Okay we know Vanessa is not returning to GH and GH really wants to bring Brenda back. I know most people say NAY to the re-cast. If you had to choose between Budig or Tognoni who would you choose? Budig IMO is all wrong for Brenda. She is too whiny, not deep enough, and her acting is just okay. Tognoni is fabulous actress and she plays vixen/!@#$%^&*] very well. ABC has apparently wanted Tognoni ever since she won the emmy for GL. Gina Tognoni's contract expires at GL in early May. I would definitely say Gina, she is fabulous and she is pretty much the only actress I see as Brenda re-cast.

No no no to a Brenda recast. Vanessa is Brenda. However, if I had to choose, I would definetly go with Gina simply because she is the better actress. I like RB, but not as Brenda.

What I would love, is Vanessa as Brenda and Gina as Carly. I always wanted Gina as Carly. I would love to see the two of them up against each other