Alison stands in shock and confusion as Casey scorns her for being so evil and hiding the fact that Gabe had been sending him mail reporting on his and Sofie's sex life. Alison denies she did anything of the sort and points the finger at Margo, recalling that she obtained the box from his house. Casey is still furious and asks Alison why she would keep this from him. Just then, Aaron comes in the door and announces he's home. Alison stays quiet in front of Casey, but as soon as he leaves, she goes off on him, accusing him of trying to come in between her and Casey. Aaron's miffed that she's talking like she and Casey are such great friends when they've only gotten close over the past month or so. Aaron lies and says that he found the box, went to take a quick shower, left the box on the table, and that's where Casey found it while Aaron was showering. Alison doesn't buy it and grunts that she's staying with her mother until Aaron realizes what a jerk he really is. Meanwhile, Casey confronts Margo, revealing that he knows Gabe has been sending him letters and photos of himself with Sofie. Margo tries to defend her actions, but Casey yells that by not telling him, she played with his heart. While he runs upstairs to his room, Tom comes in and wants to know what's going on. Margo frets that Casey probably will not ever speak to her again after what she's done.

With both Jack and Carly staring down his neck, Parker lies, trying to convince Carly those clothes got greasy last week when he helped Jack out at the farm. Jack shoots that down; they worked on Emma's tractor over a month ago. Carly tells her son not to bother lying again, they already know he tampered with his father's car, what they want to know is why. Parker refuses and gets grounded until further notice. As they make their way back into the living room, Carly tells Jack it's obvious Parker wanted him to spend time at the house. This is exactly what she didn't want happening. She didn't want to make the kids anxious over their relationship or give them false hope. Jack suggests sitting down and talking with them, but admits he's confused too. One minute, Carly seems to be enjoying herself and the next, she's telling him to get out. Jack suggests they give each other a few days to think things over. "I'll call you," he hesitates before opening the door, only to meet a blank, yet grueling stare from Carly.

Rushing into Memorial, Will staggers through the halls, asking nurses where Hallie Munson is. Just then, Iris appears and hisses that he should really keep it down. They are in a hopsital, she reminds him. Gwen comes out and automatically disapproves of Will's haggard appearance. "What the hell happened to you," she asks. Will fumbles for an explanation, but is cut short by the doctor's emergence from Hallie's room. He tells them that the nurses are taking very good care of her and suggests they get some rest in the waiting lounge until they know more. Will invites Gwen to come with him to get some coffee, but Gwen reminds Will that the only reason she called him over here is because he is Hallie's father. She doesn't want him getting any ideas of a reunion. Will apologizes and asks Gwen if she'll ever forgive him for trying to come in between her and Iris. After all, he only wanted what was best for her; he didn't want Iris screwing her over again. "Nope," Gwen interrupts. "You pretty much did all the screwing up by yourself." Will watches as she walks back to Hallie's room.

Somewhere in Canada, Paul hollers out for his mother to not sign anything. James grabs up the papers and tries to flee in the commotion, but Paul stops him from going out the door and tells Barbara that he didn't want her to sign a marriage certificate. He wanted her to sign away her fortune, along with hers and Paul's powers of attorney. Barbara is repulsed. With that, James smirks and demands Paul let him go or he'll never see Cabot again. Rosanna comes in and orders Paul to let him go, they can lead him to Cabot. Paul yells back at her that James is only bluffing. He doesn't know where Cabot is either. After Paul explains that James took him hostage just to cut a deal and find out Cabot's wereabouts, Rosanna starts to tear up. Furious, she runs out and decides to continue the search all on her own. Back in the bistro, Paul eventually lets James go and snatches the papers that Barbara just signed, ripping them in a rage. James angrily bellows that they all just messed with the wrong person and makes a snide comment about Paul being just like his cowardice mother before storming out.