Everything posted by prefab1
-
All My Children Tribute Thread
I'm only 15 minutes in, but Kelly Ripa and Rebecca Budig have already shared so many juicy behind-the-scenes stories about AMC, including about the pay gap between male and female actors:
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
Worst cop ever? He's not even the worst cop in Friday's episode, not when you have Chase risking his entire career to help Willow's case. I do get what you mean though, but I have my suspicions that the odd writing for Nathan in this scene--he arrives out of nowhere and then just as conveniently gets "called away" right as Laura and Sonny are insisting they don't need his help to open the trunk and fix the flat tire--was very deliberate. If I'm right and Nathan actually is the unseen mastermind who hired Dalton and is working with Sidwell, then the show is actually being quite clever in setting up a big shocking reveal. Right now, they're lulling us into a false sense of security, plugging Nathan right back where he was on the mid-2010s canvas: the upstanding boy scout of a cop. And of course his storyline is moving very slowly, to the point that it seems like it's stalled. But again, I think that might be intentional, so that we get used to Nathan's presence in Port Charles and drop our suspicions until the big reveal pulls the rug out from under us.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
Yes, I can totally see Willow in this role. Although the show is understandably hesitant to deal with real-world controversial issues, I can also totally see Willow as the kind of mom who refuses to vaccinate her kids (even though she's a nurse and should know better). But I can totally see her as one of those "my baby's immune system is perfect the way it is" kind of mommy bloggers, which would cause all kinds of conflict with her colleagues at GH. (Cue scene of Lucas going off on her).
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
I just want to cosign all of that. Even though Genie did overact those Laura scenes, it still worked for me to heighten the sense of terror in the scenes. Same with Britt's reactions; KT normally isn't great at conveying genuine emotion, but she surprised me with her scenes on Thursday and Friday. And I also wondered if they were chem-testing Kristina and Jacinda. I wouldn't be against it, especially if they were setting up a triangle with Jacinda in the middle of Corinthos siblings Michael and Kristina. ETA: The Nathan appearance in the middle of Laura's scenes seemed very random to me at first, but I have a feeling that it will turn out to be significant. To me, it's just another clue that Nathan is Sidwell's mysterious collaborator on the cold fusion project/Five Poppies nonsense.
-
ALL: "Soapy" Podcast hosted by Rebecca Budig & Greg Rikaart
The Suzanne Rogers episode is now up, and it is amazing. Suzanne tells some great stories about her early career as a teenage Rockette and then as a Broadway performer, including a story about standing up to Katherine Hepburn, the star/producer of the musical Coco, who was trying to pay Suzanne less than she was worth. Rebecca and Greg have grown into pretty good interviewers, knowing when to stay out of the way as Suzanne recounts her colorful career history. Near the end, she also talks about her MG and her recent cancer treatments; she says that Linsey Godfrey, one of the very few actors on the show she told about her condition, even drove her to some of her chemo and radiation appointments, so clearly some of the mother/daughter bond we see onscreen comes from some place real.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
I thought Daniel Goddard did a great job in those scenes with Joss. He might be the rare villain this show got rid of too soon, because it feels like he had great potential as a character we'd love to hate.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
So what you're saying is that, in Trump's America, her record is almost too clean to be elected to public office.
-
GH: Classic Thread
I don't know how reliable the information is, but from what I've read, he joined GH in 1977, and Alan (who started airing in September 1977) was one of his creations. That should have been enough time to get the show in better shape by the January 1978 episode we saw, but then again, shifting from a 30 minute to a 60 minute format is a big transition, one that requires a lot of filler scenes like Monica having a long flashback to a scene that must have only played out a few weeks earlier.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
It's clear that Dante views Rocco as his one "real" son and doesn't have the same paternal affection for Gio, who he distrusts. Which is perfectly realistic, since he raised Rocco and only knew Gio vaguely as the neighbor's kid. But in the world of soaps, where a few months after a paternity reveal, we expect a long-lost biological child to be fully accepted as family, it comes off as shockingly harsh. But I think Dante is a self-righteous prick most of the time, so at least it's in character.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
I rarely identify with Brook Lynn, but I loved the little head shake and look she gave Dante at the end of that scene.
-
GH: Classic Thread
That probably explains why Alan is talking about his (so-far unseen) family so much in those scenes with Monica. Marland was probably already planning to bring on the Quartermaines to expand the canvas, as the 60 minute format would require. Also, what a delight it is to see Alan and Monica so early in their relationship, where we can already witness some of the dynamics that would play out between them over the next 30 years. And although their scenes were nothing special in this episode, Genie Francis and Anna Stuart both look lovely.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
Two questions about today's episode: 1. Is this Rocco storyline the first time Genie Francis has gotten scenes with Daniel Goddard, who played her son on Y&R? They both did a great job with their confrontation scene today, and I wondered if Laura slapping Dalton was improvised, something Genie was comfortable doing because she'd worked closely with Daniel before. 2. Can someone remind me how Ric has intel on Portia? Is this something he found out from talking to Liz?
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
I think the show struggles a bit when it comes to giving any of its characters psychological depth or believable motivations. But it's particularly pronounced when it comes to the black characters, who seem to have no pasts at all beyond a few references to the relationship dramas we've seen play out onscreen. I mean, Isaiah has been on the show for a year now, and we know literally nothing about his backstory (or even why he's so into Portia). Sawandi Wilson is a good enough actor to mostly make this work, but the character is still almost a blank slate. When it comes to Portia, it would be pretty easy to give her some dialogue with Isaiah where she reflects on her past and explains how she became such a compulsive liar. It would probably have something to do with her perfectionism and the extra burden of having to be a standard bearer for black excellence in otherwise white-dominated communities like GH. It would make perfect sense why she's so guarded and feels like no one can know the real Portia. But I think there's almost no chance these writers will do the work and give her that degree of psychological realism.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
Thank you! That explains so much. And I agree that Tabyana gave those scenes with Jordan her all and showed some fire. I'm just struck by the difference in how they write Trina and her (former?) BFF Joss. While Joss has this whole storyline involving international espionage and an older lover, Trina is stuck in scenes where Ava has to explain the concept of divorce to her like she's a special needs child.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
Could someone tell me why the show writes Trina like a 14 year old rather than a 21 year old? She came off as absolutely ridiculous in her scenes with Ava and then with Jordan today.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
Frankly, ALL of Laura's scenes this week make me want Cosgrove's slimy character to win the election, including the scenes where she decides to skip the well-publicized mayoral debate to be with Rocco and the many scenes where she enumerates things that matter more to her than her job.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
I realize they're using the Rocco court scenes to move some plot pieces in action (and probably kill off poor underused Daniel Goddard's Prof. Dalton character). But it's still so silly that they probably could have avoided the whole trial if Britt--who they've already established as being very concerned for Rocco's well-being--had just lied to the cops and claimed she gave him the keyfob and asked him to look for papers in the lab she shares with Dalton.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
I've gotta give the show some credit for briefly giving us some actual medical drama in the scene with Britt and Portia. And it was perfectly in character too, with Britt acting in a wildly unprofessional manner in the service of a greater goal (acting fact to save a patient) and Portia being professional to a fault, following hospital protocol even when her inaction could cost Ned his life.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
Agreed. They seemed to be competing to see who could pitch his voice lower and speak in a monotone to sound more manly. All I could think when I was watching those scenes is that there's no way you should have Dante AND Nathan AND Chase on the same show; they're serving such similar functions, you need to get of at least one of them.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
I know it's a sweeps period for GH, so there's a non-trivial chance that Jacinda the Hooker will end up brutally murdered by the end of the month. But if they do decide to keep her around and put her in a love story with Michael, they really need to recast the part with a stronger actress. Paige Herschell might be great in a different role, but she doesn't have a lot of chemistry with Rory Gibson, and she's not selling some of Jacinda's sassier lines.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
To me, it felt like they wrote the story according to Slezak's availability. It was paced so differently than the rest of the show, with major developments in the story happening practically every day, that I can only assume Frank gave the writers an order to front-burner it because he could only convince Slezak to be on set for less than a month.
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
I thought it was a great scene, because they each had a point. Jordan is absolutely right to call Portia out on being a compulsive liar. But Portia is right to mention Curtis's "impossible standards" because Curtis is a condescending prick who is just looking for opportunities to tell the women in his life, "I'm so disappointed in you."
-
GH: November 2025 Discussion Thread
Yeah, the Tracy/Qs scenes today didn't quite work for me either. Which, to my great shock, meant that my favorite scenes today involved the Portia/Jordan confrontation. A year ago, when I got back into the habit of watching GH, both characters bored me to tears. I thought they were symptomatic of how white soap opera writers and producers either weren't interested or weren't capable of writing black characters who had distinctive personalities and compelling flaws. But now, Portia and Jordan are each getting to show their messy and petty sides, and the actresses seem to be having a blast.
-
GH: October 2025 Discussion Thread
Really good episode today. Great to see Ned and Tracy plotting, just like old times. And I love how they're bringing out more of Michael's Quartermaine ruthlessness. Although I have no use for Jacinda, those scenes with Michael, Nina, and Ava were great. Rory has been playing the brooding "dark Michael" well, but it's nice to see this different side of him and the smug smile on his face as he spars with Nina.
-
GH: October 2025 Discussion Thread
The thing about Carly is that I don't think she needs her own storyline. For most of 2025, she's really been more of a supporting player in other people's storylines (especially the Michael/Willow/Drew affair), and I think that's played to Laura Wright's strengths. It hasn't felt like Carly is eating the show, as it has in some previous years, even though she's still on at least 3 days a week. Because Carly is already this nosy, rude, chaos agent, it feels organic when she butts into other people's storylines and creates conflict.