Discussion for the week of September 5

Matthew's up and speaking! Oh wait...

It's a real shame that they've all but fired Eddie Alderson

The way Destiny put her hand to her mouth, I couldn't tell if she was shocked that Shane would attempt suicide, or embarrassed that she had enchiladas for lunch.

It's a real shame that they've all but fired Eddie Alderson.

What do you expect? You don't kill Kelly Nelson and get away with it.

I still don't know why Blair is stretched out on that piano. Is she a cabaret singer? Is she paying homage to Michelle Pfeiffer on "The Fabulous Baker Boys"?

And Bo's bumper is just embarrassing as hell.

Edited September 5, 201114 yr by Khan

Oops. Tea just said Todd is the type who "shoots first, asks questions later." Hope that isn't foreshadowing.

I feel like this episode is kind of a strange one to re-air unless they're going to deal with Eddie's murder again soon. I thought it was the one where they had to get Shane to stop from jumping, not the aftermath of it.

Eddie Ford isn't dead. He's still alive...and Irene Manning is responsible.

Destiny: Oh, Shaun, I'm so glad you're here!

Shaun: What's wrong?

Destiny: Part of my tracks fell out on the way over!

Shaun: Baby, no?!

Edited September 5, 201114 yr by Khan

I refuse to pity Blair for hitting Jack. I don't think she hit him hard enough. She should've laid his ass out.

Uh, NO Blair. Putting your little [!@#$%^&*]'s ass in check does not make you a bully, it makes you a responsible parent.

"Oh, Nora...."

It's moments like those (at the end) that make me think there's still hope for this genre.

Great job, HBS!

I had forgotten how good AW was in the bullying stuff. Darned shame it was dropped for Ghost Gigi crap.

Blair, dear, your son does NOT need anymore violence in his life. Time to re-take your anger management classes b/c you fail as a parent when you can't even control your own worst impulses.

Tea and Viki, ah I so miss their scenes together.

Edited September 6, 201114 yr by TeamEric

The show spent the last few years saying Todd's violence to women was fun and cool and no big deal to Jack and he never seemed phased by the various assaults on Blair in the last few years, including her almost being stabbed to death, so I can only come to the conclusion that the show sees any violence in Jack's life as perfectly fine. The bullying story quickly gave way to a pity party for Jack anyway.

Edited September 6, 201114 yr by CarlD2

The bullying story quickly gave way to a pity party for Jack anyway.

Some pity party. The story came and went and I still don't know why Jack ever bothered with Shane. Bullies have to have a reason for their bullying, I think. Even Todd raping Marty was motivated by something deeper.

Some pity party. The story came and went and I still don't know why Jack ever bothered with Shane. Bullies have to have a reason for their bullying, I think. Even Todd raping Marty was motivated by something deeper.

I think the idea was to imply that Shane was just weak and Jack was cool and dangerous (and the one we're truly supposed to sympathize with), like Todd. Remember the Matthew bullying story - they used that to help turn Matthew into a nasty character. I think on some level we may be expected to side with the bullies in these stories.

Edited September 6, 201114 yr by CarlD2