Jump to content

AI Quantifies the Greatest Soap of All Time


Wilsoky

Recommended Posts

  • Members

Quantifying the "best" soap opera of all time is inherently subjective, as it depends on individual preferences, cultural impact, longevity, viewership, and critical acclaim. However, by examining various criteria, we can attempt to rank them:

 

Longevity and Episode Count:

Guiding Light holds the record for being the longest-running soap opera, with 72 years on the air, including radio, ending in 2009 with 15,762 episodes. Its ability to adapt and evolve over time is notable.

Viewership and Ratings:

General Hospital has been a top-rated soap for decades, especially known for moments like Luke and Laura's wedding, which remains one of the most watched soap episodes ever. It has been on air since 1963, showing consistent popularity.

Critical Acclaim and Awards:

Days of Our Lives has been celebrated for its storytelling and character development, particularly noted for its iconic supercouples and dramatic plots. It has also received numerous Daytime Emmy nominations and wins.

All My Children is often highlighted for its influence on daytime drama through its portrayal of social issues and the iconic character Erica Kane, played by Susan Lucci, who became synonymous with soap operas.

Cultural Impact and Memorable Storylines:

Dark Shadows stands out for its unique blend of supernatural elements with traditional soap opera storytelling, influencing later shows and even spawning film adaptations.

Dallas and Dynasty are iconic for their primetime success, with "Who Shot J.R.?" from Dallas being one of the most famous cliffhangers in TV history. However, these are primetime soaps, not daytime.

Fan and Viewer Votes:

Community rankings like those on Ranker often place General Hospital, Days of Our Lives, and The Young and the Restless at the top, reflecting fan appreciation over time.

 

Given these considerations, here's a speculative ranking based on these quantifiable measures:

 

General Hospital - For its enduring popularity, significant cultural moments like Luke and Laura, and numerous awards.

Days of Our Lives - For its long run, vast number of episodes, and influence on soap opera storytelling.

The Young and the Restless - For its consistent high ratings, longevity, and impact on daytime television.

All My Children - For its pioneering approach to social issues and the iconic Erica Kane character.

Guiding Light - For its unmatched longevity, though its influence has waned since its conclusion.

 

Please note, this is a speculative ranking based on available data and does not definitively claim one soap opera as the "best" over others, as preferences can vary widely among viewers.

Guiding Light history

Primetime soap operas

Include viewer polls

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 16
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Members

For some reason lately... any time I ask my personal AI-chatbot on my computer something, it makes horrible mistakes and then when I tell him - you are making a huge mistake, he starts telling me he's sorry and then makes another mistake and gives me wrong info yet again. It literally lies to me and then corrects himself and gets all kinds of messed up info from imdb.  

I remember it was more correct months ago.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

Y&R is my favorite soap but I think General Hospital is the greatest soap of all time.

It pulled the largest daytime audience for Luke & Laura's wedding, it invented the super couple, it offers storyline variety: medicine, crime, romance, SciFi, action/thriller, business, and social issues.

It also helped transform the genre from a stage play on TV to melo-dramatic action/adventure. 

Its sweeps events like the train crash and Metro Court were awesome.

As for longevity the only soaps I really hear layman/mainstream audiences talk about today are GH, AMC, and occasionally Y&R.

I hear people mention Erika Kane and Victor Newman and Luke & Laura more than Bob & Kim Hughes, Alexandra Spaulding, or Asa Buchanan.

Edited by Planet Soap
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

LOL… I did a top 10 based on a Q&A with Claude and this is what I got… Y&R, how far you’ve fallen.

 

RankItem

1

Guiding Light (June 30, 1952–September 18, 2009)

2 As the World Turns (April 2, 1956–September 17, 2010)
3 All My Children (January 5, 1970–September 23, 2011)
4 The Edge of Night (December 1, 1975–December 28, 1984; previously on CBS April 2, 1956–November 28, 1975)
5 General Hospital (April 1, 1963–present)
6 One Life to Live (July 15, 1968–January 13, 2012)
7 Days of Our Lives (November 8, 1965–September 9, 2022)
8 The Young and the Restless (March 26, 1973–present)
9 Search for Tomorrow (March 29, 1982–December 26, 1986; previously on CBS 1951–1982)
10 Another World (May 5, 1964–June 25, 1999)
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

What Claude asked me:

What role does historical significance and longevity play in your appreciation of soap operas?

How do you weigh the impact of iconic characters and memorable storylines versus consistent quality over time?

What role does innovation in storytelling format play in your appreciation of soap operas?

Do you give extra consideration to shows that maintained high ratings throughout their run versus those that had more niche appeal?

How do you factor in a show's ability to retain its core identity while adapting to changing times?

What would shift? The ranking sort of surprised me as well. But I do find myself drawn to watching YouTube episodes of the soaps in roughly that order, now that I think about it. I would have ranked AW higher and maybe have swapped OLTL and GH in terms of my general enjoyment. Y&R was my favorite, but I’ve lost a lot of my appreciation for it over the years, and I rarely revisit old episodes.

Edited by Faulkner
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Members

I took your questions & offered them to Bing CoPilot & this was its reply.

Quantifying the "best" soap opera of all time is inherently subjective, as it depends on individual preferences, cultural impact, longevity, viewership, and critical acclaim. However, by examining various criteria, we can attempt to rank them:
Longevity and Episode Count:
Viewership and Ratings:
Critical Acclaim and Awards:
Cultural Impact and Memorable Storylines:
Fan and Viewer Votes:

End of your questions.

Beginning of reply:
Absolutely, ranking soap operas can be quite subjective, but examining them through various lenses can give us a good idea of their impact and legacy. Here are some key criteria and notable examples:

### Longevity and Episode Count:
- **Guiding Light**: This soap opera ran for 72 years (1937-2009), holding the record for the longest-running scripted show in broadcast history.
- **General Hospital**: Debuted in 1963 and is still ongoing, making it the longest-running American soap opera currently in production.

### Viewership and Ratings:
- **Dallas**: While more of a prime-time soap, it had a massive viewership, with the "Who shot J.R.?" episode being one of the most-watched TV episodes of all time.
- **Days of Our Lives**: Has maintained a loyal viewership since its debut in 1965.

### Critical Acclaim and Awards:
- **The Young and the Restless**: Frequently tops the Daytime Emmy Awards with numerous accolades for acting, writing, and directing.
- **All My Children**: Another show with a strong presence at award ceremonies, especially known for its groundbreaking storylines.

### Cultural Impact and Memorable Storylines:
- **As the World Turns**: Known for tackling significant social issues and having one of the first same-sex kisses on American daytime TV.
- **General Hospital**: The "Luke and Laura" wedding episode in 1981 drew 30 million viewers, becoming one of the most iconic moments in soap opera history.

### Fan and Viewer Votes:
- **Days of Our Lives**: Often ranked highly in viewer polls for its dramatic and engaging storylines.
- **The Bold and the Beautiful**: Has a significant international following, making it one of the most watched soaps globally.

Each of these shows has its own unique charm and contribution to the genre, making it hard to declare one as the absolute best. What's your favorite soap opera, and why does it stand out to you?

Please register in order to view this content

I replied that my favorite was Another World & I talked about its characters & its writers. CoPilot then said

"Another World" truly had a remarkable cast and some of the most memorable characters in soap opera history. Constance Ford's portrayal of Ada was indeed legendary, bringing depth and heart to the show. Anne Heche's performances as twins Vicky and Marley were captivating and showcased her incredible talent. Victoria Wyndham's portrayal of Rachel was iconic, and Beverlee McKinsey's Iris brought so much drama and excitement to the storyline.

Agnes Nixon and Pete Lemay's writing contributed significantly to the show's success, creating complex and engaging storylines that kept viewers hooked. It’s no wonder "Another World" remains a beloved classic.

Edited by Contessa Donatella
more
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Unfortunately, your content contains terms that we do not allow. Please edit your content to remove the highlighted words below.
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • OH. The AMC/OLTL Crossover with helicopter, down in the woods, 2 very pregnant, both give birth, only one baby lives. We are on the same page!!!
    • Backtracking because BTG has been distracting me from keeping up with GH. Why is Carly always involved with a paternity lie? Lulu is Dante's (wife? if Im correct) so she has the right to tell him about his son. If anything, she's in a better place to reveal paternity drama than Robin was. As for Robin...I'm conflicted about whether it was HER place to tell AJ he was Michael's dad. Being with a man who's pretending to be someone else's baby daddy is wild. Dante was snoring blaming everyone  but Rocco, however he was right about Jason. A convo isn't enough, neither is trying to be your son's friend. Adolescents need a disciplinarian. At least Lulu made Rocco and Danny scrub the house. 
    • May 2025: Stephanie Sloane interviews Kirsten Storms about all of Maxie's romances in the past 20 years: https://www.swooon.com/gallery/general-hospital-maxie-romances-spinelli-johnny-nathan-kirsten-storms/
    • I saw a new BTG promo during Watson tonight (Sunday May 11).   I don't remember what I saw (and I wouldn't say here on the nonspoiler thread anyhow). I know only that it was different from the "next on BTG" preview at the end of Friday's episode. If anyone catches the new promo, please post it on the spoiler thread.
    • I hope GH gives Lesley an on screen memorial I'd love to have Scott, Robert, Holly, Rose Kelly, Mike Webber, Blackie Parish  & Claudia Phillips return for the episodes
    • As requested by @BoldRestless the 1976 story summary of Y&R from the Daytime serial newsletter. I will post it in parts as it is quite detailed.  Pt 1 Set in Midwestern Genoa City, The Young and the  Restless, which premiered four years ago, is the story of the Brooks and Foster families. Jennifer and Stuart Brooks are, on the surface, the perfect couple, blessed with four beautiful daughters, but under the veneer of a first impression lie cracks in the facade. Jennifer had become dissatisfied with her marriage after the birth of her oldest daughter, Leslie, and had left Stuart with the idea of returning to her former fiancé, Dr. Bruce Henderson. After later reconciling with Stuart, Jennifer found she was pregnant with Laurie, and she has lived all these years with the suspicion that Laurie may be Bruce’s daughter. Leslie  has recovered from a nervous breakdown and is now a famous concert pianist, happily married to former Surgeon now newspaperman Brad Elliot.  . Chris Brooks is married to Dr. William (Snapper) Foster, and Peggy, the youngest Brooks daughter, is a college student. Jennifer recently left Stuart a second time, considering again a life with Bruce, but the discovery of a lump in her breast followed by a mastectomy for cancer has again changed her priorities.   Laurie, meanwhile, has been dating Dr. Mark Henderson, Bruce’s son.  Snapper’s mother, Liz Foster, had finally accepted the fact that her husband, Bill, had abandoned their family and had had him declared dead when he suddenly walked back into their lives, suffering from emphysema. Jill, Liz and Bill’s only daughter, was married to Phillip Chancellor, the father of her unborn child, just hours before his death. Phillip obtained a quick Caribbean divorce upon learning of his impending fatherhood and was badly injured when his now-ex-wife, Kay, meeting him at the airport upon his return, lost control of the car when he told her of his plans to marry Jill. After Phillip’s death Kay vowed to void his marriage to Jill and deprive Jill of |his estate. Kay’s son from her first marriage, Brock Reynolds, supports Jill in her claim, but Kay, a former alcoholic, cannot accept the idea of having lost Phillip to her former paid companion. Greg Foster, Jill and Snapper’s brother, is an attorney working for Legal Aid, where Chris is his assistant. Upon learning that her daughter Lauralee has become engaged to Dr. Bruce Henderson’s son Mark,Jennifer Brooks tells Mark she suspects he and.Laurie are half brother and sister. She explains she spent a week with Bruce after a bad fight with her husband, Stuart, when she believed their marriage was over. A blood test confirms her fears—Stuart cannot be Laurie’s father. Keeping what he’s learned to himself,Mark painfully breaks his engagement to Laurie and leaves town. Laurie is shattered by this, unable to understand what went wrong. But soon she begins to put bits and pieces together and confronts hermother, asking what she said to Mark that drove him away. Jennifer finally tells her daughter the truth and stands helplessly as Laurie turns to run to her father for comfort and suddenly realizes he’s not her father—even this her mother has taken from her. Laurie follows Mark to Cleveland and tries to persuade him that they can still be married—they need not have children—only to be hurt again when Mark sadly tells her their love would become dirty and they would wind up hating themselves and each other. Heart broken, Laurie agrees to let him go. Jennifer has recently left Stuart, due to growing frustration in her marriage, and had planned to marry Bruce, but discovery of breast cancer and a subsequent mastectomy caused her to reconsider her plans. When Stuart earnestly pleaded with her to come home to him and their daughters after her recovery, she agreed, but now her guilt over Laurie’s situation has caused her to waver. When Laurie confides the truth to her older sister Leslie, Les makes it clear to her mother that she finds the idea that Jennifer would think of returning to her father contemptible. But Brad Elliot,Leslie’s husband, warns her to hide her feelings or her father will notice and ask for an explanation.Jennifer gives in to Stuart’s wishes, and he welcomes her home as his wife again. Leslie has had two more piano-concert triumphs and basks in the attention of the music world, as well as that of Lance Prentiss, a wealthy industrialist who has been following her career with avid interest. Les invites Lance home to Genoa City, hoping the dynamic, handsome young titan of business can help distract Laurie from her heartbreak. With the birth of Jill Foster’s baby imminent, Kay Chancellor offers Jill one million dollars for the child —fathered by her late husband, Phillip Chancellor. After Phillip’s death Kay had the divorce ruled invalid and voided Jill’s marriage, making her unborn child illegitimate. But now, finally acknowledging Jill’s baby as Phillip’s, Kay tells Jill she can give the child the Chancellor name and social position, as well as the love she had for Phillip. Jill, torn by love for Phillip and his baby and the extreme financial need of her family (Jill’s father is dying of emphysema and needs a warm, dry climate), realizes that Kay can give her child everything he could need, things Jill could never provide, and agrees to Kay’s terms.  Jill’s son, Phillip Chancellor Foster, is born prematurely a few days later. Liz Foster, Jill’s mother, is horrified that Jill would “sell” her son to Kay, and Jill’s father, Bill, is horrified that it is concern for his health that led Jill to this arrangement. He would rather die than give up his grandson. But when Jill, who has avoided seeing her child, has to take physical custody of him in order to deliver him to Kay, she is suddenly unable to give him up.
    • tagging @Troppo who tracks B&B episode number anomalies -- see above posts.
    • Thanks!!

      Please register in order to view this content

        haha you did good explaining all that. So basically Monday's episode is gonna be what was suppose to be Friday's episode. Even though CBS and PPlus uploaded Monday's Aka Friday's show before they deleted it? LOL
    • I do mean those two, but when I download them, the Chris from Greece version is from RTL with subtitles and starts with a doctor greeting Stephanie and the rsclassicfanfanforever version is from Videoland, no subtitles and starts with Tawny and Becky? Sorry if this was already discussed. Is the Chris version merged with another episode? That one is longer.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy