Yeah. All 3 were going nuts for Y&R.

I know people dont like her but one thing Im going to miss about Soaptalk is her segments bc they were always the most fun to watch.

Yes she gushed about Y&R but thats bc the show is amazing! She has no reason to complain

Remember these are just her opinions. I thought she was right in everything she said. I disagreed with GH's Sonny/Jason and OLTL's Clint/Dorian but she gave valid reasons for why she thoguht they were hits

Dixie's Return - MISS!

This surprised me, I figured she'd be all over that.

I knew she hated Jon and Lily, thank god and has been vocal in her criticism of AMC in general a lot lately.

Obviously, she doesn't watch ATWT regularly; otherwise, she wouldn't have chosen two storylines that happened months ago. I'm not surprised: I used to read her column in SOD every week for two years, and she barely mentions it.

The same is true w/ B&B. The only thing she mentions about it is Jackie's arrest? Umm...a lot of other good things (Felicia's "death) and bad things (Nick/Brooke/Ridge the sequel) have happened too.

Like King Reilly said, it looked like they were asking her about Sweeps storylines. You also have to remember that the show is taped in advanced, so she was being asked about stuff then, not necesarily right now

Bo and Hope's break up is the biggest HIT DAYS has seen in a long time!

She mentioned that he initial stuff was good but it was a big miss for the island stuff. Patrick having satelite television in his speed boat, Bo and Hope breaking up over emails without talking to each other and no one suspecting Chelsea being involved. IA that stuff was dumb

This surprised me, I figured she'd be all over that.

She said it didn't make sense and was just stupid why she wouldn't contact her investigator husband/father of her baby to find her baby before this. Or something. I don't know? She said the timing and the story just didn't make sense and we all know why - cuz Cady was on ATWT.

The day I care about Carolyn Fatsey's opinions are the day I need to be committed

True. I don't care either, but I thought I'd post anyway.

From what I have seen of Dixie's return on AMC it is a miss. I mean having Cady back on AMC is a hit but the way the story is written was a big miss. The old Dixie would not have waited about seeing Tad esp for the reasons indicated by MMT. She would have told Tad about the baby and they would have found her - when Dixie came to her senses and all. She would not have stayed away knowing that JR was in trouble either. It has been just one big mess, and has hurt the Dixie character alot.

I disagree with her about Emily's breakdown just for the fact of Kelly's remarkable performance. Some parts of it were a miss, but not all of it.

I'm glad she said Hope & Bo's breakup was a hit before the Island. That I agree with her except I do think her and Patrick were hot together in part of the Island story.

From what I have seen of Dixie's return on AMC it is a miss. I mean having Cady back on AMC is a hit but the way the story is written was a big miss. The old Dixie would not have waited about seeing Tad esp for the reasons indicated by MMT. She would have told Tad about the baby and they would have found her - when Dixie came to her senses and all. She would not have stayed away knowing that JR was in trouble either. It has been just one big mess, and has hurt the Dixie character alot.

Dixie was a selfish !@#$%^&*] before she left town. When it comes to the character, people are upset bc MMT isnt writing the good saint Dixie that we all knew and loved all those years, but she's following the destruction to her character that was done in 2001-2002. Looking back at that Dixie, Im not surprised by her actions bc she was so out of character then.

thought I'd post anyway

I'm glad you did, thanks!

Soap mag columinists/writers are a polarizing lot in general. I'm all okay with Hinsey now because she's dissed Frons Sweeps Stunts=Emmy Gold strategy on national TV, even if but a wee bit and is all over McT and AMC right now. But Hinsey was persona not grata when she supported the rape storyline and others I found objectionable. It's really irritating when Hinsey or Torchin or any of them don't agree with you.

I'm sorry, but the "Passions" mermaid WAS a miss. Now it's great. And the actress is an excellent performer with a very real screen presence. Just LOBSTER LOVE her towering '!@#$%^&*]' pose. And the mermaid element is SO 2000 "Passions." Ms. Hinsey, you don't no [!@#$%^&*]!

She's got things right with Y&R. Pretty much everything there is a hit right now.

Y&R was good for awhile, but the way they have dumbed down so many of the strong females makes me mad......Katherine, Jill, and Vicky all used to be women with spunk and more backbone than most of the men on the show; now they all seem to be blind to what is going on around them and just do what others suggest they do......

I am SO tired of the Skin Cream Killer, she makes the show hard to watch; and if she doesn't get caught soon I may quit watching for awhile.....I want to know what's up with Brad's past, but the SCR just ruins any show she is in........Why won't they expose her for the SCK she really is? Make her go away!!!!

SCK is ruining the characters of both Michael and Kevin, she deserves to be the bag lady begging for money that she envisioned herself as a few weeks ago........Send her to the Women's Prison PRONTO, and bring John home!

Carolyn Hinsey will never be happy until Maurice Benard gives her the lovin' she so desperately craves from him.

But she IS right about Y&R, Nick/Phyllis and HappyFunVictor! are hits.

Carolyn Hinsey will never be happy until Maurice Benard gives her the lovin' she so desperately craves from him.

So true. That woman has a serious hard-on for him. Too bad...I can think of better soap studs to get hot and bothered over.