While cleaning out the horse stalls, Erin tells Holden of what she overheard Grant saying the night before, but Holden just dismisses it as another lie. Later, Holden tells Emma of what occurred last night between himself and Lily and he seems optimistic. He asks when Emma plans on hosting Grant and Lisa's engagement party and Emma says that December 19th sounds good.

Susan and Andy meet up at Java an await John to come, after calling him in to ask him what's going on with him and Roxie. Elsewhere, Emily catches Roxie doing some Christmas shopping and sees a pharmacy bag, which Roxie quickly tucks away. John arrives and tells Andy and Susan that his sex life is none of their concern. After John leaves, Andy seems to have accepted John's excuse, but Susan admits that she's still skeptical.

Barbara arrives at work and finds a letter from Jennifer and a card from Paul. She's touched that her children are finally "coming around". She's taken back for a bit, though, when she spots a Christmas card from Will and Gwen. Gwen arrives, pleased to see that Barbara got their card. She soon picks up on Barbara's fesity move and leaves. Later, Barbara makes a statement that (as an old saying goes) once you marry a man, you marry his mother as well.

Everyone is shocked at what is going on before their very eyes. Henry plays along with Katie, but when she starts making out with him, he has to pull away. Mike storms off, as Margo chases after him. Henry exits and Craig enters to see his baby sister. Craig has a heart to heart with his little sister, and as he leaves, promises to keep in touch and see how Katie is doing. As he walks into the hospital parking garage, we see Craig walking right into the cross-hairs of someone's gun.