Everything posted by j swift
- GH: March 2024 Discussion Thread
-
Another World Discussion Thread
It is interesting how the foreshadowing of Blackhawk, and Quinn discussing her boss, was so similar to the introduction of Adam on AMC. Prior to Adam's arrival, people in Pine Valley were intrigued about this rich guy moving to town, and Ross was hyping up his arrival. And then it turned out that he was using an alias and had history with significant members of the community. But, Adam stuck (for a variety of reasons) and Steve was killed off.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
Agreed, in fact, I would go as far as saying it is an 'ideas vs. execution' issue. The concept was good, but the casting, and other issues beyond the control of the writing, were poor.
-
DAYS: March 2024 Discussion Thread
2.3/10 I hate today's wrinkle that Holly will hide the fact that she did drugs in order for Nicole to not feel guilty for being a bad mother. On Christmas Day, Holly was talking about Nicole being a bad mother because she missed her birthday. Johnny knows that she smoked pot. And Eric and Nicole took Holly for breakfast when they thought she had a hungover. So, the idea that Holly would now be motivated by guilt over Nicole to not exonerate Tate is silly. Maybe even more like Jason Bourne than Jason Quatermaine. The guy's been in a coma for weeks, now he can jump out of bed and pin Stefan against the wall?
-
DAYS: March 2024 Discussion Thread
While I can see it happening, given their contractual status, it would seem like a big course correction given how well Nicole and EJ have been getting along since their wedding. I would not like it if EJ became suddenly evil again like he did in the fall, in order to facilitate the pairing of Nicole and Eric. But, I think that's where we're heading with Tate's conviction.
-
GH: February 2024 Discussion Thread
My memory may be way off, BUT, the other thing that keeps annoying me about this dialogue is that IIRC Stone and Jagger interacted for a relatively short period of their time on screen. Jagger was around for a long time before they established his siblings, and I don't think of him having many significant scenes with Stone. I get that Jagger today would not recall Stone's connection with Sonny kindly, because of all the trouble that befell Stone. But, and correct me if I am wrong, they weren't that close to begin with.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
At the risk of once again being in the minority, I liked David Canary as a Steve re-cast. He was blustery like Reinholt, but there was also a vulnerability that made his appeal to Alice more relatable. I also thought the idea of Steve's re-entry was creative, because there was so much talk about his company Blackhawk before his arrival. But, the recast Alice, and the poor excuse for his return from the dead ultimately doomed the character. Along with the fact, that they may have underestimated the appeal of Rachel and Mac as an "endgame" couple.
-
DAYS: March 2024 Discussion Thread
I agree, I would guess that they needed some time to figure out how to tell the drug and baby switch story if Nicole was not going to be on canvas. As I read it, the issue was not about AZ thinking about coming back, but that the former producer wanted to fire her, so they required a plan B. Now, it is unimaginable that they would be able to tell those stories without recasting Nicole. But, unfortunately, I can see a future without Nicole once those stories end in six months. Because Holly could be raised by Maggie and EJ, while Nicole raises Jude off-screen.
-
GH: February 2024 Discussion Thread
While I'm not an immediate fan of the new actor playing Jagger, I also don't recall the original character or actor being that compelling. The pairing with Karen was intriguing, and the triangle with Brenda was a great teen/young adult story for the time, but Jagger was the weakest link within that plot. Also, I am giving GH some creativity points for choosing Jagger as a potential mate for Carly because of all the historical connections. And he was established as a law enforcer in his prior times on the canvas. Amusingly, whenever @vee references him as Wagger, I was reading it as 'wager' (like a bet) in my head and I didn't understand the nickname, but now I think it is fits.
-
Generations Discussion Thread
For me, what is so entertaining is that it feels as if the author was trying to write a campy ode to soap opera catfights. But the actors actually flipped the script and told the context of the scene and how difficult it was to film. So that we couldn't help but respect them for their efforts. I think it is a triumph any time that soaps that underestimated, and then someone notes why they deserve their place in culture.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
I agree, but I don't think that is a bad thing. We have to consider the context. The book is a memoir, not an attempt to write the history of the show. The humor is derived from his frustrations working for the first time within the daytime genre. And there is no way of knowing if he maintained these opinions years later.
-
Another World Discussion Thread
I hope we can put a moratorium on the semi-annual retrial of Virginia Dwyer's firing. The interpretation that any writer had enough power in a production to dismiss an actor on their own because they didn't like the way that they read their lines is simply too literal. I am not quoting anyone in particular, I am just voicing my frustration that we keep circling back to the same disagreement.
-
GH: Face the Music | promo (week of February 26, 2024)
It is always intriguing to me how much a production plays into the minority portion of the audience that is clued into soap news. For example, DAYS is promoting that Stefan might kill Burton’s character's this week. Which would be kismet if he is also going to debut on GH on Monday. But, I tend to believe it just a coincidence, since DAYS production didn't know six months ago that Burton was going to be re-hired at GH. It is a fun correlation, but logically there couldn't be a relationship between the two events.
-
GH: February 2024 Discussion Thread
To me, the recent focus on Spinelli, a character who has outgrown his charm, feels like putting the pieces in place for Jason's return. Everyone on the canvas is being reset to where they were when Jason was relevant. Sonny is single, Spinelli is on his own, Drew and Sam are arguing. It all feels very deliberate. But the regression of characters is rarely popular.
-
The Wendy Williams Thread
Not the “it could have been worse” defense… I would respect them if they suggested that it was newsworthy and that they sought the consent of her son. But, all of these explanations after the fact seem insincere. There is a long tradition of this type of show from Grey Gardens, to Michael Jackson's Martin Bashir interview, to Whitey Houston's interview with Wendy, to Britney's Instagram videos. Collectively, they raise the intriguing question: How should our culture address affluent mentally impaired adults who resist assistance? Should we gawk or avert our gaze? Do we have the right to look in Wendy's fridge because we were fans for 15 years? Or is it more respectful to ignore her decline? I think judgements of who is good or bad in Wendy's life is easy. But, for me, it is trickier to grapple with what is my personal responsibility in terms of media consumption? Is it noble to resist the urge to watch this provocative footage? Or is it just a fascinating story that I am drawn to for the same reasons that I am a fan of soaps?
-
Another World Discussion Thread
@Mona Kane Croft My wish would be Lenore Moore Curtin Delaney (perhaps recast with Judith McConnell, just for the Nik Coster reunion). Lenore returns as the ultimate society matron whom Donna Love is desperate to impress. Lenore is instantly accepted back and placed on the board at the hospital. The ladies of Bay City plead with her to rejoin the Country Club. And Carl cannot take his eyes off of her anytime he is out with Rachel. Then Wally falls hard for Vicky Hudson. She's a breath of fresh air. He's from DC, and she knows politics from her time with Grant. But, he's a human rights lawyer and good guy. Suddenly this is Donna's way into Lenore's orbit. If Vicky marries Wally, Donna can invite Lenore to the Love Mansion every year for Thanksgiving. But, Wally has a bit of his father's madness in him and is secretly jealous of Jake or any other man who once loved Vicky. Let's just hope he doesn't go scarf shopping anytime soon...
-
GH: February 2024 Discussion Thread
I concur. And there's clearly a difference between people talking about their reactions on a public forum, versus attacking or critiquing the actors directly on social media. In this case, we've seen this woman in the media for decades, and it is only natural to have a response to the extreme changes that have occurred over time. I would be mortified to be compared to images of myself twenty years ago, but I have not chosen a profession that commodifies my appearance.
-
The Wendy Williams Thread
Two head scratching responses: A: Yet, they filmed for months, so that doesn't absolve them of exploiting her story when she is at her worst. B: He needs to sit down and get a job
- GH: Face the Music | promo (week of February 26, 2024)
-
DAYS: February 2024 Discussion Thread
I guess if my cheating ex-husband followed me to a new town and started dating my new friend, and ingratiating himself with my new boyfriend, I'd be a bit freaked out. And, even though my ex-boss and my ex-police partner both have amnesia, I would probably question that as an excuse. But, I'd still probably be a bit more forthcoming with information about our past. Also filed under suspension of disbelief, if Steve could get BobEtte's birth certificate in seconds, why couldn't the Seattle police track down Jada as his next of kin when he was in the accident?
- GH: Face the Music | promo (week of February 26, 2024)
-
DAYS: February 2024 Discussion Thread
3.7/10 Rather than yelling at journalists and telling them confidential police information, why doesn't Jada tell BobEtt what she knows about his past? The highlight was Johnny's scene at Holly's bedside. The lowlight was EJ just finding out that Johnny got married. Why doesn't this family text each other? And is Chad still wearing Victor's clothes? Because that suit seemed awfully tight for Vic. Do you think Kiriakis had a skinny closet and a fat one for when his weight fluctuated?
- DAYS: February 2024 Discussion Thread
-
The Wendy Williams Thread
Unlike a 12-year-old, I don't derive my observations nor the validation of my opinions from the internet. But, I appreciate our respectful contretemps over this very compelling show.
-
The Wendy Williams Thread
Will is not a good caretaker, but that is not his job. However, he is the one who got Wendy into rehab, he takes away the liquor, communicates the conservator, and he yelled at the PR lady for taking her to LA. So, while he is easily overwhelmed, he's still doing more than her nieces and nephews to get her the help that she requires.