AMC:Would you ever accept another Brooke English?

[AMCGio83]

i HATE new Greenlee! Wow. First the Anti- Beall thing, now this. Sympatico:)

[R Sinclair]

And should I also mention we both joined SON within 24 hours of each other?

[David_Vickers]

NO, Julia Barr IS Brooke English. Brown & Essensteine should bring back Barr on contract and with mucho airtime. btw, AMC tried re-casting Brooke in the 80's when Julia Barr left before, a pitiful re-cast Harriet Hall played Brooke for a year, Brooke was nothing like she was. This brooke had a little longer than shoulder length blonde hair and Ms. Hall was a very poor actress. I remember this from back in my teen years.

[AMCGio83]

Obviously we're twins. Do you want to be Kitty/Kelly, Natalie/Janet, Cindy/Karen, Jeremy/Gilbert, Stuart/Adam, Tad/ted, Frankie/Maggie...hmmm maybe AMC's constant use of the twin gimmick should have it' own post lol.

[AMCGio83]

I don't think it's B&E who have any ay in bringing her back. JHC and Frons would need to and from what I read it doesn't seem that Julia Barr wants to ever come back.

[DevotedToAMC]

Absolutely not. Julia Barr is the only Brooke and to recast her would be an insult. Plus, they won't write for Brooke as long as Frons is there (shame on him. She is one of the most talented daytime actresses ever)

[David_Vickers]

They could bring up the idea of bringing her back, but yeah Julie Hannan Carruthers and Brian Frons would have the final say so. I've read that too that Julia doesn't want to ever come back, and I don't blame her after the way she was treated by Carruthers, Frons and McTavish.

[DevotedToAMC]

Yep she deserved a much better exit than what she got...I hope another soap snags her up and she shines there. Missed opportunity for AMC