2. Melinda

GAP

3. Phil

4. Blake

5. Lakisha

GAP

6. Sanjaya

7. Chris- Hate that he was pimping votes for the V Tech shooting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

The world is so cynical. Chris is from Virginia and probably has friends at Virginia Tech. If he hadn't said anything, people would probably be complaining about that.

I thought Lakisha was the worst. Hearing her sing a Carrie song showed me she is not going to win this thing. I just don't like Phil so I don't think he could do anything to change that. I was hoping Sanjaya would sing a real country song and wear a cowboy hat. What a let down.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

While I'm sure that the condolences sent by Chris were heartfelt, I'm sure that a small part of him knew that it would work in his advantage by winning sympathy votes. Did anyone notice how Chris more or less interrupted the judges critique of him to bring up the Virginia Tech situation? As soon as Simon said something bad about him, he jumped in with the condolences line... seemed VERY obvious to me that he was trying to cut Simon off at the pass.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I just found out my 11 year old niece has been voting for Sanjaya and I've threatened to throw her cell phone into Lake Michigan. She says "but he's soo cuuuuuute". I'm to the point I can't even look at that kid any more. And I hate Ryan Seacrest even more than I already did because of the way he's been pimping him. I'm so glad Simon shut him up last night. Sanjaya started out as kind of a sweet, clueless young boy who seemed to have a little charm. Now he's an egotistical, arrogant, smirking kid not smart enough to realize he's become a huge joke. Fun and games are over, he needs to leave tonight.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

But you no what is so bad about this whole ordeal...Randy, Simon and Paula put Sanjaya through to the top! They could have easily saw how horrible he would have been. They are all supposed to be so good at picking the next big star why did they screw up here. I place some blame at their feet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Breakdown writers can pitch stories and obviously they have influence over what is included in the breakdown but MVJ is the final decision maker. It depends on the faith you have in MVJ if you feel Carlivati is going to be a problem. I don't think a throwaway having a book author named after him is a sign he's taken over the show. Most people didn't even catch the reference.
    • Tamara Tunie reading that damn letter is exactly why I wish this show had more experienced actors.
    • BETH CORRELL'S FRIEND

      Please register in order to view this content

              CATHERINE COX        Also Credited as Catherine Carpenter; Catherine Carpenter Cox                      12/13/1950 - Present THE EDGE OF NIGHT     Billie Schumann   1984 THE GUIDING LIGHT     Unknown Role     Unknown Year LOVING         Unknown Role     Unknown Year AS THE WORLD TURNS     Phyllis Leonard    Unknown Year ANOTHER WORLD     Nurse Margaret     6/29/1990 and STARS IN THE HOUSE     Self    2021 Appeared in two episodes of LAW AND ORDER  (2002; 2006) and an episode of THE COSBY SHOW (1990). PILOTS/PROPOSALS FOUR IN LOVE      Pam        1980  CBS     movies BUNKO      Cat     2007 TENDERNESS      Bowling Waitress     2009 BROADWAY MUSIC IS     12/20/1976 - 12/26/1976        Viola   **** DRAMA DESK AWARD NOMINEE -- OUTSTANDING ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL WHOOPEE!      2/14/1979 - 8/12/1979    Harriet Underwood OKLAHOMA!   12/13/1979 - 8/24/1980    Replacement -- Ado Annie Carnes   July 1980 - ???? BARNUM     4/30/1980 - 5/16/1982    Replacement -- Charley Barnum  3/3/1981 - ???? ONE NIGHT STAND    (Never Officially Opened)  10/25/1980   Amanda Klein SHAKESPEARE'S CABARET   1/21/1981 - 3/8/1981    Catherine BABY     12/4/1983  - 7/1/1984    Pam Sakarian    **** DRAMA DESK AWARD WINNER -- OUTSTANDING ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL OH COWARD!    11/17/1986 - 1/3/1987       **** TONY AWARD NOMINEE -- BEST ACTRESS N A MUSICAL RUMORS     11/17/1988 - 2/24/1990    Replacement -- Chris Gorman FOOTLOOSE    10/22/1998 - 7/2/2000      Ethel McCormack TOURING GODSPELL    10/22/1972 - 7/28/1973       Understudy GODSPELL   9/10/1973 - 6/23/1974   Performer GODSPELL     1976 " Bless the Lord"        National Tour MUSIC IS   1976      Viola       National Tur SIDE BY SIDE BY SONDHEIM     1979 STARTING HERE, STARTING NOW CITY OF ANGELS   7/4/1991 - 11/24/1992     Replacement -- Oolie; Donna THEATER COMPANY     1977     Amy    Heinz Hall    Pittsburgh, PA RAP MASTER RONNIE    1984                Village Gate Upstairs IN TROUSERS     1985      His Wife    Promenade Theatre WONDERFUL TOWN    1988      Ruth Sherwood    Goodspeed Opera House    East Haddam, CT THE WAVES     1990    Rhoda    New York Theatre Workshop GODSPELL    2000  York Theatre   NYC HOT AND SWEET    (Staged Reading)   2000    Dodge Stages   NYC ANNIE      2002     Miss Hannigan    Paper Mill Playhouse   Millburn, NJ MEMPHIS      (World Premiere)  2003    Ensemble; Susie; Patti Page; Clara   Understudy -- Gladys Calhoun   North Shore Music Theatre    Beverly, MA MAME     2004   Mame Dennis    Merry Go Round Players     Auburn, NY RICHARD CORY     2005     Mrs. Baker    NY Musical Theatre Festival Production INSPECTING CAROL     2006     Zorah Bloch      George Street Playhouse   New Brunswick, NJ MARRIED ALIVE!      2008      Diane     Gulfshore Playhouse     Naples, FL MEMORY IS THE MOTHER OF ALL WISDOM    2009     Mother    Barrington Stage Company Stage II     Pittsfield, MA THE MEMORY SHOW     2010     Mother     Barrington Stage Company Stage II     Pittsfield, MA VOTE FOR ME: A MUSICAL DEBATE      2010    Governor Janet Tilghman    Urban Stages Theater   NYC FLAMBE DREAMS   2012     Elaine Christiansen     45th Street Theatre THE MEMORY SHOW     2013    Mother   The Duke on 42nd Street BY STROUSE IT'S BETTER WITH A BAND SWING SHIFT!      Vera       Theatre by the Sea Marriages      Keith Hermann   ???? - ????       Divorced      David Evans     1986 - Present    2 Children     THE ORIGINAL ARTICULETTE         SHERITA BOLDEN   BEYOND THE GATES     Barbara that founded the Articulettes   (v)  6/3/2025              Works Behind the Scenes as a Booth Production Assistant     2025 PodCast THE YATRA SISTERS     Co-Host and Organizer       DETECTING LESLIE'S IMAGE?           DREY WIGFALL     Born   Andre DeShawn Wigfall                  6/25/1981 - Present BEYOND THE GATES    D. C. Metro Analyst -- Detective __ Walker    6/2/2025 and YO MOMMA      Self           2006   ALL THE QUEEN'S MEN      Officer Green    2023 movies SOLICIT BEHAVIOR     Mr. Young     2007    (Made for T. V.) KISSING STRANGERS    Jeff     2010 THE CANADOO   Derrick     2016 A SOUL BURDENED    Corporal Marcus Andre Hughes    2021 IT HAPPENED IN THE 4TH QUARTER   Mr. Gaines    2023 THE COMEBACK     Paul    2023 ZOMBIE VIRAL STUDIO     RADIO SLAVERY: THE MAKING OF AMERICA Upcoming MEND      TBA    Pre Production THEATER IN THE BLOOD           University of South Carolina MA RAINEY'S BLACK BOTTOM     Trustus Theatre         FOUND KAT LURKING                RICH LOWE       Also Credited as  Rich Lowe Ikenna           8/10/1987 - Present BEYOND THE GATES     Darius -- Hotel Employee   6/6/2025 and BUBBLY BROWN SUGAR      Caleb     2018 Upcoming INTERTWINED PROOF OF CONCEPT     David     TBA     Pre Production movies SEVEN MILES FROM FOREVER    Joshua Wright     VERA'S HOLIDAY FLOP       Ex-Husband      THE LEAST OF ALL     Matthew Reynolds    2017 THE GREAT WAR     Corporal Johnson    2019 HYPOCRITE     Eddie Ogden    2019 THE ORATORY     2021 HEARTBEAT   Cliff     2022 COME OUT FIGHTING   Private Michael "Salty" Buttons     2022 Upcoming    LIONEL       TBA     Completed THEATER THE ROYALE     2017     Fish      Raymond James Theatre     Saint Petersburg, FL         E. M. T.                       NILES AUSTIN      1/8/1994 - Present BEYOND THE GATES      E. M. T.     4/17/2025; 6/6/2025 Appeared on the series SINS OF THE CITY (2023). movies SIGNUM    Michael   2024 Currently working as a studio assistant at Dream Inc.  BTG Recurring actress Jerri Tubbs works there as an Instructor.           Kenjah  (McNeil)    pg. 445 BEYOND THE GATES     Dr. Madison Montgomery     6/4/2025 - Present   Adam Chambers    pg. 445 DAYS OF OUR LIVES     Dave the Skydiving Instructor           June 6,  2025 Leann Hunley       pg. 425   DAYS OF OUR LIVES     Anna Fredericks Brady DiMera    8/2/1982 - 7/10/1986; 6/21/2007 - 4/2/2009; 12/10/2009- 6/5/2010; 1/9/2017 - 2/16/2017; 1/5/2018 - 2/14/2018; 8/9/2019 -  4/21/2020; 12/18/2020 - 5/31/2023;   6/6/2025 - Present     One more on the way!      
    • Oh wow. After reading your post, I realized that they had "Carl Ivati" in the script AGAIN yesterday June 6.    Eva said she was reading his latest, and Tomas said "Work's been so busy, I haven't had time to get into his new series". Then Eva proceeds to tell him that "the first book is called 'Mercy and Goodness' and it's all about how the couple first met and how they got separated".   She goes on and on about how great it is. And she says she has the book in her hotel room if he wants to borrow it. She says it has twists and turns. And meanwhile Kat is snooping in Eva's room to look for the helmet and gloves, and finds the book and dismisses it as "basic". I saw that whole scene -- but I wasn't paying attention to the name of the author.  And when Tomas said the name, I heard it in his accent so I didn't hear "carlivati".  II was mainly trying to see if the acting had improved with the actor playing Tomas, and I think he has improved somewhat.   I only see it when typed out. So they had several scenes yesterday about a "Carl Ivati" book?  Barf! Well at least Kat had the good sense to dismiss it as "basic". Ron Carlivati wrote the breakdown yesterday!   Featuring himself in it! Addressing to the collective "you" whoever you may be: Some of you, months ago, said Oh Ron is only doing breakdowns.  The story comes from MVJ, so he won't influence things, you said. May 27 started it, with Christopher Dunn breakdown and Lynn Martin script. But they didn't need to continue it June 6 with Carlivati breakdown and Jazmen Darnell Brown script.
    • I was completely lost. But it is wonderful that it exists. I didn't really know Robert Mandan had done soaps...well, besides SOAP.
    • Jack and Jennifer are tired. I just don't care about them when they return. They add nothing to the show.
    • Did they really bring back Jack and Jennifer for Jack to prop up Leo and Jenn to serve as an obstacle to Chad/Cat? Are we sure Ron still isn't in the building?
    • We can only hope that they finally kill off Leo too 
    • We can only hope that maybe the new writers might read this.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy