Lily is VERY much like Drucilla.

CK is not.

Hence TPTB deliberately writing Lily as obtuse to Chloe which they didn't & wouldn't when Davetta played Lily.

Personally I don't think Davetta would have allow Daniel & Amber get away with what they did. Matter of Fact I can't see her going out like how CK did. This what I mean CK going with the flow with what the writers are writing.

Edited July 7, 200817 yr by MoTheGreat

Personally I don't think Davetta would have allow Daniel & Amber get away with what they did. Matter of Fact I can't see her going out like how CK did. This what I mean CK going with the flow with what the writers are writing.

That could be why they recasted, because Davetta was playing the Lily in such a way where we as an audience would never expect her to let them get away with that. But I think if given the chance seh could have played Lily the way they wanted her to.

They write Colleen the same why they did when Adrienne was playing her

The hell they do.

The writing for Colleen has been lacking ever since Tammin was cast.

Just about everything about the character has been changed because Tammin can't convey any of it.

Lily on the other hand has never been written like Dru.

Yes she has.

Which is why it is absolutely absurd the way TPTB constantly reference how much Lily is like Dru with CK playing the part.

And if she ALWAYS will be very much like her mother as you say, then again she wouldn't have put up with that porn mess nor would she still be friends with Chloe.

As Darn previously stated it's most likely TPTB wouldn't have done the porn story with Davetta.

And the EXACT same character knew from jump Carmen was trouble & had NO PROBLEM confronting her nor did the EXACT same character have a problem confronting the bitchy college girls who trashed her Mother at the coffee house.

Now all of the sudden she's BFF with & giving chance after chance to a chick who's NEVER been anything less than rude, obnoxious & openly coveting everything in Lily's life including the boyfriend she's so in love with?

Complete writer's contrivance to fit the actress.

It's clear the writers intended for Lily to be like she is now which is why they brought CK back.

It's clear the writers intended for Lily to be an vehicle for their idea of "diversity" via an "actress" who never has & never will be capable of doing the role justice.

Edited July 7, 200817 yr by DeeeDee

As Darn previously stated it's most likely TPTB wouldn't have done the porn story with Davetta.

And the EXACT same character knew from jump Carmen was trouble & had NO PROBLEM confronting her nor did the EXACT same character have a problem confronting the bitchy college girls who trashed her Mother at the coffee house.

Now all of the sudden she's BFF with & giving chance after chance to a chick who's NEVER been anything less than rude, obnoxious & openly coveting everything in Lily's life including the boyfriend she's so in love with?

Complete writer's contrivance to fit the actress.

Damn shippy! Deeedee is on fire tonight.

Edited July 7, 200817 yr by MoTheGreat

Complete writer's contrivance to fit the actress.

That seems to be a huge theme on Y&R with female characters and recasts. We've seen it happen to Victoria, Lily, and Colleen.

That seems to be a huge theme on Y&R with female characters and recasts. We've seen it happen to Victoria, Lily, and Colleen.

It's agenda driven.

What's happened to Victoria alone is cringeworthy.

The hell they do.

The writing for Colleen has been lacking ever since Tammin was cast.

Just about everything about the character has been changed because Tammin can't convey any of it.

Yes she has.

Which is why it is absolutely absurd the way TPTB constantly reference how much Lily is like Dru with CK playing the part.

As Darn previously stated it's most likely TPTB wouldn't have done the porn story with Davetta.

And the EXACT same character knew from jump Carmen was trouble & had NO PROBLEM confronting her nor did the EXACT same character have a problem confronting the bitchy college girls who trashed her Mother at the coffee house.

Now all of the sudden she's BFF with & giving chance after chance to a chick who's NEVER been anything less than rude, obnoxious & openly coveting everything in Lily's life including the boyfriend she's so in love with?

Complete writer's contrivance to fit the actress.

It's clear the writers intended for Lily to be an vehicle for their idea of "diversity" via an "actress" who never has & never will be capable of doing the role justice.

The writing for Colleen was lacking before Adrienne left, she was reduced to Gina's waitress and a back up character to Kevin, Jana and Lily. But character wise she was still the same, the good girl who will stand up for her friends no matter what and who doesn't like to be told by her father what to do.

And yes Lily is compared to Dru as far as her being a model but we're talking about personality here. And then they try to say things like oh Lily is so caring and compassionate like her mother, when every heroine or non villainess on the show is caring and compassionate. Most people with decency are.

CK's Lily has confronted people as well including Carmen who was still on when CK took back over the role as well as Amber who she saw through right from the beginning. But confronting somebody hardly makes her like Dru. Everyone confronts people at some point and anyone whose father Carmen was dating would have confronted her regardless if Dru was their mother or not.

If you want my honest opinion, while Davetta may have been more feisty than CK she still was a long way from Dru. The Dru who grew up on the streets and in the hood. Davetta may have had mouth but she hardly comes off as someone who could have handled herself in the streets. The reason why Dru takes no mess is because she had to fight for what she had, Lily did not. She grew up as a cushy princess. The main difference between CK and Davetta is that CK comes off more as a pampered caucasian girl while Davetta came off more as a pampered black girl.

The writing for Colleen was lacking before Adrienne left, she was reduced to Gina's waitress and a back up character to Kevin, Jana and Lily. But character wise she was still the same, the good girl who will stand up for her friends no matter what and who doesn't like to be told by her father what to do.

And yes Lily is compared to Dru as far as her being a model but we're talking about personality here. And then they try to say things like oh Lily is so caring and compassionate like her mother, when every heroine or non villainess on the show is caring and compassionate. Most people with decency are.

CK's Lily has confronted people as well including Carmen who was still on when CK took back over the role as well as Amber who she saw through right from the beginning. But confronting somebody hardly makes her like Dru. Everyone confronts people at some point and anyone whose father Carmen was dating would have confronted her regardless if Dru was their mother or not.

If you want my honest opinion, while Davetta may have been more feisty than CK she still was a long way from Dru. The Dru who grew up on the streets and in the hood. Davetta may have had mouth but she hardly comes off as someone who could have handled herself in the streets. The reason why Dru takes no mess is because she had to fight for what she had, Lily did not. She grew up as a cushy princess. The main difference between CK and Davetta is that CK comes off more as a pampered caucasian girl while Davetta came off more as a pampered black girl.

Indeed.

The writing for Colleen was lacking before Adrienne left, she was reduced to Gina's waitress and a back up character to Kevin, Jana and Lily.

The writing for Colleen ONLY took a turn when "Korbleen" didn't work as well for viewers as TPTB had hoped.

Before that she & Adrian were on almost EVERY day & it was JT who took the bullet for that relationship.

And yes Lily is compared to Dru as far as her being a model but we're talking about personality here.

Lily has been compared to Dru ever since she was born & especially since she was SORASed.

CK's Lily has confronted people as well including Carmen who was still on when CK took back over the role

The only reason CK's Lily confronted Carmen was cause she returned in the middle of that story.

And that "confrontation" wasn't even a confrontation to the point where Lily who up until then had been written as a PRIME suspect in Carmen's murder was backburnered completely.

as well as Amber who she saw through right from the beginning.

She didn't like Amber in the begininng but she didn't confront Amber until Extreme Catwalk which happened way after Amber had done a lot of damage to her, her friends & her marriage.

Everyone confronts people at some point and anyone whose father Carmen was dating would have confronted her regardless if Dru was their mother or not.

Hardly.

Prior to Davetta's Lily the ONLY person Lily confronted other than her Family was Kevin & she only confronted Kevin AFTER he raped her & tried to murder Colleen.

If you want my honest opinion, while Davetta may have been more feisty than CK she still was a long way from Dru. The Dru who grew up on the streets and in the hood. Davetta may have had mouth but she hardly comes off as someone who could have handled herself in the streets.

Davetta's Lily was very much like her Mother but not exactly just as Dru was like her Mother (Mamie) but not exactly the same & Davetta's Lily was afforded opportunities her Mother wasn't just as her Mother & Aunt were when they were her age.

The reason why Dru takes no mess is because she had to fight for what she had, Lily did not.

Hence the constant issues between them.

But Lily DID grow up with a strong sense of self, a strong degree of cultural pride, a love for family, the ability to think for oneself & an appreciation of the advantages afforded through education.

And once she & Daniel got married she didn't expect her parents to take care of them.

She got a job & was willing to not go to college (and risk upsetting her parents in the process) to pursue something that would fufill her even if she & her husband had to struggle.

The main difference between CK and Davetta is that CK comes off more as a pampered caucasian girl while Davetta came off more as a pampered black girl.

The difference between Davetta & Christel is Davetta could elicit empathy & convey warmth & growth.

Christel can't.

Edited July 7, 200817 yr by DeeeDee

The writing for Colleen ONLY took a turn when "Korbleen" didn't work as well for viewers as TPTB had hoped.

Before that she & Adrian were on almost EVERY day & it was JT who took the bullet for that relationship.

Yes which is what I said, Colleen took a back seat before Tammin took over the role.

The only reason CK's Lily confronted Carmen was cause she returned in the middle of that story.

And that "confrontation" wasn't even a confrontation to the point where Lily who up until then had been written as a PRIME suspect in Carmen's murder was backburnered completely.

But again all soap characters confront people. Even in the short amount of time Sabrina and Adam have been on they have already had several confrontations with people.

She didn't like Amber in the begininng but she didn't confront Amber until Extreme Catwalk which happened way after Amber had done a lot of damage to her, her friends & her marriage.

But she confronted her when she found out what she did.

Hardly.

Prior to Davetta's Lily the ONLY person Lily confronted other than her Family was Kevin & she only confronted Kevin AFTER he raped her & tried to murder Colleen.

But Lily had no reason to confront anyone else other than family members or Kevin. (She also confronted Daniel as well). What is she going to do, confront people for no reason?

Davetta's Lily was very much like her Mother but not exactly just as Dru was like her Mother (Mamie) but not exactly the same & Davetta's Lily was afforded opportunities her Mother wasn't just as her Mother & Aunt were when they were her age.

Hence the constant issues between them.

And those opportunites shaped her into a much different person than Dru.

But Lily DID grow up with a strong sense of self, a strong degree of cultural pride, a love for family, the ability to think for oneself & an appreciation of the advantages afforded through education.

Most people have those qualities..most good people any way. Most people have a strong cultural, love their family, and those that have education tend to appreciate them and have a strong sense of self. In fact Brad Carlton, Jack Abbott, Victoria..(I could go on)

have all those characteristics. Most normal people have all of those characteristics. They'are not unique to Dru or Lily. Dru shares no unique personality traits with Lily.

Yes which is what I said, Colleen took a back seat before Tammin took over the role.

No.

You said Colleen was backburnered when Tammin took over the role which was completely not the case.

At all.

But again all soap characters confront people. Even in the short amount of time Sabrina and Adam have been on they have already had several confrontations with people.

Eh.

But she confronted her when she found out what she did.

She KNEW Amber was a bitch THE ENTIRE TIME.

Yet she stood idly by while Amber repeatedly insulted & was rude to her friend & caused a ton of problems in her marriage.

But Lily had no reason to confront anyone else other than family members or Kevin.

Yes she did.

(She also confronted Daniel as well).

Eh.

She tried to be tough with him for a second.

That's hardly a "confrontation".

What is she going to do, confront people for no reason?

That's not the point.

Davetta's Lily had a spine.

Christel's never has.

And those opportunites shaped her into a much different person than Dru.

No.

They didn't.

No.

You said Colleen was backburnered when Tammin took over the role which was completely not the case.

At all.

Eh.

She KNEW Amber was a bitch THE ENTIRE TIME.

Yet she stood idly by while Amber repeatedly insulted & was rude to her friend & caused a ton of problems in her marriage.

Yes she did.

Eh.

She tried to be tough with him for a second.

That's hardly a "confrontation".

That's not the point.

Davetta's Lily had a spine.

Christel's never has.

No.

They didn't.

Riiiiiight.

LMAO. Riiiiiiiiight.

Yes they are & yes they do.

My exact words were, "The writing for Collen was lacking before Adrienne left the show," which basically means she was backburned before she left. And yes Brad Carlton has all of those qualities, he definitely has a strong sense of self, a pride for his jewish culture, he's supportive of Colleen and going to college, the same as Dru and Neil are so yes he has the ability to think for himself. And most of the characters share those qualities.

And again everyone has confrontations, that's hardly a unique character trait. And no, Davetta's Lily did not confront Carment until way after she thought Carmen was still after Neil. And I wouldn't call Lily spineless, she's just a poor judge of character. She confronted Chloe when she found out about the kiss, but she 's naive enough to believe that Chloe isn't after Cane, the same way Davetta's Lily was naive enough to believe that Daniel was a good person to marry in the first place. Both Lily's were warned numerous times about how these people were, yet Davetta's Lily still married Daniel, and CK's Lily is still friends with Chloe.

"The writing for Collen was lacking before Adrienne left the show," which basically means she was backburned before she left.

Eh. No.

The implication was that Colleen was heavily on the backburner.

And she wasn't.

And again everyone has confrontations, that's hardly a unique character trait. And no, Davetta's Lily did not confront Carment until way after she thought Carmen was still after Neil. And I wouldn't call Lily spineless, she's just a poor judge of character. She confronted Chloe when she found out about the kiss, but she 's naive enough to believe that Chloe isn't after Cane, the same way Davetta's Lily was naive enough to believe that Daniel was a good person to marry in the first place. Both Lily's were warned numerous times about how these people were, yet Davetta's Lily still married Daniel, and CK's Lily is still friends with Chloe.

The constant strawman arguments are hilarious.

Lily on the other hand has never been written like Dru.

I totally agree. Otherwise we wouldn't be hearing find your inner Dru or you're more like your mother than you think. I suppose DS is the first recast in history to portray her character in a different manner than the original actress. I could never get into her version.

PJA I am totally with you on this one!