500 worst Rolling Stone album reviews of all time

Start new topic

September 20, 201411 yr

Member

Interesting mostly to get a glimpse at some of the terrible reviews they have had over the years (including calling Queen "fascists").

http://rateyourmusic.com/list/schmidtt/rolling_stones_500_worst_reviews_of_all_time__work_in_progress_/1/

Edited September 20, 201411 yr by DRW50

Quote

Replies 1
Views 1k
Created 11 yr11 yr
Last Reply 11 yr11 yr

September 20, 201411 yr

Member

One thing I know they've been criticized for over the years is their opinion of Led Zeppelin. Back in their heyday, RS used to, from what I understand, routinely give them crap, but then several years later they named as the greatest rock band of all time. Granted, there's the issue of different people being there, but still, that's one thing I've heard a lot.

Quote

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

No registered users viewing this page.

Talkin' 'Bout TV Movies

I get casting Deidre Hall since she was the closest NBCD had to a superstar by that point, but CZP and (RIP) Charleson were stretches for me. Were Susan Lucci and Melody Thomas Scott unavailable or something, lol?

By Khan · 1 minute ago1 min
Looking back...Primetime Ratings from the 80's

Not that there wouldn't have been opportunities! For instance, they could've hired George Takei (there's your ST person) as one of Chao-Li's relatives, who was also after the Nazi treasure. Or they could've hired Anthony Daniels and Kenny Baker (a.k.a. C3PO and R2D2) as another team out for the gold (and comic relief for the storyline). Heck, they could've even hired none other "Blofeld" himself, Donald Pleasance, as a sworn enemy of Gustav and his father's, who will stop at nothing, including romancing poor Emma, to keep Riebmann from reclaiming the treasure.

By Khan · 5 minutes ago5 min
Knots Landing

I agree. Especially because it happened so damn quickly, with absolutely no breathing room for him, for Cathy, for all of us.
David Jacobs insisted that was the plan all along, but I doubt it. I think they had every intention of keeping Joshua around for years to come, but Michael Filerman and his ego ruined everything.
I'd still love for someone who was there to explain to us what the original intention was for Empire Valley; was it ALWAYS meant to be revealed as an underground spy network? Because, even if that wasn't how it started, it still feels as if they were leading up to something big. Otherwise, why invest so much time in another real estate development scheme? We'd already been there and done that with Lotus Point.

By Khan · 18 minutes ago18 min
DAYS: December 2025 Discussion Thread

I feel like Days was always going to run into this problem regardless of writing. Days has done a horrible job establishing the next generation of leads. It has relied on Marlena, John, Bo, Hope, Kayla, Steve, etc., etc. for far too long. We end up at this point where most of the characters that get significant airtime are boring.
It seems to me the writing team is just too afraid to entirely revamp the show and are doing the bare minimum and coasting along with mediocre material. Because at least it's not as bad and offensive as Ron, right? Let's not rock the boat too much.

By carolineg · 30 minutes ago30 min
BTG: December 2025 Discussion Thread

OMG I agree! I can't put my finger on it but there's something morbid about it. Same thing for gambling.
Big agree.
Honestly it's been campy from the get-go. If one enjoys it, they should make peace with the fact it's pure camp.
Kat's hat was giving Lindsey McKeon's Marah (GL) vibes when SATC's stylist Patricia Field joined the show.

Madison is such an underdeveloped character - she can be a genius doctor and then a teenager - and the whole relationship with Chelsea is treated as an afterthought. This show has too many characters and too few (talented) writers.
Extra comments:
Greg Vaughn is a pro and a stud, however I don't see where the story is with him and Nicole. There's no stakes, no tension. Mark my words: they will tease a big secret with Kial in the next few months, that's all they can do story-wise.
Speaking of love stories: how grand can these love stories be if the most exciting thing these couples can do is bounce between cafes and book a hotel room? If I see that hotel room one more time, I'll scream. They have a huge problem with sets.
I have liked Vanessa so far but I don't understand what they want to do with her.
While WF was a bust, I'm enjoying the new writing and I'm loving the direction lately. They're experimenting a lot - and succeeding.
Loving Leslie & Marcel.
I literally have no idea what's next for Ashley and Derek. Not that I'm worried at all, but they've been written into a corner. They were isolated before, they're even more isolated now.
I don't see any chemistry between Shanice & Ted. In fact, I don't see any chemistry between Keith's Ted and ANYONE.

By Aback · 1 hour ago1 hr
DAYS: Behind the Scenes, Articles/Photos

I didn't remember her still being in Salem as late as 1979. But I agree, I thought she was absolutely gorgeous.

By teplin · 1 hour ago1 hr
DAYS: Behind the Scenes, Articles/Photos

If you can ever visit the Paley Center for TV in NYC, they have a number of 1976 Days eps available in the viewing library, including Amanda during her cancer story

By yrfan1983 · 1 hour ago1 hr
DAYS: Behind the Scenes, Articles/Photos

Yeah.
Amanda got pregnant, and (I think) she wasn’t sure if Chris or Greg was the father. But the pregnancy turned out to be ectopic and she had to terminate it. And it sounds like, after that, she decided to just make a go of her marriage to Greg and left Salem with him.
Which was too bad because from what I’ve read, Greg sounds like a real douche 😂😂😂
I wish more of this time period was available to see

By AbcNbc247 · 2 hours ago2 hr
DAYS: December 2025 Discussion Thread

Excellent posts @cody_1990 !
There have been a lot of boring couples lately. And a little too much Dimera. I think that all the ingredients are there for a good show, but Paula/Jeanne just need to use them more effectively. And yeah, a few characters do need to be sent packing lol
I’m surprised that they haven’t actually gone over budget, with the amount of characters we’ve seen on screen lately lol
Not yet. This isn’t Ron Carlivati’s show anymore 😂😂😂😂
As for techniques, maybe playing a character as smug or arrogant was one of them.

By AbcNbc247 · 2 hours ago2 hr
DAYS: December 2025 Discussion Thread

Have we seen Theo's abs? Otherwise, I'm not sure what acting "technique" they're talking about here... drink less water if shirtless scenes?

By te. · 3 hours ago3 hr

Sign In

500 worst Rolling Stone album reviews of all time

Featured Replies

Archived

Recently Browsing 0

Recent Posts

Talkin' 'Bout TV Movies

Looking back...Primetime Ratings from the 80's

Knots Landing

DAYS: December 2025 Discussion Thread

BTG: December 2025 Discussion Thread

DAYS: Behind the Scenes, Articles/Photos

DAYS: Behind the Scenes, Articles/Photos

DAYS: Behind the Scenes, Articles/Photos

DAYS: December 2025 Discussion Thread

DAYS: December 2025 Discussion Thread

Important Information

Account

Navigation

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)

Chrome (Desktop)

Safari (iOS 16.4+)

Safari (macOS)

Edge (Android)

Edge (Desktop)

Firefox (Android)

Firefox (Desktop)