I agree the show has stalled again. And the dialogue can be so tough when nothing is happening... Nevertheless, I had some downtime this weekend and probably won't this week, so I made a point to catch up. These characters and performers are (mostly) so great, and all the ingredients are there for the stories to be compelling, but they keep dragging them out and/or skipping over the drama.
I can't believe Bill is once again getting out of the hospital with no long-term health consequences or anyone being the wiser that Hayley is poisoning him. After coming so close to figuring out what's going on, it seems like the "Only Murders Beyond the Gates" club has once again gotten distracted on a tangent: this time the idea that Hayley is having an affair with Randy, like with Lynette and the fake mugging except at least they were right that time. Sooooo frustrating, and not in a "Make 'Em Wait" way. And seeing Mike on Friday was just a reminder that Hayley could still be on the show at this point (if that's why they're dragging this out), had this story reached a logical conclusion months ago and he was representing her at trial.
Relatedly, they're burning through (wasting) so much material for Dani and Andre. If I actually believed Bill was in any medical jeopardy at this point, that alone could have driven a wedge between Dani and her current husband. There's also Dani carrying the BRCA gene. Exploring Andre's past love(s) definitely should have happened further down the road. And this is a bit late because I've been on the fence but I've finally come down firmly on the side that Dani and Bill hooking up during the tornado was out-of-character for her and just plain illogical (but also unnecessary at this juncture). Dani is a mess but being cheated on was so traumatic for her, I don't think she would do that to Andre, at least without a lot more remorse. Even if they did eventually have an affair, Dani could have been drawn back to Bill organically, like after those other obstacles had taken their toll on her marriage, and then finally acted on her feelings at a time more conducive for sex. They wouldn't even have needed an imminently life-threatening situation, to a degree that would be a turn-off to many people, because they both have had reasons to be feeling their mortality all year.
Speaking of skipping over drama, I still believe Martin and Smitty should have met in the first week(s) of the show and gotten to this point over years after a real romance. I think I've said that before and I know I've said the same thing about Jacob and Naomi, but at least those two are not saddled with grown children. And it is not playing to the actors' strengths. They each have many charms and good chemistry together, but they're not nearly as experienced as the cast members who would have the gravitas to be playing matriarchs and patriarchs (some of whom are playing said children's grandparents).
Other random musings on the past few episodes:
Why would Naomi and Tomas argue over legal strategy in front of a client, let alone in front of opposing counsel? And wasn't Naomi, who sued the firm for sexual harassment last year, being really inappropriate in pulling rank and badgering Caroline about whether she thinks her colleague is cheating on her husband, who's also Caroline's boss? I guess if Caroline filed a complaint there's an argument that Naomi has no actual authority at the firm, but that's also problematic.
Was Leslie/Dana being a bartender as well as waiting tables always part of her back story with Bill? I only remember the part about the diner. Couldn't they have just stuck with that and lightly redressed the Orphey Jean's set?
Bill and Ted's scenes reminded me that Ted could easily be Bill's confidant, instead of Joey. And the fact that it was the same episode as Iziah laying it on so thick about Joey reminded me that they also initially teased Bill having been a father figure to Iziah. So much of this would be more interesting if you substituted Bill for Joey. Heather is fine, notwithstanding what I said about not being needed in Andre's sphere at this point, but I'd be more interested in meeting someone from Bill's family.
By
DeliaIrisFan ·
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.