I‘ve always appreciated it.
Mattson was a powerhouse as Janet, and my sympathies were always with her.
I felt her pain.
But I’m also one who never thought the Kate Collins version was a complete cartoon, either.
She also, in more subtler ways, brought levels of humanity & compassion to the role.
There’s a scene I just watched from October 1991 - a brief line probably no one remembers - right after Janet is exposed and is in jail; she asks Livia if she can please help her to get her eye glasses back, because “they took them from me and I don’t see very well.”
It’s just said so pathetically, and I just wanted to reach into the screen and give Janet a hug (and this was soon after she shot a teenager and planned on shooting another one in the head).
Anyhow, Janet is truly an iconic soap character.