Jump to content

OLTL Todd/Marty II: Exactly Why Soaps Are Dying!


Recommended Posts

  • Members

As someone else pointed out, Todd isn't supposed to be a good guy. Even TSJ has said Todd shouldn't be a good guy. He's not interesting as a good guy and he shouldn't be. I don't want Todd redeemed. I do agree though that, Todd's never been this disconnected from his family before..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 39
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Todd has never been a good guy, nor rootable, but he's never been so completely crazy before either. Higley's pincushion made the character seem rather inept whenever he even tried simple revenge. Now, with the strike writers, he became both a coward and a bully. I can't say he's never done anything like this before -- he even had Nora for a little time after her memory loss ordeal, but that was offscreen. From the getgo, his even holding Marty captive seemed crazy, and the audience wasn't clued into his plan for awhile. Then, most people thought he was crazy if he thought he could pull it off. Now we are to believe the sudden change of heart?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Todd has never been a good guy, nor rootable, but he's never been so completely crazy before either. Higley's pincushion made the character seem rather inept whenever he even tried simple revenge. Now, with the strike writers, he became both a coward and a bully. I can't say he's never done anything like this before -- he even had Nora for a little time after her memory loss ordeal, but that was offscreen. From the getgo, his even holding Marty captive seemed crazy, and the audience wasn't clued into his plan for awhile. Then, most people thought he was crazy if he thought he could pull it off. Now we are to believe the sudden change of heart?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Todd has never been a good guy, nor rootable, but he's never been so completely crazy before either. Higley's pincushion made the character seem rather inept whenever he even tried simple revenge. Now, with the strike writers, he became both a coward and a bully. I can't say he's never done anything like this before -- he even had Nora for a little time after her memory loss ordeal, but that was offscreen. From the getgo, his even holding Marty captive seemed crazy, and the audience wasn't clued into his plan for awhile. Then, most people thought he was crazy if he thought he could pull it off. Now we are to believe the sudden change of heart?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Todd has never been a good guy, nor rootable, but he's never been so completely crazy before either. Higley's pincushion made the character seem rather inept whenever he even tried simple revenge. Now, with the strike writers, he became both a coward and a bully. I can't say he's never done anything like this before -- he even had Nora for a little time after her memory loss ordeal, but that was offscreen. From the getgo, his even holding Marty captive seemed crazy, and the audience wasn't clued into his plan for awhile. Then, most people thought he was crazy if he thought he could pull it off. Now we are to believe the sudden change of heart?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

While this particular story may not be the death of soaps, the overall misogyny and degradation of pretty much any and every female character in daytime is at the core of it as is the other side of the coin: the romanticizing of abusive sociopaths on one level or another like Todd Manning, Sonny Corinthos, and Ryan Lavery.

Todd & Marty were very different from any other rape story ever told. The brutality, the fear, and fact that the audience was there for almost the whole thing rather than getting a fade out and coming back after. We saw what happened and how deeply it affected her.

The fact that Marty currently has amnesia doesn't mitigate the horrific nature of what's happening here, nor does it make Todd's actions any less abusive. Quite the opposite. As disturbing as it would be for Marty to choose to get involved with Todd of her own free will, at least she wouldn't be his victim again. That's all she's ever been on this show. Todd's perpetual victim and here we are again. He's already raped her again, only even more brutally this time because it also involved her mind. Her entire identity. Her relationship with her child. Everything about herself. He didn't take that before, but he got it this time.

Does anyone honestly think that Todd Manning is gonna pay for this? Really?

He'll get shot or stabbed which will set off some lame murder investigation/trial that will wrap up just before he's revealed as being still alive and Todd & Marty will be "reunited" as the next Luke & Laura and we all know it. There are no limits on the depth to which they can sink now, they've crossed the line and for what? Really, aside from Carlivati's obsession with recreating '80's-'90's OLTL in his own image and failing miserably what was the point of all of this anyway? To show that Todd is a bad man? Anyone who didn't already know that is probably too dumb to figure it now too. That Todd's insane? Again, not a big secret. Regardless of the intent, the net effect is insulting and offensive to women and I'm sorry but if you're not a woman, you just plain don't get it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Apparently, I'm the only one in the world who sees this story NOT as a twisted romance, but as an unbelievably heartbreaking tragedy.

When Marty gets her memory back, just IMAGINE what that woman will be feeling. Just imagine for a moment. Not only will Todd have violated her AGAIN, this time in a truly disturbing, emotionally repulsive way, but she'll (probably) also be left with a feeling of affection for him. What the hell does she do with THAT?

And Todd... how can he go back from this? Like always, his intentions are good, but he goes about them in the WORST. POSSIBLE. WAY. No one will understand him. No one will support him. He'll be adrift and alone again and all due to his own misguided choices.

This is rich, psychological storytelling that we haven't seen in ages on soaps, and I say bring it on. This is gutwrenching, uncomfortable, thought-provoking, controversial stuff. You know, the stuff we claim to WANT on soaps in lieu of another love triangle or baby switch.

I love Marlena, I really do, but I find it hard to believe she'd praise a show like Passions and then claim THIS is what is bringing daytime down? Nah, I'm not buying it, with all due respect.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Thanks Michael. I guess we're in the minority here. Not to say that others haven't made GREAT points, I guess I just see this story differently than how others are perceiving it.

As for Passions... that show was everything WRONG with daytime, wrapped up in a really ugly package. But apparently some find that to be clever, inventive and wickedly satirical. That just goes to show why nobody in a suit knows what to do with daytime when they receive such mixed messages from their audience.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • IKR! Tanya Turner, at one point, was EVERYTHING. 
    • I can see both sides here. I don't believe that everything in that period was intended as comedy, but I think John Considine played the part in a very mustache-twirling way, as did Marcus Smythe as Peter until near the end, and that did come across as the material not being taken seriously. And I think the same is true of some of the treatment of other stories. The Sin Stalker, for instance, has that incredibly batshit material with Crystal Gayle being attacked. It's pure WTF, and something that, if done in more recent decades, would probably end up having the part played by a Drag Race or Real Housewife.  The main takeaway I have from that period is how little those running the show cared. There's just a callousness. And that leads to a real cynicism onscreen.
    • I think too many of Mary's storylines were absolutely depressing. A lot of that  though was mitigated by her relationship with Scott, Cheryl, Ada and other characters though. I'm one of the few who preferred Mary with Reginald and wish that they had made Reginald less of a villain and made the Reginald/Mary/Vince triangle more of a battle and less a foregone conclusion. Mary choosing Reginald had much more storyline possibilities. What if what if what if...  
    • Thank you for the info about SFT related to EON. I thought about adding SFT to my watch list, but I don't know if it's the kind of soap for me. I know very little about it except for a few of the actors and that it was on two different networks. I also know based on this board or somewhere else that the two Lizas both died young from cancer. Warms my heart to see so many EON people on SFT because they are such good performers and I wish they had been moved to other shows. Perhaps, they were and I'm just not aware of it.
    • There was a few times when Silk Press Sheila came into her apartment after going grocery shopping.. she could have been unloading her items as she talked to Eva or Ted and saw a few of the products on the counter that are P & G products.
    • I enjoyed today's show. I liked seeing Mona again and her confronting both Eva and Leslie. I did feel for Eva, especially at the end of their confrontation, when Mona said "Good", when Eva mentioning losing everybody she cared about. Though, I can understand Mona's anger and Leslie deserved every bit of her ire. Both Leslie/Eva betrayed her especially Leslie. Mona put her both her professional and personal relationships with the Duprees on the line and what Leslie/Eva did put her in an awkward position. Speaking of Leslie she continues to act trifling and caring only about herself and her needs. At this point, it only seems like she cares about herself and wanting Ted for herself. I'm not even sure how if her feelings for Mona were ever sincere, though she called out about people turning against her after Mona left. I have yet to see Leslie really display that she sincerely cares about anyone, and I do think that needs to change at some point. I enjoyed Nicole and her scenes today with Leslie/her children. I also like that Martin took a more sensible approach regarding how the family should handle Eva. He did straight up acknowledge she was his sister, and it seemed like he was opened to up to accepting her. I think he will be among the first in the family to soften towards/accept her. And in spite of the way she was introduced into their lives, he will end up being happy to have two little sisters. I wonder again about Kat/Eva being twins/Eva being Nicole, when Martin/Kat brought up them being the same age and Kat even used the word "twins" in disbelief, when Martin suggested they shared a connection from the beginning.
    • LOL! They did show a Pantene and Dawn commercial today. Image them incorporating those into the show. 
    • He joined Julian in Bermuda when he getting a divorce from Ivy. And, was the one who tricked Theresa and Julian in to believing that they had gotten married there. That would be nice.  That was such a good book, and it was too bad that the show retconned it so much. I still have my copy somewhere.
    • Instead of Febreze, Eva pulled a few tissues of Puffs and cried into them. Hayley comes in with a pack of Always and is like "Well, Bill turns out I'm not pregnant." Andre and Derek sharing a bottle of Pepto after eating Ashley's cooking. Vernon and Anita drinking up their Metamucil. 
    •   I liked the actress who played Tina. She was not the typical soap hire. I hadn't thought of her in many years until I saw a Spauldingfield video of her. It makes sense if they were planning to make her Frank's daughter as she was tied to the Coopers and nothing else was done with her beyond singing and the relationship with Marcus that Rauch never cared about. David was hurt by Monti Sharp leaving the role. I don't blame Monti for leaving, as he was getting less and less to do, but Russell Curry was a very generic actor was too old for the part. Yes, black don't crack, but he was nearly 40. When David returns at the end of the decade they cast an actor who was a little too young, which just shows how little interest the show had in the character or black characters in general (and random recasting would return with the Boudreauxs). Marcus is a character who got a lot of buzz early on and then the show lost interest (again).  Anyway, if you stay watching, be warned that the Hart/Dinah/Roger stuff gets worse and worse. Luckily you don't have the same lengthy ties to the show so it may be OK for you. It made me feel a bit sick at the time. Thanks for giving more info. And to @DeeVee and @P.J. as well. I suppose there were tiers of people who were seen as disposable, and Eve was shielded for a time due to that tier. Once they were clearly getting rid of characters like Justin or Amanda, then she was also on that list (I know she left before they did but it wasn't that long before). Characters like Eve, quiet, able to be used in many avenues, are important for community, or they should be, although she had clearly reached a natural end. The problem is no one really replaced her - all the characters who were likely seen as dull were shipped out from 83-85, and we were left with an unbalanced canvas (and characters who were meant to be exciting but were still dull, like Calla, Simon, et al).
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy