Everything posted by Reverend Ruthledge
-
Guiding Light Discussion Thread
I don't remember that but I do remember the very strange B.B. Ramsey name. It was even stranger than you recall. Michelle was originally named "Berta Bauer Ramsey". Not even the correct name "Bertha" was used. I never understood that. The naming of that baby was just weird all the way around. I'm glad Claire changed the name to Michelle.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Knots Landing
I think that's what it is. The shows were more about the artist's vision than about ratings so they felt more pure. I used to think I didn't like Dynasty at all until I watched the first season (which I had missed the first go-round). I was shocked at how good it was and how much I liked it. I never understood why people thought it was boring until Joan Collins entered the show. In my opinion, she just made it campy. Not that I'm against camp. It has its place. However, I thought the first season was thought-provoking and that's what I tend to prefer. What came later was pretty mindless. Same, to a lesser extent with Dallas and Falcon Crest. I will say that Knots Landing never veered into camp as far as I know. I'm not very knowledgable on the latter seasons.
-
Knots Landing
I'm strange in that I go against popular opinion with most things. I thought the first season was the best for all the primetime soaps I watched (Dallas, Dynasty and Falcon Crest). Except for Knots Landing. The first season was good. I just felt like it got better as it went along whereas the other primetime soaps started to deteriorate in my opinion. If you liked the first season or two of Knots Landing, you're in for a treat as you keep watching.
-
Radio Soap Opera Discussion
Thank you, Paul.
-
As The World Turns Discussion Thread
Well, in ATWT's defense, the Pa Hughes funeral came when the show was an hour and Papa Bauer's funeral was when GL was only 30 minutes. So, ATWT had more time to fill. Actually, if ATWT would have been 30 minutes, it would have been the same amount of focus as Papa Bauer's funeral was actually only one scene as well. Now, after having defended ATWT, I still say that the lack of time dedicated to Pa Hughes during that episode was inexcusable. You are correct about Chris Hughes. I'm not sure about Jim Matthews. I think John Black on Days got two or three days dedicated to his funeral (if I'm not mistaken). I felt like it was overdone.
-
As The World Turns Discussion Thread
Yes, it was the Soderbergs. I'm usually a fan of their writing but I felt like they didn't do Pa Hughes justice with this episode. However, you are correct that, at least, he got a funeral unlike other patriarchs/matriarchs like Mary Matthews and Nancy Hughes. And I might add Bert Bauer. Among others. So I have to give kudos to the Soderbergs for that.
-
As The World Turns Discussion Thread
The episode was surprisingly very light on Pa Hughes and his memory even though it was his memorial episode. Chris and Nancy talked about him in one scene in the episode but his funeral was only one scene. The final scene. The other scenes were between Jay and Carol, Lisa and Grant, Tom and Dee. But not much talk about Pa Hughes. I was a bit surprised that Pa Hughes didn't warrant more of a send-off. Bob's eulogy was nice but that was about it.
-
As The World Turns Discussion Thread
I don't know for sure but I doubt that any of these people or the farm was mentioned again. John and Edith strangely didn't even get a mention at their own father's funeral. So they had both been long-forgotten by this point. You are absolutely right that Irna would have at least mentioned them since they were her creations. Apparently, even in the glory days of the 70s, writers tended to have little concern about characters they didn't create. This is probably why Donald and Penny only got a brief mention. This, of course, got way worse going forward in the soap world.
-
As The World Turns Discussion Thread
Bob said she wasn't physically able to make the trip to Oakdale for the funeral. She was at "the farm" with her family. So, I would assume the farm he mentioned was the farm Grandpa Hughes and Irna lived in together. And I would also assume that they had married. I guess Grandpa either died in Oakdale on a visit or his body was sent there just for the funeral. I don't know. I only have the funeral episode. If that happened, it would have been 1975. I'm not doubting it happened. That's just the one Christmas episode I don't have. It's definitely not 1974. He didn't surprise anyone with a visit that year and had some lines. And he died in 1976. So it had to be 1975.
-
As The World Turns Discussion Thread
Penny sent a cable but there was no excuse for her not being there given. I guess maybe because she was in England that it was too far for her or something. Donald, who was living in California at the time, tried to make it but was the victim of that old "plane grounded by fog" soap trope.
-
As The World Turns Discussion Thread
It was an "accident" only in that Ellen didn't mean to kill her, just stop her from telling Dan that Ellen was his biological mother (which Franny, the housekeeper, had just threatened to do). It was a spontaneous act on Ellen's part. Not premeditated murder. Which is why she was released from prison. Franny was leaving the room to go tell Dan and Ellen grabbed a small statue on the desk and bashed her over the head to stop her. Franny didn't have any children of her own. She considered Paul and Dan her own children. That was part of the problem. She was possessive of them and hated Ellen because she was their new mother after David married her (or was about to marry her. I can't remember the chronology).
-
DAYS: June 2025 Discussion Thread
Did I miss something? Why isn't Will at the funeral? And it's been great to see Deidre Hall acting again. I haven't seen that since the 80s.
- As The World Turns Discussion Thread
- As The World Turns Discussion Thread
- As The World Turns Discussion Thread
-
As The World Turns Discussion Thread
Julie Poll's 40th Anniversary Book states that he died of an embolism. I can't vouch for the accuracy of that either. As I've learned after collecting scripts is that no history book is 100% reliable. I have scripts from right after Neil died but I don't think I have any from the time of his death. Penny is talking about moving on after Neil's death but I don't think there is any specific mention of the way he died. I believe it happened off-screen. Neil and Penny had moved to New York and were off the show during that time. I THINK. So, the manner of his death could have just been a line somewhere.
- As The World Turns Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
-
Ratings from the 70's
That makes sense. Thanks.
-
Ratings from the 70's
Thank you, Jason. I always thought As the World Turns was the number one soap from 1958 to 1978. I guess that's not true.
-
Radio Soap Opera Discussion
If those came from that mass-produced CD that was put out a while back, I'm afraid those episodes are wildly out of order and are very confusing to listen to. I had to painstakingly put them in order to make sense of things. I need to make my own CD to give to people just to try and fix the problem. Thankfully, I had time during the lockdown to do that. Just a word of warning.
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread
- Guiding Light Discussion Thread