There was something off for me in Monti Sharp's portrayal, similar to when he was on ATWT a year earlier as a villainous doctor. I remember him being positioned as the heavy in the triangle with Dara and Taggert - a triangle I never cared about, and neither did the show. I liked Dara but no one at GH had any interest in her - my guess is Guza would have dumped her immediately if he'd had the option.
Philips for me played the different parts of Justus perfectly well, but he did not fit into Guza's toxic fantasies.
One of my main memories of Justus of this period is Ned smirking, smugging, and judging, as he spent 90% of his time doing.
I truly despised Ned in these years.