Jump to content

ATWT Thursday February 14


Recommended Posts

  • Members

Okay, sadly, it is time to let Nuke go.

Hidden or underplayed sexuality and passion...isn't that the definition of being in the closet? The once-brave, remarkable ATWT, featuring two young gay men, is now perpetuating the closet. Our young, healthy men don't kiss...and they barely touch. This perpetuates the worst stereotypes of some viewers ("if they'd just deny their unnatural urges, I could tolerate them").

I celebrate ATWT for starting this story, but I now conclude it is time for Nuke to leave Oakdale. More harm is being done with this sweep-it-under-the-rug portrayal than not having it all...because the story we are seeing is not honest. Let us say farewell to Nuke now, while we still care. ATWT gets prompts for going further than ever...and we'll hope that the NEXT story on the NEXT soap will be even more honest.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 16
  • Created
  • Last Reply
  • Members

Ask many longtime ATWT fans, and I bet they'll tell you there was a time when even heterosexual couples didn't display much affection. ATWT has always been more "clinical" and "psychological" than that, IMO.

Noah and Luke don't need to leave. Christopher Goutman and Jean Passanante (and P&G/Televest) need to do a better job convincing conservative middle Americans they are a couple like any other. They need to make us care more about their happiness, and invest in them and root for them like we'd do for anyone else.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.



  • Recent Posts

    • Has Sonny been a mobster since Guza? Yes, he has. Back then was he portrayed somehow as a good man, righteous? No, he was not.Now, fly through time. Sonny has been credited with taking care of Stone & then Robin. Before you could turn around twice & shout! Sonny donated enough money to build a wing of the hospital in honor of Stone. IMO Mulcahey was on the right track. Maybe that lead to this? We may thank him yet.
    • I totally agree and that's why I wish they had played up Mary's connection to Reginald because I think Alexander had more chemistry with Considine. They never explored her backstory and just thought Mary belonged back with her family. I think a better story would be if she rejected Vince and wanted to stay with Reginald. I know we've litigated Reginald's character, but I wish they had played it that way because it would have kept the Loves and the McKinnons connected beyond just Vicky and Jake. 
    • GENERAL HOSPITAL From @depboy'S Research   Pete         Robert Axelrod          August 1989 Marge            Opelene Bartley    August   1989 - 89      Cheryl Stansbury's maid Gary         Dean Abston      August 1989 Ben         Vince Bonato     September 1989 Peter           Loren Blackwell      September 1989 ____     DeSouza      Al Dunn     September 1989 Mrs. ___ ___   Dawson        Marilyn Alex  September - October 1989      Phoebe's Mother Mr. ____   Dawson      Buddy Farmer      September 1989 -  October 1989  Phoebe's Father Phoebe Dawson          Lycia Naff        September  - October  1989   Carnival worker that knew Decker.  Felicia thought she was Phoebe when she had amnesia. . ..[amnesia, Felicia...]Kristina Wagner 89 ______ Sanderson     Les Brown    February  - March 1989; September 1989 _____   Sargon      Tony Xauet     August - September 1989 ____ Griffin     Terry Shepard       September   1989 Marty    John Michalski      September 1989 Train Conductor    Leo Schreiber     September 1989   Stranger on the Road    Thomas Prosler    September 1989 Farmer     Stephen Breuthaupt      September 1989 Hobo      Steve Wells    September 1989 Fire Chief             George D. Wallace   March 1985;   September 1989 Hotel Manager       Ben Wilson    September 1989 Dutch             Brad Trumbull     September 1989 Secretary       Carol Robbins      September 1989 Private Investigator         Jack Mayhall    September  1989 Agent Randall Tucker     Jon Huffman       September 1989  Andrew Slezak      Michael Tulin      August 1991 Debbie      Sherrie Wills      July - August  1991    waitress for Mac hired by Taub to spy on him Eddie         Kevin McDermott       August 1991      hench, Taub Brian         Sean Doherty      August 1991 Sister Agatha   Fran Ryan      August 1989; December 1989  nun, Monica knew about her daughter Tanganeva            Thalamus Rasulala      September  - December 1989; June - July 1991 Fred      David Myers      October 1989 Bernie     Jack Forbes   October 1989 Lynx Henshaw           Elizabeth Savage      October - November 1989       David McAllister's partner-in-crime Kyle        Jan Munroe    October 1989  ___  Romero    Carlos Rivas         October 1989 Puerto Rico Hotel Clerk      Rene Fernandes     October  1989 Puerto Rico Hotel Manager       Spartacus  Santoni     October 1989 Dr. ___ __  Clark         Victoria Hearst       November - December   1989 Costume Shop Clerk      Bob Bancroft     November 1989 Mace     Len Donato   November 1989 Michael    Darryl Ferrera      November 1989 - February 1990     Mobster Funeral Director      Ron French       November 1989;  April 1993 Dr.  ____   Silva             William Marquez         November 1989 - ???/90 Loan Officer     Warner Laughlin      November 1989 Molly          Kathy Molter       August 1989 Nurse Esther_____ Gibson         Davey Davison     August 1990     Dr. Benson Perry's Nurse    Cop     Ken Zavayna    August 1989 Captain of the Sparrow        David Goss       August 1989 Television Commentator    Wayne Thomas     August  1989   A little poking around revealed... Moe       Colby Chester         1980 Spider         Steve Comisar       1979 Minister Roy Evans    James Dale Ryan      1980 Construction Worker   Frank Crim     3/28/2025 Delivery Man     Frank Crim   11/29/2022 Aaron Thomas    Chandler Springer  12/27/2024  wants a picture at the MetroCourt with Kai. Reporter    Francisco De Cun  4/16/2025     at Laura's Press Conference about the vote Liam Mike Corbin   Never Seen   child of Sasha and Brando    week of 12/6/21                        Parker Ervolina     7/6/22    Sasha's  imagination    
    • I just saw this old-ish quote from Jane Krakowski, mentioning the circus story as a worst (she said it was a ratings grab) along with the flood. She also mentioned that the reason her character was called TR is because they didn't come up with a name for her - it stood for "The Runaway." https://www.soapcentral.com/soapcentral/news/2017/0629-jane_krakowski_search_for_tomorrow.php What was TR's exit, anyway? She left before the show ended and then returned for the finale, right? Did she ever have love again after Ryder? This is John Mahoney around five minutes, right? I never knew he was on a soap.

      Please register in order to view this content

      I sometimes wondered why Evie was recast. I get why now. I've always had a soft spot for Colleen Dion, but she is very, very green here.
    • Mary Carney was the best of the Mary recasts. I think everyone I've seen talk about the show has said this, or almost everyone. The show just gave up too quickly. I agree the story was over. I don't think the show ever developed Mary's career enough to make viewers care about that aspect. I remember reading an interview with Ilene Kristen where she talked about how much support she got from viewers with Jill and Frank (I think it was from around then). I don't know if Roger/Delia was always the plan (wasn't he interested in Mary early on?) but I sometimes think they threw that together to try to make viewers feel Delia had no moral high ground. Frank was an interesting construct as a man who looked like the ideal politician yet behaved...like a typical politician. I think that's why he mostly took off once they cast Daniel Hugh Kelly, who fit the duality. 
    • Yes and no. If they had wanted to recast Phillip, then no, he didn't need to return. There were already too many recast Spauldings at this point. Regardless of how you feel about Dusay, Raines or Poser, I think the viewers had trouble connecting to them. I think the viewers loved Rick Hearst, and yes, if he had stayed, then you could've built around him. But with a lackluster Michael Dietz soon to appear, Grant Aleksander anchored the family. Reva--pfft. Yes, she could've stayed gone. I'm unsure what the early reception to Josh/Annie was, but I thought RN and CW had good chemistry. Reva had been gone a while at this point, the audience would've accepted anyone who was good to Josh's children. 
    • Phillip and Rick became BEST friends when they first SORASed the characters.  They had been at the same boarding school and came back together to finish high school. That's when they met Mindy and Beth. The four of them were together a lot and called themselved The Four Musketeers. Initially, Phillip/Mindy and Rick/Beth were paired up until Phillip fell in love with Beth. 
    • LaGuardia, R. (1974b). The wonderful world of TV soap operas. ISBN-13 ISBN-13 978-0345272836 It took Harding “Pete” Lemay, however, a skilled playwright who thoroughly believed in the heretofore unexplained psychological potential of the daytime serial, to transform Mrs. Nixon’s love-triangle subplot into a balanced story contrasting realistic human behavior and that “other world of fantasy and striving. He found story devices no longer necessary.” For example, Lemay said, “I didn’t feel it was necessary to keep Rachel a black-and-white character. I didn’t see her as a villainess… I saw her instead as a human being who had always had bad breaks and who defeats herself because she is so used to failure. When she lost Steve this last time, I wanted the audience to feel her pain as I felt it. I wanted them to feel her tears. Mr. Lemay, along with his producer, Paul Rauch, should be given an Award for the Greatest Contribution to Daytime Serials, for completely eliminating melodramatic cliche’s in a daytime drama, and for their invaluable demonstration that, what viewers really want is drama based on psychology rather than on escapist melodrama. Under Lemay and Rauch “Another World”, which had previously used many tried-and-true soap opera devices (although fewer than most other shows), got rid of them, employed inward writing, and became one of the top two or three daytime television shows. About the only happy event in “Another World” was the birth of Ada’s daughter, Nancy, named after Ada’s dear friend on her deathbed Nancy Wickwire.   Edit to add: Emphasis on "dear friend". Should be changed to "special friend".  
    • ITA. While I'm all for vets being featured, the show has boxed itself in by not adequately developing a younger set. It's like Kyle's realistic options are Claire and Audra with Summer gone. Chance is barely used. Noah and Faith are off-canvas now.  Abby's story has been run to the ground in all the wrong ways. There's a Newman/Abbott war going on and Abby is on the sidelines? Give me a break. Abby shouldn't be a hostess, but at either Jabot or NE and right in the middle of all this stuff. Abby and Adam should've formed an alliance as the not Nick/Victoria kids.
    • Absolutely. On any other show, Frank Ryan would have been a shining romantic hero. I think they made Delia so impossible so you would feel as though he had a right to cheat on her. But he was a deadbeat dad, neglectful of the women in his life, even neglectful of his family, ridiculously ambitious. Once in a while he'd show some integrity, and then he'd go back to being a self-centered jerk. But he was definitely an interesting character.  When Pat was married to Delia, it was two incredibly neurotic people caught together in a very toxic relationship. Again, fascinating to watch. Yeah, when those first contracts ran out, the people leaving caused a big issue. Almost like they did too good a job with the initial casting.  I actually liked the first recast for Mary. (I think her name was Mary Carney?) Part of the problem was after being so front-burner for 3 years, Mary and Jack's story was basically resolved and they had to fall back on the tired "marriage vs career" trope. Then they brought in the second and third recasts that were total misses. Plus, they were ramping up Siobhan's character. It seemed they were more interested in focusing on her once Mulgrew left. 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy