Do you think this is fair?

[MTSRocks]

Link

Student faces Facebook consequences

October 2007: Valdosta State University student Hayden Barnes is expelled for an online parody the Georgia school's officials found threatening.

January 2006: A gay student at John Brown University, a private, Christian college in Arkansas, is kicked out of school because he posted pictures on Facebook in which he was dressed in drag.

September 2005: Sophomore and Student Government Association president Cameron Walker is expelled from Fisher College in Boston for posting his critique of a campus police officer on Facebook. The action marks the first time a college has expelled a student for a posting on the website.

May 2005: Two Louisiana State University swimmers are kicked off the team after administrators discover they belonged to a Facebook group that targeted and bashed team coaches.

- SOURCES: Star files

Freshman hit with 147 academic charges for online study network at Ryerson University

Mar 06, 2008 04:30 AM

Louise Brown

Education Reporter

Study groups may be a virtual trademark of the Ivory Tower – but a virtual study group has been slammed as cheating by Ryerson University.

First-year student Chris Avenir is fighting charges of academic misconduct for helping run an online chemistry study group via Facebook last term, where 146 classmates swapped tips on homework questions that counted for 10 per cent of their mark.

The computer engineering student has been charged with one count of academic misconduct for helping run the group – called Dungeons/Mastering Chemistry Solutions after the popular Ryerson basement study room engineering students dub The Dungeon – and another 146 counts, one for each classmate who used the site.

Avenir, 18, faces an expulsion hearing Tuesday before the engineering faculty appeals committee. If he loses that appeal, he can take his case to the university's senate.

The incident has sent shock waves through student ranks, says Kim Neale, 26, the student union's advocacy co-ordinator, who will represent Avenir at the hearing.

"All these students are scared s---less now about using Facebook to talk about schoolwork, when actually it's no different than any study group working together on homework in a library," said Neale.

"That's the worst part; it's creating this culture of fear, where if I post a question about physics homework on my friend's wall (a Facebook bulletin board) and ask if anyone has any ideas how to approach this – and my prof sees this, am I cheating?" said Neale, who has used Facebook study groups herself.

Ryerson officials have declined to comment while the case continues.

Ryerson's academic misconduct policy, which is being updated, defines it as "any deliberate activity to gain academic advantage, including actions that have a negative effect on the integrity of the learning environment."

Yet students argue Facebook groups are simply the new study hall for the wired generation.

Avenir said he joined the Facebook group last fall to get help with some of the questions the professor would give students to do online. As the network grew, he took over as its administrator, which is why he believes he alone has been charged.

"So we each would be given chemistry questions and if we were having trouble, we'd post the question and say: `Does anyone get how to do this one? I didn't get it right and I don't know what I'm doing wrong.' Exactly what we would say to each other if we were sitting in the Dungeon," said Avenir yesterday.

He is still attending classes pending his hearing but admits the stress of the accusations is affecting his midterm exam results.

"But if this kind of help is cheating, then so is tutoring and all the mentoring programs the university runs and the discussions we do in tutorials," he said.

Neale said the Facebook account appears to have been pulled offline yesterday, although Avenir said it has not been in use since the course ended in December.

He had earned a B in the class, but after the professor discovered the Facebook group over the holidays, the mark was changed to an F. The professor reported the incident to the school's student conduct officer and recommended expulsion.

Neale said Avenir missed two meetings to discuss the matter because of a miscommunication. Tuesday's hearing was arranged to give him a chance make his case against explusion. Ryerson is not obliged to do so.

While Neale admits the professor stipulated the online homework questions were to be done independently, she said it has long been a tradition for students to brainstorm homework in groups, particularly in heavy programs such as law, engineering and medicine.

Each student in the course received slightly different questions to prevent cheating, she said, and she did not see evidence of students doing complete solutions for each other. Instead, she said, they would brainstorm about techniques.

"They'd say to each other stuff like ... `Remember what to do when you have positive cations (a type of positively charged ion)' and that sort of thing," she said.

But Neale admitted the invitation to the Facebook group may have been what landed them in trouble. It read: "If you request to join, please use the forms to discuss/post solutions to the chemistry assignments. Please input your solutions if they are not already posted."

Still, said Neale, "no one did post a full final solution. It was more the back and forth that you get in any study group."

[DevotedToAMC]

Good lord I think these school officials need to lighten up. I highly doubt what they found threatening is actually threatening to the majority of people. Critiquing a campus police officer? Sh1t I can write a freaking novel about how I was violated by a campus police officer on there (this eventually lead to me being diagnosed with PTSD). The police officer ended up leaving the school so hey I did something right. These are not the top of the line police officers here.

Way too out of bounds...I have Facebook but do not get into this kind of stuff but also am not objecting to it since I find pretty much no harm in what these students did (got too much time on there to think of this since I got over 600 friends to keep in contact with as much as possible)