Everything posted by carolineg
- Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
- Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
I don't think the show is being written worse all of a sudden or anything. I don't see a noticeable dip in quality. It's been bad for years. I think it's the fact that a lot of popular characters are leaving makes it seems worse than it is. Most of the characters being focused on are either in boring stories or just unpopular in general. Despite Talia having eyebrow acting that only Drake Hogestyn admires, I thought the actress was charismatic and had some potential. It's a shame they let her go so quick.
- GH: Classic Thread
-
GH: Classic Thread
Re: AJ and the money-Damian had evidence that Alan killed Ray Conway and was holding it over Alan's head. AJ decides to hire a professional to steal the evidence from Damian and takes the money from the hotel account to pay the guy. Alan and Monica find out and give the money to AJ to bail him out, but don't tell Ned/Edward why AJ took it in the first place. It was more evidence that AJ was a screw up for them, but AJ was actually trying to do something helpful.
-
General Hospital: October 2023 Discussion Thread
There is a lot of complexity to early Sonny/Carly. The show spent a lot of time building both Sonny/Brenda and Sonny/Carly and I think both were very different pairings and relationships that made sense as part of the evolution of the characters. While I agree with the fact he loved these women (including Nina), I don't agree with the fact that he idolized these women. I think there are aspects of these women that he found particularly attractive (ie Brenda's beauty and charisma, Carly's loyalty, Lily's acceptance, Alexis's intelligence, etc), but I don't think Sonny truly respected any of them as an equal partner and they all take 2nd to his business. With Nina/Sonny I do think they get along well and love each other, but there isn't anything on the page or on screen that merit this huge event wedding. Most of their relationship has been either Sonny following Nina around at the MC or talking about Willow/Michael/Carly. I know it's a big deal for Nina, but why is Sonny acting like he hasn't written at least a dozen similar vows at this point? If the whole event wasn't treated like this was a brand-new experience for both of them, I would be okay with it. Because I do agree the production looks lovely.
-
General Hospital: October 2023 Discussion Thread
I disagree with this take on Sonny. The problem with Sonny and his women is not the fact he put them on a pedestal or was in love with the idea of them. I have made many posts over the years about the issues with Sonny and women and I am not going to hijack the thread talking about 30 years of toxic relationships, but Alexis was not the only woman who expected Sonny to be a partner. The only woman Sonny idolized and put on a pedestal was his mother. I am sure you can argue at times it felt like Lily, Brenda or Carly were put on a pedestal by him, but his actual behavior doesn't indicate that. And his relationship with Nina doesn't even have half the depth of any of those relationships. Anyhow, that's just my opinion on it.
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
What is Harris going to do at the Salem PD? Answer phones? lol. He can't solve cases or be an actual cop without going to an academy. Could you imagine the legality of him actually helping? I have actually always wondered what happened to all the criminals RoJohn arrested. Wouldn't they all have grounds to appeal their sentences since John wasn't actually a cop or Roman?
-
General Hospital: October 2023 Discussion Thread
You really expanded on what I was trying to say much better. I have no idea what makes Nina different to Sonny than any other woman he dated. They are very generic and I don't feel like I know anything about their actual relationship. They just seem like two people that get along well, not desperately in love. Even if the show delved into the comfort and stability of two people finding love that fits them better than the fiery, passionate affairs of their youth it would be more interesting. Painting Sonny/Nina as a love that they have never experienced before is just weird and the family co-signing this nonsense like they haven't watched their dad get married multiple times. I will never be a Nina or Nina/Sonny fan, but the show was on to something when they fell in love and Sonny thought he was Mike. Instead of exploring how being Mike really changed him this romance has fallen into usual Sonny patterns. I actually really can't wait for Sonny/Lois scenes, but I agree about there being so few people she knows still on canvas. Even people she spent less time with like Robin, Jax, Jason, etc are gone.
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
Lol at Marlena checking in with Kate about Phillip, but not her own daughter and her wrecked marriage. They really must have stacked some scenes with LK/DH at the Pub. Even though it's silly it's also kind of fun to anticipate when Marlena and Kate will pop up in an episode because you know they'll get a scene. Everything else was okay. They really are trying to make Harris happen. And good to know Ava STILL makes pasta. Her only defining characteristic is cooking Italian food.
-
General Hospital: October 2023 Discussion Thread
I know this Nina/Sonny wedding is going to blow up, but does Nina really want to get married in Puerto Rico? Does she know Sonny's actually brought every woman he's ever dated there? Honestly does Nina really know anything about Sonny's past at all? This is not really Nina/Sonny specific and probably belongs in the people married many times thread because every love story culminates in marriage on soaps. I watched the montage and sure, it's cute, but I honestly feel they only know like the Cliff Notes version about one another's life. I don't know, I guess I just hate Sonny spewing the same old crap to woman that will be out of his orbit shortly. I just don't find a Sonny wedding to be this groundbreaking event.
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
I think someone else said this, but I don't understand why Brady, John, Marlena, etc can't be involved in Belle/Shawn's story. Marlena appears for 2 min everyday! Instead of fangirling Harris/Ava it would have been nice for her to talk to Shawn or Belle instead. She found out about Talia/Shawn and nothing happened lol. I liked the Shawn/Belle/Phillp's scenes, but I don't understand why the show can't utilize the cast properly. Pretty much every relevant person in this story appeared today but didn't interact with one another the fullest. I understand there's always production issue, but why couldn't Belle spend a scene with Marlena/Brady before seeing Phillip and then go to Shawn? The oppurtunity was there to have everyone involved with this story today and it wasn't.
-
General Hospital: October 2023 Discussion Thread
Oh yeah. I felt it was pretty natural for them to start speaking like Lois, but not doing it in other aspects of their life. I don't watch GH til Hulu, but Lois made it seem like she was still physically living at her parents house to this day. Which cool, I guess. I just would have expected Lois to move on and remarry and have more kids years ago.
- Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
-
General Hospital: October 2023 Discussion Thread
@Liberty Cityis correct though. RS has taken it down a notch since the 90's with the accent. Olivia and Brooklyn also starting to dip into accents probably didn't help. Ha! I am from California and everything I know about Bensonhurst GH taught me. Are you telling me it's not all large, close knit Italian families, video arcades, a pizza parlors???😂
-
General Hospital: October 2023 Discussion Thread
I honestly think it's just jarring at first. I always tend to cringe at it when I hear it and then get over it. I'll have to watch some old clips to judge if it's less distinct. I think Rena does fine with it though. To be very clear it's a minor annoyance for me from an awesome character. 99% of my complaints are major annoyances from awful characters. Lois is still top tier amazing in my book.
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
Theresa, Andrew, Paul, Brady, Phillip, and Belle screw me up. Andrew should be older than Theresa and both should be older than Paul, Brady, Belle. Paul, Brady, Belle should all be close in age since they were all born within 3 years of each other on the show. John was busy! Technically, from their actual birthdates? No. Alex and Theresa should be near the same age. But when you take into account Phillip, Belle, Brady being significantly older than what they should be it makes that generation the most muddy to me to figure out. I would assume Theresa would be late 30's because she was played younger than Brady and Alex would be older than Sonny so 35, 36 ish. When you add in Abby being born in the same year as Brady and Stephanie being born before both it gets even weirder, but I am more confident with those two because they were aged after Belle/Brady/Shawn et all.
- General Hospital: October 2023 Discussion Thread
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
Ugh. SBu and TB I can tolerate, but that's sad about GR/Leo. I literally have no idea what Johnny does all day. He needs a job. The show could just tell us he works at Dimera like everyone else. I would group it like this-in my own head-with facts at hand 24-26 Johnny, Chanel, Allie, Wendy 28-30-Ciara, Tripp, Claire, Theo early to mid 30's-Will, Sonny, Alex, Chad, Stephanie, Gabi
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
Allie was over 21 when she got pregnant with Henry. I am going to assume Johnny/Allie are at least 25 now. Chanel was Allie's bff in London so I also assume they are the same age. Although with Chanel's backstory she should be almost 30 right now lol. Holly seemed younger to me than Tate so I thought 16 was a reasonable guess. You know I like SBu, but I have no investment because I am just waiting for the other shoe to drop and GH to re-hire him. Like we all know it's coming, so what's the point?
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
It's not as jarring as seeing Brady/Belle at John/Marlena's wedding and they come back from their honeymoon and Kirsten Storms is there, but it's definitely a bit more off putting than Tate who has been gone for years. The show would have been better off with Sydney because she's been off screen. She just obviously wouldn't have a crush on her own brother. Since I doubt they are going to make Johnny some weird predator that goes after teenage girls the Holly crush feels pretty irrelevant to me and they should have just aged a whole group so we don't have to watch a 16-year-old put the moves on a 28-year-old man.
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
Yup. Nicole could have had a line to EJ and then a line to Chloe about Holly becoming a teenager and how crazy it is, so it would have been established she has aged. I swear the last time Nicole talked about Holly she was mentioning teddy bears lol. It seems like the bare minimum to ask, but who knows? I think it's a silly mistake to age just Holly and Tate. Sydney and Parker should absolutely be a part of this too. What fun is a teen scene with just one boy and girl?
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
Exactly. I am not expecting Days to treat mental health in a realistic way. I do think there is a way to portray Susan in a more sensitive light though. She's always been a bit of a "joke", but the portrayal doesn't age well. Even when she debuted 25 years ago she was treated as someone who was unstable. Now she's just everyone's favorite eccentric lady in town. If the show insists on keeping Susan just dial everything back a little. It is strange Nicole didn't mention Holly at all before she appeared. Not even, "I think Holly has a crush on Johnny. She's growing up so fast" throwaway line. I almost wonder if it's intentional to make the viewer 'forget' these kids and that they are aging them by a decade.
-
Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread
I don't understand the writing for Susan ever. Sometimes she written as a psychic with special powers and a bit eccentric like when she was with Edmund, Harris and Ava. And sometimes she's written like today where she seems to be mentally stunted or developmentally slow. Is she someone we are to perceive as a functional adult or is she supposed to be mentally ill or neurodivergent? The show is intentionally vague with Susan and I never know what to think of her behavior. It's like everyone placates her like she's just a run of the mill weirdo, but some of her actual behavior suggests much deeper problems. The pacing of Holly/Tate was bad, but I feel like Days always does this with rapidly aged kids. Instead organically mentioning the child over a period of weeks they just show up one day as a teenager.
- Days of Our Lives: October 2023 Discussion Thread