Carly's upset with Jack that he went to Lily for advice on them. Protesting, he lectures how he doesn't know what to do anymore. Carly later speaks with Lily, who tells her that she's becoming more like the judgmental Jack that she always loathed. Carly sighs that she can't even tell what she wants anymore. Lily suggests that the straw that broke the camel's back with Jack was him marrying Katie. Carly laughs it off. Back at work, Kim tells Carly of a job conference in Chicago and she jumps at the opportunity.

Still upset about Clark voicing his distaste towards Luke being gay, Luke confronts Emma. Emma assures Luke that Clark's opinion has no impression on the feeling she has for either of them. Later, Emma tells Clark that she needs him to be more open-minded. After a small fight, Clark storms out and heads to the Lakeview. It's there that he runs into Lisa. Just as Lucinda steps off the elevator, she spies Clark and Lisa talking. When Dusty approaches her, she suggests he do a little match-making with Clark and Lisa. She adds that if Clark is away from the Snyder's, he's away from Lily; and the further Lily is away from Clark, the further she is from learning the truth about Lucinda and Clark's connection.

Aaron shows up for work and shows Gwen around on her first day at Donovan's. Casey shows up for work and is surprised to see Gwen working there. After he spots Gwen talking with Aaron, Casey gets the idea that Aaron hired Gwen out of some ulterior motive. Aaron assures a confrontational Casey that Dusty hired her. Alison backs Aaron's story and Casey feels foolish, soon apologizing to them both. Later, Alison praises Aaron's efforts towards making things right with Casey.

At work, Katie keeps busy to avoid running into Brad on set. When Brad tries to make a big production out of Katie's pregnancy, Katie downplays it to her co-workers as his wishful thinking. Kim tells her of a conference out of town and Katie decides to go, but only if Brad stays home. Realizing he's going to come anyway, Katie lies to Brad and tells him that she's taking a trip out of town to see Cricket. Witnessing everything, Margo scolds Katie for lying again. Casey sees the whole thing and scolds his aunt for lying, recalling that lies are the exact same thing that made Simon and Mike leave her. Meanwhile, Brad speaks with a jeweler and picks out an engagement ring, intent on popping the question when Katie returns.

In Kansas, Rosanna's upset to learn that a woman named Kathy never worked at the market. She's confused and puzzled that the woman just vanished. Later, we see Kathy inform someone that she did what they asked, handing them the same check that Rosanna paid her with.