Marlena site

Edited May 22, 200817 yr by ChrisL

ITA!! General Hospital has got to be the wrost soap on air!

All of the characters are horribly written! GUZA NEEDS TO GO!!

I don't quite agree on everything stated. For instance:

Then after an operation, Michael goes into a coma which the doctors tell his mother is irreversible. And Carly refuses to listen to them, because in her head, she “knows” Michael will wake up. Huh? What parent, what mother, doesn’t listen to doctors when their child’s life is at stake?

I don't see the harm in this one. No mother would just accept that their child is gone, and since when are doctors considered as absolute truth?

BTW I don't watch GH anymore, but is Dylan Cash officially gone from the show?

I don't see the harm in this one. No mother would just accept that their child is gone, and since when are doctors considered as absolute truth?

BTW I don't watch GH anymore, but is Dylan Cash officially gone from the show?

I agree, MTSRocks.

Hit the nail on the head! Great column, Marlena!

BTW I don't watch GH anymore, but is Dylan Cash officially gone from the show?

Yes. He is moving on and doing other projects.

She hit the nail on the head. The story is insulting and distasteful drivel, as is the show as a whole.

Yes. He is moving on and doing other projects.

Wonderbra commercials?

Another great column! I will relish the day Bob Guza gets fired. GH will never be good again if Guza continues to write.

We could wrangle about whether Carly, as a mother, would or would not have taken the doctor's word as final on her son all day long. It's a matter of opinion.

We could also debate whether Carly has evolved that much from her days as Sonny's dysfunctional f*ck-bunny. I don't think she has but many believe her actions the last few weeks (like asking Sonny to give up his rights to Morgan) represent a total 180.

Marlena also talks about the CarSon limo scene as if Guza meant for it to be some great love reunion. I disagree with her. I don't think Guza cares about love in the afternoon or even "love in wartime," as he so memorably puts it. I think he views Carly as a sociopath. And Michael's death represents punishment for Sonny. I think Guza wanted the limo scene to be seedy and pathetic. Because GH is not a soap to him. It's a drama, like The Sopranos! Revealing the rotten motives of rotten people!

Marlena's point, though, is that GH is soulless and empty and emotionally bankrupt. And I absolutely agree with her.

You know, a show like The Shield -- which I love -- shows the soulless, violent and morally bankrupt underbelly of inner city LA. But even at its most depressing and despairing, there is soul and evolution and real emotion, thanks to the characters. Even the conflicted anti-hero Vic Mackay has a soul. Well, GH doesn't even have that. TIIC just want to focus on characters with no redeeming qualities whatsoever because they think they are pushing the envelope or something.

Edited May 23, 200817 yr by Cat

Guza and McTavish are like soul siblings. They write with such misogyny its absolutely disgusted. I loved Marlena's describing the "Real" AMC. She hit the nail right on the head. Its been refreshing with all facets of this Jesse/Angie storyline to see us getting glimpses of what our show used to consist of.

Marlena's point, though, is that GH is soulless and empty and emotionally bankrupt.

It's been that way for the better part of 20 years.

It's been that way for the better part of 20 years.

Hmmm, I don't know. 15 years ago, the show was offering me plenty of heart.

Marlena also talks about the CarSon limo scene as if Guza meant for it to be some great love reunion. I disagree with her. I don't think Guza cares about love in the afternoon or even "love in wartime," as he so memorably puts it. I think he views Carly as a sociopath. And Michael's death represents punishment for Sonny. I think Guza wanted the limo scene to be seedy and pathetic. Because GH is not a soap to him. It's a drama, like The Sopranos! Revealing the rotten motives of rotten people!

Cat, I completely agree

Hmmm, I don't know. 15 years ago, the show was offering me plenty of heart.

15 years ago the show was already destroying legacy characters to prop Sonny.

It's been a downward spiral ever since.

ITA!! General Hospital has got to be the wrost soap on air!

Agreed. With AMC a close second, with the exception of the great jesse/Angie storyline.

Edited May 24, 200817 yr by Cola