Andrea Hall-Gengler for KRISTEN!!

NO!

Despite her resemblace towards ED, Tracey in a triangle with Dee and Drake would be an utter joke. I mean, can you actually picture a woman Tracey's age going after Drake, LoL?

Yeah, but we're all saying Watros and Cynthia's nearly a decade younger than Eileen.

NO!

YES! FUC* YES!!

Why are you opposed to that?!?!?!

Yeah, but we're all saying Watros and Cynthia's nearly a decade younger than Eileen.

Good point. But at least with Watros, we KNOW she could pull off Kristen.

What about Tracy Lindsey Melchior? I've always thought she looked a lot like Eileen.

She looks a very young Eileen... too young for the role.

Why are you opposed to that?!?!?!

Because it would be an f-ing disaster!

Because it would be an f-ing disaster!

Support your claim.

I shouldn't even have to dignify this, but, since you ask...

1) Kristen is sexy. No offense toward AHG at all, but she's not. Kristen is NOT frumpy.

2) AHG has already played TWO characters on DAYS.

And those are just off the top of my head. I'm sure I could think of plenty more given the time.

Edited April 23, 200718 yr by Mason

Even if they went an idiotic route of "Kristen gets plastic surgery to look like Marlena" route, I wouldn't want Andrea Gengler in the role. I mean, c'mon. Looking like Marlena isn't the only thing required to winning the role, you're still playing Kristen. And in my personal opinion, Andrea Hall couldn't do it. She just doesn't have the sex appeal, or the look... or anything. She's so far from Kristen, it's not even funny. I want Kristen back in all her glory -- not with some frumpy, uglier, older version of Deidre with an odd speech impediment.

Not to mention, people would be so confused. They'd be confusing Kristen for Hattie and Hattie for Kristen... it would be a huge mistake.

Edited April 23, 200718 yr by Kenny

Even if they went an idiotic route of "Kristen gets plastic surgery to look like Marlena" route, I wouldn't want Andrea Gengler in the role. I mean, c'mon. Looking like Marlena isn't the only thing required to winning the role, you're still playing Kristen. And in my personal opinion, Andrea Hall couldn't do it. She just doesn't have the sex appeal, or the look... or anything. She's so far from Kristen, it's not even funny.

Not to mention, people would be so confused. They'd be confusing Kristen for Hattie and Hattie for Kristen... it would be a huge mistake.

The last time people saw Hattie, she looked like Deidre. There would be no confusion.

Why would Kristen be "sexy" after being in a dungeon for a decade? (Longer if you factor in EJ's rapid aging..she's been in the dungeon for 25+ years).

So that rationale doesn't work.

Kenny, if you hate Andrea Hall, then you'd have to admit Deidre would be the better Kristen recast. I'd loooove to see Deidre give Kristen a try!!

The last time people saw Hattie, she looked like Deidre. There would be no confusion.

Why would Kristen be "sexy" after being in a dungeon for a decade? (Longer if you factor in EJ's rapid aging..she's been in the dungeon for 25+ years).

So that rationale doesn't work.

YOU... using rationale? You for real? LoL

For all we know, Kristen broke out of that damn dungeon, killed Susan and has been raising EJ for all these years.

Who said she's been in a dungeon all this time? Do you know something we don't?

Who said she's been in a dungeon all this time? Do you know something we don't?

If that were the case, Tony wouldn't have come up with the Salem Stalker scheme to avenge Kristen's supposed suicide.

If Kristen escaped the dungeon, the first thing she would have done was go straight to Salem and kidnap John and kill Marlena. And then she'd fly to England and take Elvis.